When Cleveland’s current version of Cavaliers basketball took shape in 2022-23, the identity was obvious from the jump. This was a defense-first team, the kind that made opponents work for every inch.
That season, Cleveland finished No. 1 in defensive rating during the regular season at 109.9. Evan Mobley and Jarrett Allen controlled the paint, while Isaac Okoro, Dean Wade and others made the perimeter miserable for opposing offenses.
But the edge that defined that group has faded little by little. Over the next three seasons, the Cavaliers’ defensive rating slipped from first to seventh, then eighth, then 15th. This year, it has dropped all the way to 22nd.
There are plenty of reasons for that decline, but the biggest issue has been the front office’s failure to replace the defensive pieces it let walk or moved on from.
Okoro and Wade were not fully replaced
Okoro was never a perfect player, and he may not even be a serviceable NBA player. Still, there is a clear link between Cleveland’s defensive slide and the decision to move him in the summer of 2025.
In his final season with the Cavaliers in 2024-25, Cleveland was +5.5 better in net rating with Okoro on the floor than when he sat. The player Cleveland got back for him, Lonzo Ball, did not provide that kind of impact in 2025-26. Last season, the Cavaliers were -4.7 worse with Ball on the floor than off it.
Then Wade left in free agency last summer, signing a four-year deal worth over $38 million with the Philadelphia 76ers. Cleveland tried to answer by bringing in Peyton Watson, but that move has not worked out either.
This season, the Cavaliers are a stunning -16.8 worse in net rating when Watson is on the floor versus when he is off. He has struggled at both ends, and the price of getting him included sending out Max Strus, who had been one of the more positive defenders on the roster over the years.
The draft move that stands out
With money tight, the cleanest way for Cleveland to patch its perimeter defense would have been through the draft.
The Cavaliers held the 29th pick, but sent it to Sacramento in exchange for the 34th pick and a 2032 second-rounder. They then used that 34th pick on Meleek Thomas.
Thomas is not a bad player, at least not yet. Less than a month into his NBA career, he has already flashed as a high-level scoring guard off the bench.
The issue is fit. For this roster, he looks like a luxury, not a need.
Cleveland already has plenty of small to mid-sized guards. Donovan Mitchell and James Harden soak up the most minutes, and the bench group includes Sam Merrill, Tyrese Proctor and even Craig Porter Jr. as real rotation options alongside Thomas.
Proctor’s role was uncertain before the season, especially after Thomas was drafted, but Kenny Atkinson has made a clear push to get him on the floor and has even started him in some games. That only makes Thomas’s place in the mix harder to figure out.
What Cleveland passed on
The player Sacramento took at 29 was Alex Karaban. He has not made much of an impact on what may be the league’s worst roster, but he fits what Cleveland needed.
The Cavaliers do have Mario Hezonja, who has been a solid frontcourt piece, but he is closer to a big than a true wing at this point. Jaylon Tyson has also dealt with injuries through the first month. A bigger wing like Karaban could have filled rotation minutes and at least helped patch the Wade-sized hole.
There is also the possibility that Karaban could grow into a reliable wing over the next decade, which would not be a shock given his time at UConn.
And Karaban was not the only option in that range. Koa Peat went 30th, Trevon Brazile went 35th and is already playing valuable minutes for the Denver Nuggets, and Emanuel Sharp went 45th, among others.
Maybe Cleveland ends up loving Thomas. That is still on the table. But for a team built to win now, passing on a clear defensive need could be the kind of choice that keeps coming back around.
In Other News...
Cavaliers Suddenly Face A Contender Debate They Cant Ignore
The Cavaliers early-season rsum has already shifted from promising to uneasy, and the conversation around them has followed suit. At 4-4 through eight games, Cleveland has spent the first stretch of the schedule trying to prove it belongs in the contender class, only to watch several games slip away after building leads and then letting them get away.
Andy Baileys latest power rankings reflected that wobble, and the timing only adds more intrigue with Philadelphia coming up next. The matchup carries extra weight because LeBron James is now with the 76ers, and the Cavs are still trying to sort out whether this is just an early stumble or the first sign that the gap between good and great is wider than expected. [Read more 🡒]
Cavs Suddenly Face Lineup Uncertainty Against The 76ers
The Cavaliers head into their home matchup with the 76ers carrying a little more uncertainty than usual, with three players on the injury report and several more already unavailable. Kenny Atkinson is left sorting through possible lineup changes before tipoff, a familiar early-season puzzle that can quickly alter rotation plans and the way Cleveland wants to attack a matchup like this.
Jarrett Allen, Peyton Watson and Tyrese Proctor are all in question, while Jaylon Tyson and NaeQwan Tomlin have already been ruled out. Add in the players away on G League assignments, and the Cavs are suddenly thin enough that the final look of the roster could hinge on late clearance decisions rather than any fixed plan. [Read more 🡒]
Cavaliers May Already Be Facing A James Harden Reality Check
The Cavaliers uneven start has already put a brighter light on the James Harden gamble, with Cleveland sitting at 4-4 after a recent loss to the Oklahoma City Thunder. For a team that reshaped its roster to bring Harden in, the early returns have been more sobering than transformative, and the questions around his fit are starting to sound less theoretical and more immediate.
Hardens production has slipped from the level that once made him one of the leagues most reliable engines, with his scoring efficiency and playmaking both trending down from previous seasons. Cleveland knew it was betting on a veteran star to help stabilize the offense, but the early stretch has only sharpened the concern that the version of Harden the Cavaliers are counting on may not be the one they get. [Read more 🡒]