Cavs Are Still Waiting On Two Key Pieces To Click

The Cavaliers face a pivotal moment as Sam Merrill's health and Peyton Watson's adjustments could make or break their offensive strategy.

The Cavaliers are at a point where two very different needs are tied together: Peyton Watson needs live reps, and Sam Merrill needs to get back on the floor.

That’s because the version of Cleveland’s offense Kenny Atkinson wants to run only really clicks when there’s a shooter like Merrill moving through the chaos. With Max Strus gone via trade, Merrill is now the lone player on the roster built to fill that specific role. He’s not the headline name, but he’s become a central piece in the way this offense is supposed to breathe.

“In Kenny’s ideal world, Sam Merrill and Max Strus are running around the core like a fricking carousel with defenses trying to keep track of them,” said Jimmy Watkins, a cleveland.com columnist, on the Wine and Gold Talk podcast. “They have two guys like that, but he needs at least one to do the stuff to run the stuff that he wants to run and distract defenses with a shooter like that. So Sam Merrill is disproportionately important to this team compared to prior years because he’s kind of the only guy that can do the things that he does.”

Merrill has missed the last six games with a right elbow injury, and according to cleveland.com’s Chris Fedor, he had essentially been playing through it since the beginning of the season.

That absence has made the timing awkward for Watson, who is being worked into the starting lineup while the Cavs try to build something more stable around him. He’s new to the system, new to the role, and playing with stars who already have their own rhythms. On top of that, he’s operating alongside two non-shooting bigs, which only sharpens the need for clean spacing and dependable movement around him.

“He’s a big new piece. He just got a big new contract.

There’s a lot of pressure on him,” Watkins said. “This is a new world for him to navigate.

Just his role and his importance to this team and the teammates that he’s playing with. It’s a new world for everyone around him to try to figure out because they haven’t played with Peyton Watson before.”

For now, the coaching staff is choosing patience over panic. When asked about the starting lineup, Atkinson passed on making a change and pointed to the small sample size, saying it’s too soon to make hard judgments based on the first 15 games.

Watson, in other words, needs more time. He just hasn’t had a clean stretch to collect those reps because of the injury interruptions around him.

There’s also a broader lineup idea Atkinson has been working toward: the three-guard look. Podcast host Ethan Sands said the team entered the season wanting to develop that setup, using Meleek Thomas and Tyrese Proctor as ball-handlers who can absorb pressure and help keep James Harden and Donovan Mitchell from getting worn down the way they were in last year’s postseason.

“The three guard lineups take away the pressure of James Harden and Donovan Mitchell being hounded by opposing defenses,” Sands said.

That concept has real tactical value, but it still needs the right pieces to function. Someone has to keep defenses honest by running off the ball and bending coverage.

Merrill is that player right now. Thomas or Proctor may grow into that job later, but at this stage, Atkinson’s system has one clear answer.

There is at least a bit of optimism before the Memphis game. Both Merrill and Watson are listed as questionable, which suggests a return could be close.

If Merrill’s elbow is finally right and he can handle a full workload, the whole offense can shift. The spacing changes.

The screening actions matter more. Watson gets cleaner chances to work in transition and on cuts.

It doesn’t look like much on the page. On the court, it can change the whole feel of the team.

In Other News...

Cavs Just Bet On A Surging Prospect With Real Stakes Attached

The Cavaliers have added another developmental piece to the mix, signing Zack Austin to a two-way contract after a strong stretch with the Cleveland Charge. Austin, who went undrafted in 2025 after stops at Pittsburgh and High Point, had been turning heads with his production and activity on the defensive end, giving Cleveland a reason to reward the momentum he built in the G League.

To make room, the Cavs waived forward Riley Minix, a move that underscores how real the stakes are for the players on the edge of the roster. Austins rise has been quick, but the bigger question now is whether he can turn that Charge success into something lasting at the NBA level. [Read more 🡒]

Tyrese Proctor Is Giving The Cavaliers A New Rotation Question

Tyrese Proctors emergence has given the Cavaliers something they did not necessarily expect to be sorting through this early: a new rotation puzzle. With Evan Mobley sidelined, Proctor was pushed into a larger role against the Bulls and handled it well, giving Cleveland a useful look at a different lineup combination while helping the team secure the win.

What makes the situation more interesting is that this does not appear to be a one-off. Kenny Atkinson seems open to keeping Proctor on the floor in meaningful minutes even when James Harden is available and doing his part, which adds another layer to how Cleveland can shape its bench and wing groups going forward. For a team still figuring out the best way to balance its pieces, Proctor has at least forced a real conversation. [Read more 🡒]

Cavaliers Just Reopened A Risky Kyrie Irving Debate

Kyrie Irvings return to Cleveland for the 10th anniversary of the Cavaliers 2016 championship brought back plenty of memories, and the reception he got from fans only added to the sense that some old emotions around his time here never really went away. It also reopened a conversation that has lingered in the background for years: whether the Cavaliers could ever make a serious run at bringing Irving back to pair him with Donovan Mitchell.

The idea has obvious appeal on paper, especially for a team still looking to maximize its title window, but it comes with the same complications that have followed Irving for much of his career. He is older now, his injury history is part of the equation, and any deal would likely force Cleveland to part with meaningful assets to make the money and value work. For now, there is no official trade or agreement, just a familiar star, a warm welcome, and a debate the Cavaliers did not exactly ask to reopen. [Read more 🡒]