The Cavs can live with stretches of shaky offense. They can even survive a few defensive lapses. What they can’t keep surviving is the same old damage on the glass.
Against the Knicks, Cleveland defended well enough in spurts, but it never mattered once New York started stacking extra possessions. The Knicks hauled in 16 offensive rebounds and converted them into 26 second-chance points in a 109-97 win, wiping out whatever defensive work the Cavs had managed to build.
That’s the part that has stuck with the Wine and Gold Talk podcast, and it goes beyond one ugly night. The rebounding issue has become a pattern, and Cavs beat reporter Chris Fedor pointed directly at the way Kenny Atkinson is constructing his lineups.
“I think it’s a personnel thing,” Fedor said. “And I think part of it is if Kenny is going to continue to say rebounding is an issue.
One of the answers is stop playing three guard lineups. Stop playing three small guys who are not good rebounders at the same time.”
The Knicks game backed that up in plain numbers. Five New York players finished with at least six rebounds, including Jalen Brunson with six. Tyler Kolek added four rebounds in 14 minutes.
Atkinson’s postgame message was blunt, and it didn’t hide who needed to hear it.
“We’ve got to find a way to rebound better,” Cavs head coach Kenny Atkinson said postgame. “Sure, they’ve got size and, sure, they’ve got talented guys.
But, they’ve got Kolek and those guys in there, Brunson. Those guys are going in there and getting rebounds. ...
We have to rebound better collectively. There’s no one pointing the finger, this guy’s got to do it or this guy.
Collectively, we’ve just got to be better.”
That was a direct shot at Donovan Mitchell and James Harden, who combined for just six rebounds.
Podcast host Ethan Sands added another wrinkle: Cleveland’s guards aren’t just small, they’re crashing the wrong way. According to Sands, Peyton Watson said after the game that the Cavs’ guards are diving too far into the paint when they go after misses, leaving themselves out of position for the long rebounds that come off 3-point attempts.
“I think that we’re running into the paint a lot to go and rebound when we should be rebounding the elbows, especially given the shot quality,” Watson said. “So I think that there’s a strategic thing to that, but it’s also just willpower, at the end of the day.
Who wants it more and who’s going to go and make those plays? And I think that we didn’t make enough of those plays tonight.”
There is at least one Cleveland player who has shown he can help in that area. Mario Hezonja, who brings size, strength and physicality, has been one of the team’s better rebounders to start the season. He grabbed five boards against the Knicks despite struggling on offense.
Fedor’s point was simple: the answer may already be on the roster, if Atkinson is willing to use it more often.
The contrast with New York is hard to ignore. Karl-Anthony Towns gives the Knicks a gritty rebounder in the middle, Josh Hart is one of the league’s best pound-for-pound rebounders, and OG Anunoby and Mikal Bridges add length and physicality on the wing.
Cleveland doesn’t have that kind of rebounding depth across the board, and unless the rotation changes or the roster does, Fedor said Atkinson may be stuck “lamenting this for the entire year.”
For now, the Cavs keep running into the same problem: too many second chances for the other team, too few answers for themselves.
In Other News...
Cavs Quieted Early Doubts With Help From An Unexpected Rotation Boost
The Cavaliers answered an early test against Philadelphia with the kind of effort that usually travels well in the postseason conversation: physical rebounding, connected defense and enough shot-making from Donovan Mitchell to keep control of the game. Cleveland had the edge on the glass and made life difficult for the Sixers for long stretches, a good sign for a team still sorting out how its rotation pieces fit together after a recent trade added another layer to the mix.
Peyton Watson was a big part of that stability, giving Cleveland a useful two-way boost in his latest outing and helping slow down Tyrese Maxey on the perimeter. Mitchell supplied the steadying offense with 23 points, eight assists and seven rebounds, and the Cavaliers got contributions across the lineup to protect the lead and finish the job, even as the bigger question remains how much of this version can hold up once the schedule tightens. [Read more 🡒]
Kenny Atkinson Revisits The Cavs Quote Fans Never Forgot
Kenny Atkinson spent part of the week revisiting a line from the previous Eastern Conference Finals that stuck with fans long after the series ended. The comment came when his team was already down 0-3, and he said the point he was trying to make was about expected wins and the broader context of the question, not a claim that his group had somehow earned a better result.
Atkinson also used the moment to underline something coaches often say but rarely get to explain in detail: analytics matter, but so do mental and physical toughness when the games get tight and the season gets heavy. For Cleveland, it is another reminder that the margins in the postseason are shaped by more than numbers, even if one old quote still has a way of following a coach around. [Read more 🡒]
Cavaliers Just Got A Frustrating Knicks Reminder They Couldn't Ignore
The Cavaliers left Madison Square Garden with a 109-97 loss and a familiar kind of frustration, the sort that can linger because it was built on more than one bad stretch. Donovan Mitchell poured in 37 points, but most of that damage came late, after the game had already tilted the wrong way, and Cleveland spent much of the night trying to dig out of an early hole against a Knicks team that looked more physical from the start.
New Yorks edge was felt in the places Cleveland usually wants to control, with extra possessions and loose balls turning into a steady problem the Cavs never solved. James Harden had a rough night offensively, going 2-for-9 and finishing at minus-23, which only added to the reminder that this matchup can get away from Cleveland quickly when the other team wins the hustle battle and forces the Cavs to chase instead of dictate. [Read more 🡒]