As Cleveland heads toward the 2026-27 NBA season, one of the quiet but important questions inside the Cavaliers’ building is how much runway there is for their young guards. The roster has already been reshaped after the embarrassing Eastern Conference Finals loss to the New York Knicks, with Donovan Mitchell extended, James Harden re-signed, Mario Hezonja added, Max Strus and Dennis Schroder traded away, and Peyton Watson brought in among other moves.
That leaves Kenny Atkinson and his staff with a rotation puzzle. The starting five looks set: Harden, Mitchell, Watson, Evan Mobley and Jarrett Allen are expected to anchor the group. The real fight is on the bench, where Cleveland appears to have a handful of spots spoken for and only one meaningful opening left for a young combo guard.
Sam Merrill and Jaylon Tyson look positioned for regular minutes. Hezonja should see time on the wing, Craig Porter Jr. is likely to open as the backup point guard, and either Nae’qwan Tomlin, Thomas Bryant or maybe Khalifa Dior will handle backup center duties. Once those roles are accounted for, there may be just one remaining lane for either Tyrese Proctor or Meleek Thomas.
Both have flashed recently. Only one can realistically start the year in the mix.
Proctor’s strongest argument starts with familiarity. He’s entering his second NBA season, and even though his rookie year was limited, those 50 games still matter.
He’s also older than Thomas by a notable margin. Proctor spent three seasons at Duke and will turn 23 at the end of this season, while Thomas just turned 20.
In basketball years, that’s a real head start.
There’s also the point-guard angle. Proctor has experience handling the ball, and while he probably won’t be a true lead guard, he did carry plenty of offensive responsibility at Duke. If Porter Jr. isn’t viewed as part of Cleveland’s long-term answer at the position, Proctor has a chance to carve out value as the backup lead guard and simplify the path to minutes.
Defensively, Proctor has the cleaner resume too. His rookie season didn’t show much on that end, but at Duke he became one of the better wing defenders on the roster thanks to his size and ability to guard 1-3.
Thomas, though, brings a very different kind of pressure. His Summer League run in July was loud enough to force the issue. He led the league in scoring at 27.3 points per game, shot 50 percent from the field and drilled 43.8 percent of his threes.
Those are huge numbers, and they stand out even more when compared with Proctor’s Summer League work from 2025, when he averaged 17.3 points and shot 29.4 percent from deep.
Thomas slid to the second round for reasons that are easy to name: defense, decision-making and shot selection. But the scoring talent is obvious.
He’s already shown he’s a better shooter than Proctor, and his 41.9 percent mark on 197 attempts from three last year at Arkansas backs that up. The jumper clearly travels.
He’s not just a perimeter specialist, either. Thomas graded out around average in the midrange and at the rim, which means he doesn’t carry one glaring hole in his offensive game. Put him on the floor with Merrill, Tyson and Watson, and those wings can stay in cleaner 3-and-D roles while Thomas does more of the shot creation.
Then there’s the age factor. NBA teams obsess over youth, and Thomas fits squarely into that development window.
Cleveland can shape him through most of the years when growth usually happens, from 19 to 22. That makes him the kind of player a team may want to keep molding instead of rushing into a rigid role.
It also creates a natural path for him to begin in the G-League. For Thomas, that could mean reps, touches and a heavier workload.
For Proctor, that route doesn’t make nearly as much sense. He’s at a stage where the Cavaliers may need to find out what they have.
In that sense, this could be now or never.
And that is what this decision really comes down to: how much Cleveland believes in Proctor’s future. If the Cavaliers think he can be part of the rotation for years, he should get the first crack at real minutes.
That doesn’t mean Thomas would be wasting time in the G-League. Quite the opposite. Thirty-five-plus minutes a night there could turn into a better 10 minutes when he gets called up.
But if Cleveland’s view of Proctor has cooled, then the calculus changes. He was drafted 49th in 2025, and the Cavaliers only owe him just over $4.5 million until his club option in 2028. If they decide Thomas is the better long-term bet, they can move on without much pain.
In Other News...
Cavs Have One Two-Way Prospect Worth Watching Closely
The Cavaliers have spent the offseason sorting through the margins of the roster, and their two-way group is part of that picture. Cleveland currently has three players in that category, but Ernest Udeh Jr. is the one drawing the most attention because of his physical tools and the kind of impact he could eventually provide if his game keeps coming along. For a team that has leaned on depth and development, those end-of-roster decisions can matter more than they first appear.
Udehs appeal is tied to the same kind of attributes contenders always seem to value: size, activity and the chance to contribute without needing the ball. The Cavs are not counting on him to be a finished product right away, but there is a path for a player with his profile to become useful in a hurry if the rest of the roster thins out or injuries force the issue. In a system where opportunity often comes unexpectedly, he is the one two-way name worth keeping an eye on. [Read more 🡒]
Cavaliers Still Have The Kind Of Talent That Raises Expectations
Even after the roster shuffle that sent De'Andre Hunter to Sacramento last season, the Cavaliers still have enough juice to show up in the league's spotlight. One of the NBA's top-10 plays for the 2025-26 season included Hunter, who spent 27 games in Cleveland before the trade, crossing over and finishing a dunk against the Bulls in a moment that looked plenty familiar to anyone who watched this group when it had more pieces in place.
The bigger point for Cleveland is what comes next. The Cavs have added Peyton Watson on a four-year contract and still intend to chase a title this season, which keeps the standard high even as the personnel changes around them. Plays like Hunter's are a reminder of the talent that has passed through here, and also of the kind of ceiling the Cavs are trying to keep intact as they move into another year with expectations attached. [Read more 🡒]
Evan Mobley Faces A Bigger Cavs Question Than His Stats Show
Evan Mobley is heading into a pivotal season in Cleveland after another solid all-around campaign, but the conversation around him has shifted well beyond the box score. He averaged 18.2 points, 9.0 rebounds, 3.6 assists and 1.7 blocks last season, yet the most noticeable wrinkle was the dip in his three-point shooting to 29.7 percent, a reminder that his next leap may not come from simply doing more of the same.
For the Cavaliers, the bigger question is how Mobley fits into a frontcourt that now includes wing Peyton Watson and how much responsibility he can shoulder as a high-post facilitator. If he can become more of an offensive hub in that role, it could open up more of Clevelands spacing and give the team a different way to attack when defenses load up elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]