The Cavaliers’ backcourt is starting to look crowded in a way that forces real decisions.
Early injuries have given Cleveland a chance to test a lot of different combinations, and the depth has shown up. But as players return, the minutes are tightening, and the result is a roster where too many guys are being pushed into spots that aren’t really theirs. That has left the Cavs with a logjam and lineups that are too small.
Donovan Mitchell and James Harden have their places locked in. After that, Meleek Thomas and Tyrese Proctor look like the next guards who should be on the floor every night. Jaylon Tyson has been more of a small forward, and he should still be able to get run there.
That still leaves a crowded mix once Mario Hezonja and Peyton Watson are taking some power forward minutes too. Sam Merrill has been a steady part of the picture for the last few years and has been reliable on both ends. Cleveland went 37-15 with him in the lineup last season, and it would have been hard to imagine him being left out of the rotation entering this year.
Still, the reality is that the Cavaliers may have to choose. The same kind of conversation came up with Kevin Love during the 2023-24 season, when he was let go at the deadline because he didn’t like being removed from JB Bickerstaff’s rotation.
He believed he had more to give. That kind of surprise could happen again if Cleveland has to trim the group.
Merrill is 30 and turns 31 in May, so age is not really the issue. The two clutch free-throw misses didn’t create any new distrust in him from the veterans, either.
But Proctor and Thomas have looked more versatile and tougher for opponents to target. Proctor, the Duke product, turns 23 in April.
Thomas, the former Arkansas Razorback, turned 20 right before the season. That youth could end up carrying real weight in the final call.
Craig Porter Jr. is in a tricky spot too. He brings athleticism and defensive versatility, but his impact drops off when he isn’t playing point guard. There just aren’t enough of those minutes to go around.
Merrill remains one of Kenny Atkinson’s favorites, so a complete benching still seems unlikely. He still gives Cleveland floor spacing and draws charges better than anyone else on the roster.
Even so, it’s hard to argue against giving Thomas and Proctor 20-plus minutes a night based on what they’ve already shown. Mitchell and Harden are still playing in the mid-to-upper 30s, and that number could come down a bit to create more room for the younger guards.
The depth showed up in Cleveland’s win over Dallas, where Tyrese Proctor finished with 24 points, 11 rebounds, 10 assists and 4 3PM. Mario Hezonja added 22 points and 7 rebounds, Meleek Thomas scored 20 points with 3 3PM, Thomas Bryant posted 19 points and 11 rebounds, and Jaylon Tyson chipped in 18 points with 3 3PM.
Maybe Merrill becomes a late first-quarter sub, entering behind one of Tyson or Hezonja and behind Proctor or Thomas, who should be the first two guards off the bench. Depth is a good problem to have, as long as it’s handled the right way.
Cleveland didn’t bring in a huge wave of youth, but the guard play has changed the outlook. Merrill could become a trade chip. Atkinson and GM Koby Altman have some difficult choices ahead, and Craig Porter Jr. could be moved or waived before his January 17th contract guarantee.
The Cavaliers have decisions to make, and the clearest path is to keep Thomas and Proctor in key roles every night the rest of the way. Everyone else will have to fight for what’s left.
In Other News...
Ty Jerome Situation Reminds Cavs Why That Offseason Decision Happened
Ty Jeromes exit from Cleveland still feels like one of those roster decisions that made sense in the moment and only looks clearer with a little distance. After a strong 2024-25 season with the Cavaliers, Jerome moved on in the offseason and landed with the Memphis Grizzlies, where his ability has never really been in question. What has followed him, though, is the same concern that shadowed his time in Cleveland: availability.
The latest reminder came when Jerome was sidelined for Memphis in a recent game against the Cavaliers, another setback in a career that has been interrupted too often by injuries. Analyst Jimmy Watkins has pointed to that history as the central reason Cleveland moved on, and it is easy to see why the front office would be wary of betting on a player whose talent is real but whose body has too often complicated the picture. [Read more 🡒]
Cavaliers Fans Already Have One Big Concern About Peyton Watson
Peyton Watson arrived in Cleveland with the kind of contract that immediately puts a player under a brighter spotlight, and the early returns have given Cavaliers fans plenty to monitor. The sign-and-trade brought him over from Denver on a four-year deal, the sort of investment that comes with clear expectations on both ends of the floor, especially for a team trying to stay in the mix in the East.
Through his first stretch with the Cavaliers, Watsons offense has not looked like the version that helped make him such an appealing target in the first place. His shooting has dipped, even as he has been asked to take more threes, and that gap between price tag and production is already becoming the conversation around him. For Cleveland, the question is less about whether Watson can help than whether his current role and output are going to match what the franchise clearly believes it is paying for. [Read more 🡒]
James Harden Carried The Cavs But One Late Issue Still Lingers
James Harden gave the Cavaliers exactly the kind of jolt they needed in a 128-119 win over the Pacers, pouring in 51 points while adding six rebounds and six assists. He knocked down seven 3-pointers and was flawless at the line, while Donovan Mitchell, Peyton Watson and Mario Hezonja also chipped in as Cleveland dug out of an early hole and steadied itself long enough to stay in front.
The part that lingers is how quickly a comfortable night can tighten again against a team like Indiana, especially after the Pacers found life late and forced Cleveland to answer under pressure. Hardens shot-making carried the night, but the Cavaliers still had to navigate a stretch that reminded everyone how thin the margin can be when the game starts to tilt the other way. [Read more 🡒]
