Donovan Mitchell isn’t backing off his Cleveland commitment, even if the Cavaliers’ early-season start hasn’t exactly matched the size of the bet he made.
Mitchell signed a four-year, $273 million extension in July with a player option for 2030-31, locking himself in through 2031 after the Cavaliers’ first conference finals appearance in his career. He did it on the first day he was eligible, passing on the chance to wait until next summer for an extra $80 million.
The timing mattered, but so did the message. Mitchell said the move came from belief in what Cleveland is building, even with the team sitting at 6-7.
“In the moment it kind of leaves a sour taste in your mouth,” Mitchell said. “But as you sit ... you have to realize, OK, you’ve done something you haven’t done before.
OK. Now that’s great, but I wouldn’t call it an accomplishment.”
Cleveland’s postseason run last spring gave Mitchell his deepest trip yet, but it ended in a sweep at the hands of the New York Knicks in the Eastern Conference Finals. Before that, the Cavaliers had survived a seven-game first-round series against the Toronto Raptors and then won Game 7 on the road against the top-seeded Detroit Pistons.
The offseason brought more changes around Mitchell. James chose the Philadelphia 76ers instead of returning to Cleveland, while the Cavaliers re-signed former MVP James Harden, 37, to a three-year deal after acquiring him at the February trade deadline. Cleveland also kept forward Evan Mobley and added wing Peyton Watson as a fifth starter.
Coach Kenny Atkinson said Mitchell’s extension mattered inside the building.
“When doubt lingers in an organization, it’s not great,” Atkinson said. “Everybody’s just unsettled. So, the fact that Don locked it up, that was huge.”
Still, the on-court picture has been uneven. Through the first 12 games, Cleveland’s starting lineup has posted a minus-12.0 net rating, and Mitchell’s individual production has been solid if not spectacular: 22.8 points, 5.5 assists and 5.0 rebounds per game while shooting 37.6% from 3-point range.
Mitchell also had to laugh off the outside noise this summer. At his basketball camp in Greenwich, Connecticut, he heard jokes about a comment Atkinson made during the playoff series. Before Game 4, Atkinson said the Cavaliers were “analytically winning the series,” pointing to expected shot metrics.
“You get swept and you look the way we looked, there’s criticism and the jokes come with it,” Mitchell said. “We all laugh at it, but at the same time it’s like, all right, bet. Time’s going to come.”
An Eastern Conference executive wasn’t ready to buy into Cleveland either, saying, “All their questions will be answered in the playoffs,” and adding, “But it feels like they have the same issues that have plagued them for years.”
For now, the Cavaliers are 6-7 after Friday’s loss to the Miami Heat, and the early results haven’t done much to quiet the skepticism. Mitchell, though, has already made his choice.
In Other News...
Jaylon Tyson Still Has A Chance To Change Clevelands Bench Rotation
Jaylon Tysons first month has been a reminder that even a promising young wing can find his path to steady minutes blocked by health and by the numbers game. He has appeared in six of Clevelands 12 games, logging 21.1 minutes and seven points per night, but his shooting has not matched last seasons efficiency as he works through a neck issue and an ankle problem that have interrupted both his rhythm and his availability.
For a Cavaliers team trying to sort out its bench on the fly, Tysons situation is still one worth watching because the door is not closed on him reclaiming a useful role. Cleveland has been patient with his recovery and development, but the competition for wing minutes is real, and Tyson will have to show he can stay on the floor and rediscover the consistency that made him part of the conversation in the first place. [Read more 🡒]
Cavaliers Suddenly Have A Sam Merrill Decision Fans Didn't Expect
Sam Merrill has quietly become one of the more useful two-way pieces on Clevelands roster, which is why his current situation feels a little more complicated than anyone expected. The wing has carved out a role with his shooting and steadiness, but an elbow injury has knocked his rhythm off enough that the Cavaliers are now watching closely as he works through it.
The bigger issue is that Cleveland has depth on the wing, so the front office has to weigh whether Merrills long-term value to the rotation is enough to keep him in place or whether he becomes part of a trade conversation. Other teams have already shown interest, and the Nuggets are among the clubs linked to him, which only adds to the intrigue as the Cavs wait to see whether his play rebounds once he gets healthier. [Read more 🡒]
Charles Barkley Is Missing What Makes These Cavs So Complicated
A 6-6 start can still leave a team in a gray area, and that is where the Cavaliers sit right now. They are not playing like a club in crisis, but they are also not the same group that defined the last stretch of their recent run, with the roster now carrying a very different look and a lot more moving parts than the outside conversation sometimes acknowledges.
Kenny Atkinson is part of that complexity, too, after being named the 2025 NBA Coach of the Year, but the bigger picture is that Cleveland is trying to sort out a new identity while leaning on a younger bench and a reshaped rotation. Meleek Thomas and Tyrese Proctor are part of that next wave, and their development matters because the Cavs are no longer just trying to manage expectations around a veteran core - they are trying to figure out what comes next. [Read more 🡒]