The Cavaliers opened the new season looking like they were ready to bury last spring’s playoff collapse - until the game turned and the same old issues came roaring back.
Cleveland raced to a 29-point lead, piled up a near-perfect first half and had a real chance to spoil LeBron James’ Philadelphia home debut. Instead, the night ended with a 114-106 loss to the 76ers on Thursday, a result that felt uncomfortably familiar to anyone who watched the Cavs blow a 22-point fourth-quarter lead against the Knicks in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference finals last season.
One game in October doesn’t define a season. That much is obvious. But it also doesn’t make what happened any easier to swallow, especially after an offseason full of talk about growth, accountability and being better prepared for those exact moments.
Cleveland came out sharp and in control, leading 35-18 after one quarter and 69-45 at the break. The ball moved, the offense flowed, Jarrett Allen was a factor inside, and Evan Mobley found room to operate. Donovan Mitchell was brilliant early and finished with 32 points on 11-of-19 shooting along with 10 rebounds, looking for long stretches like the best player on the floor.
Then Philadelphia started pushing back, and the Cavs started losing their grip.
The Sixers opened the third quarter with an 11-0 burst, and a lead that had been 29 points shrank to single digits. Cleveland recovered enough to take an eight-point cushion into the fourth, but that edge vanished too. Philadelphia grabbed its first lead at 96-95 with about seven minutes left and never gave it back.
Tyrese Maxey led the Sixers with 32 points. Joel Embiid had 24, and Jaylen Brown added 17 points and 10 rebounds. As for James Harden, he scored 16, made some shots and also mixed in a few costly turnovers.
There may not be some giant talent gulf between these teams. Brown is still settling into his new situation, Embiid is still very good but not the MVP-level wrecking ball he once was, and LeBron, at 41, is more of a glorified role player than the engine he used to be.
Maxey, though, is the real headache. Through two games, he’s been Philadelphia’s best player, and he was again Thursday.
Still, Cleveland did plenty to help sink itself. Allen finished with 14 points but wasn’t featured enough after halftime.
Mobley had 18, yet again looked like a player who can dominate stretches without always taking over when the game demands it most. Mitchell, after carrying so much of the night, managed only two points in the fourth quarter.
That’s the part that will stick. This team can look overwhelming when Mitchell is rolling, but when opponents force the ball out of his hands, the whole thing can get shaky fast.
I’ve said on television and radio that Mitchell is good enough to help lead a team to a championship. I still believe that. But he needs a true 1A alongside him.
Maybe that’s Mobley. The Cavs believe it can be.
I want to believe it, too. But eventually, potential has to turn into production when the game is on the line.
There were some bright spots. Craig Porter Jr. brought energy.
Mario Hezonja scored 10 and showed signs of becoming a legitimate contributor. Peyton Watson was just OK, though it was his first game with a new team.
Even so, the bigger issue remains impossible to ignore: too often, this team gets rattled when the other side makes a run. Philadelphia turned up the energy and defensive pressure, and the Cavs didn’t respond well enough. Basketball demands adjustments, and Cleveland abandoned the formula that had built a 29-point advantage.
That falls on the players, and eventually it falls on Kenny Atkinson too. I want to believe in him.
I really do. But if these kinds of collapses keep happening, it becomes harder and harder to defend the coach.
Before the game, Mitchell said the team needed to keep things internal and block out the outside noise. That’s smart, because there’s going to be plenty of noise now. Social media will go into overdrive, fans will panic, and some will want major changes before the Cavs even play their home opener Saturday against Brooklyn.
I’m not going that far. It’s too early for that.
But I do feel for the fans. They spent the offseason waiting for a fresh start, only to be handed a painful reminder of how last season ended.
The season is only one game old, and there’s a lot of basketball left. Cleveland will win plenty of games.
Things will shift. They always do in the NBA.
But the questions didn’t go away over the summer, and they’re already back. Can Mobley grow into that second star?
Can Harden be trusted when the pressure spikes? Can Atkinson keep his team composed when a game starts slipping?
Most of all, can the Cavs hold onto what makes them dangerous in the first place?
They don’t have to be perfect for 48 minutes. Nobody does.
Bad possessions happen. Bad quarters happen.
But you can’t build a 29-point lead, play such a strong first half and then spend the rest of the night looking like you’ve forgotten how you got there.
Not after last spring. Not again.
In Other News...
Cavaliers Already Have A Playoff Problem Brewing In The East
The first two nights of the NBA season already offered a reminder that the East may not get any easier for Cleveland. Philadelphia opened with a win over New York behind its new-look roster, Toronto handled Chicago, and Detroit rallied past Boston, all while offseason shakeups have reshaped the conference picture. For the Cavaliers, that means the early scoreboard watching carries real weight, because the teams trending up around them are the same ones that will shape the playoff race later on.
Clevelands path gets difficult fast with several of those threats looming on the schedule, and the mix of fresh star power in Philadelphia, Toronto and Miami has only sharpened the pressure. The Cavs know how tight the margins can be in the East, and the way those clubs have changed this summer suggests the race for seeding could become a problem well before spring. [Read more 🡒]
Peyton Watsons Cavaliers Debut Raised An Early Concern Cleveland Cant Ignore
Peyton Watsons first game in a Cavaliers uniform came with plenty of attention, given the size of Clevelands investment and the expectation that he would fit right into a rotation built to win now. Instead, his debut against the Philadelphia 76ers left an early question hanging over what the Cavaliers are getting back from a multi-team sign-and-trade that brought him to town.
Watson put up eight points along with a few defensive flashes, but the sloppiness was impossible to miss in a loss that saw Cleveland squander a 29-point lead. His minus-19 was the worst on the team, and the turnover count stood out in a game the Cavaliers had every reason to control, which makes the debut feel less like a one-off and more like the first test of how quickly he can settle in. [Read more 🡒]
Ty Jerome Just Gave Cavaliers Fans A Painful Reminder
Ty Jeromes early-season form in Memphis has offered a sharp little reminder of what the Cavaliers let walk out the door. After his season in Cleveland was cut short after 15 games, he has picked up right where he left off, giving the Grizzlies another productive guard and showing the kind of scoring punch and shot-making that can change a second unit in a hurry.
For Cleveland, the sting is less about one big night than the broader comparison to last seasons backup point guard situation, when Lonzo Ball struggled to provide much consistency. Jeromes success makes the decision to move on feel a little harder in hindsight, even if the Cavs had their reasons for not bringing him back, and it leaves plenty of room to wonder how different the guard rotation might look if he were still in the mix. [Read more 🡒]