Cavaliers Just Reopened A Risky Kyrie Irving Debate

Could the Cavaliers enhance their roster by reuniting with a proven star like Kyrie Irving, despite the hurdles involved?

Kyrie Irving got a reminder in Cleveland on November 14 that some bridges never fully burn.

When the Mavericks guard returned to Rocket Arena for the Cavaliers’ celebration of the 10th anniversary of the 2016 championship, the response was loud and unmistakable. Fans applauded him, and the tribute to his Game 7 three-pointer against Golden State sent the building into a frenzy. Irving looked moved by it all and thanked Cleveland fans for “sticking it through with me as I was a young person.”

That kind of reception makes it fair to ask a question that would have sounded far-fetched not long ago: should the Cavaliers think about bringing him back if the price is right?

The basketball case is easy to see. Irving next to Donovan Mitchell would give Cleveland one of the league’s most dangerous backcourts, a pairing built on pure shot-making.

Both guards can create offense on their own, crack defenses open and take over when the game tightens. Irving has also shown he can thrive without being the lone centerpiece.

He fit perfectly beside LeBron James during Cleveland’s championship run, then later proved his value as a second star again with Luka Doncic, helping Dallas reach the 2024 NBA Finals before losing to Boston.

That’s why the idea has real bite for Cleveland. With James Harden struggling to find consistency lately, the Cavaliers would have to weigh whether Irving is simply the better offensive option.

Harden is still a strong passer, but Irving brings a different level of scoring punch and self-created offense. If Cleveland could move off Harden’s contract and bring in a player with Irving’s ceiling, that would be hard to ignore.

But this is where the dream gets expensive.

Irving is 34 and coming off a serious knee injury, so durability has to be part of the conversation. His 34-point showing against the Cavaliers on November 14 was a sharp reminder of what he can still do, but it doesn’t erase the risk.

Then there’s the price Dallas would ask for. A straight Harden-for-Irving swap probably wouldn’t be enough, especially with the Mavericks reportedly reluctant to entertain Irving trade offers.

Cleveland might have to attach one of its starting big men to get Dallas to listen. Evan Mobley would be too steep a price, and that should probably shut the door.

Jarrett Allen is a different story. He still gives the Cavaliers real value inside, but if including him with Harden could land Irving, the front office would at least have to consider it.

Even then, the fit wouldn’t be simple. Cleveland would have to figure out the frontcourt gap Allen would leave behind, and the money would need to work under NBA trade rules. Still, championship windows don’t stay open forever.

No one should confuse this with a guaranteed path back to the title. Irving’s age, health and trade cost all matter.

But this also isn’t a nostalgia play for a player with nothing left. Irving can still swing a game, and his ability to work alongside another elite scorer makes him a compelling fit with Mitchell.

Cleveland already knows what that kind of partnership can look like. The city reminded Irving of it just days ago, and he answered by making it clear the feeling was mutual.

In Other News...

Cavs Just Bet On A Surging Prospect With Real Stakes Attached

The Cavaliers have added another developmental piece to the mix, signing Zack Austin to a two-way contract after a strong stretch with the Cleveland Charge. Austin, who went undrafted in 2025 after stops at Pittsburgh and High Point, had been turning heads with his production and activity on the defensive end, giving Cleveland a reason to reward the momentum he built in the G League.

To make room, the Cavs waived forward Riley Minix, a move that underscores how real the stakes are for the players on the edge of the roster. Austins rise has been quick, but the bigger question now is whether he can turn that Charge success into something lasting at the NBA level. [Read more 🡒]

Cavs Are Still Waiting On Two Key Pieces To Click

The Cavaliers are still sorting through a couple of moving parts as they try to settle into a steadier rhythm. Sam Merrill, a rotation piece who had been playing through a right elbow injury since the start of the season, has now missed six games, leaving Cleveland to adjust its backcourt mix while it waits for him to get back to full strength. At the same time, the staff is still working on integrating Peyton Watson into the starting lineup, a process that naturally takes time and depends on having the rest of the group in place around him.

Patience has been part of the message on Watson, with the coaching staff giving him room to develop without forcing the issue. The next checkpoint comes against Memphis, where both Merrill and Watson are listed as questionable. For a Cavs team trying to build consistency, getting those two pieces moving in the same direction would go a long way toward making the rotation feel a little more complete. [Read more 🡒]

Tyrese Proctor Is Giving The Cavaliers A New Rotation Question

Tyrese Proctors emergence has given the Cavaliers something they did not necessarily expect to be sorting through this early: a new rotation puzzle. With Evan Mobley sidelined, Proctor was pushed into a larger role against the Bulls and handled it well, giving Cleveland a useful look at a different lineup combination while helping the team secure the win.

What makes the situation more interesting is that this does not appear to be a one-off. Kenny Atkinson seems open to keeping Proctor on the floor in meaningful minutes even when James Harden is available and doing his part, which adds another layer to how Cleveland can shape its bench and wing groups going forward. For a team still figuring out the best way to balance its pieces, Proctor has at least forced a real conversation. [Read more 🡒]