The Cleveland Cavaliers thought they were buying certainty when they sent Darius Garland to the Los Angeles Clippers for James Harden in February. Instead, 10 games into the season, the deal is looking a lot more like a warning sign.
At the time, the move had all the shine of a front-office win. Harden had just finished a strong stretch in Los Angeles, averaging 25.4 points and 8.1 assists before the trade, and Cleveland’s run to the Eastern Conference Finals made the whole thing look even better.
The Cavaliers had swapped out a fringe All-Star for a former MVP who seemed to have found something close to his old form. For a while, that looked like the right gamble.
It doesn’t now.
Through Cleveland’s first 10 games, Harden is putting up 15.7 points and 5.8 assists while shooting 36.6 percent from the field. Garland, meanwhile, is averaging 21.2 points and seven assists for the Clippers, hitting 47.1 percent of his shots and 37.1 percent from deep. That’s a gap of 5.5 points and 1.2 assists per game, and Garland is doing it while shooting more than 10 percentage points better from the floor.
That matters because Cleveland didn’t just move on from any guard. Garland is 26, faster, quicker and still moving toward what should be the prime of his career.
Harden is 37, and the league has a way of reminding even great players that the body doesn’t always keep up with the name on the back of the jersey. Garland has his issues too, including 5.1 turnovers per game this season, but the overall production is making it harder and harder to argue the Cavaliers improved their backcourt.
The contrast gets even sharper when you look at Harden’s playoff run. Cleveland had every reason to believe the trade was paying off after reaching the conference finals, but the postseason numbers tell a more complicated story. Harden averaged 19.2 points and 5.5 assists over 18 playoff games, with 41 percent shooting overall and 29.9 percent from three.
Against the New York Knicks, things got worse. In Cleveland’s four-game elimination, Harden averaged 16 points and three assists while shooting 38.9 percent from the field and 17.9 percent from three.
Those numbers didn’t exactly scream superstar rescue mission. They looked more like the warning lights Cleveland chose not to stare at too closely.
That’s the real sting here: the Cavaliers already had a point guard who could grow alongside Donovan Mitchell. Garland wasn’t perfect, and the concerns about his defense and playoff performance were real.
But he was also a two-time All-Star who hadn’t reached his ceiling yet. Cleveland gave up that runway for a player whose best years were always going to be behind him sooner rather than later.
It’s easy to imagine what this season might have looked like with Garland and Mitchell still sharing the backcourt. Cleveland would have had two dynamic scorers, with Garland’s pace and playmaking working alongside Mitchell’s ability to take over games. That wouldn’t have guaranteed a title answer, but it would have meant keeping the more productive guard and the one with more years left.
Instead, the Cavaliers bet on Harden’s past and paid with Garland’s future. Ten games into the season, with Cleveland sitting at 5-5 and Harden struggling to score efficiently, the trade looks less like a bold upgrade and more like a costly mistake.
In Other News...
Cavs May Not Be Done Turning To The Charge This Season
The Cavaliers have already dipped into their two-way pipeline this season, leaning on Tristan Enaruna and then bringing back Riley Minix when Enaruna went down. Minixs return gave Cleveland another look at how much value can come from the G League side of the roster, and it kept the Charge in the conversation as more than just a development stop. For a team trying to stay nimble over the long haul, that kind of depth can matter as much as any midseason trade.
With that in mind, there are a few names in Canton worth keeping an eye on as the season moves along. The Cavaliers could again turn to their affiliate if they need another body or want to reward someone who has earned a closer look, and the Charge have multiple players who fit that conversation. The next call-up may not be far away, which is exactly why this part of the roster still feels worth watching. [Read more 🡒]
Cavaliers Core Just Raised The Pressure On Clevelands Finals Window
The Cavaliers have built a roster that looks expensive now and only gets pricier from here, with Donovan Mitchell, James Harden, Evan Mobley, Peyton Watson and Jarrett Allen set to eat up a major share of the cap over the next three seasons. For a team trying to stay in the title mix, that kind of financial commitment changes the conversation quickly. It is no longer just about talent on paper, but about making sure the current core turns into something that can actually get through the East and into the NBA Finals.
Cleveland still has some room to maneuver, but not much, and the clock is already ticking on the window this group is supposed to justify. The front office has assembled a high-cost core with the expectation that it can contend right away, and the pressure only grows as future contract decisions come into view. If the Cavaliers are going to keep this group together and keep adding around it, the payoff has to come sooner rather than later. [Read more 🡒]
Jarrett Allen Gives Cavs A Needed Boost At The Right Time
The Cavaliers are getting a timely lift as they head into their matchup with the Charlotte Hornets, with Jarrett Allen set to be available after sitting out the past two games. His return gives Cleveland a needed boost in the middle, where his size and presence can change the tone of a game and add some stability to a rotation that has been working through early-season unevenness.
For a team trying to get back above water and move past a 5-5 start, having Allen back in the lineup matters beyond just one night. Cleveland has been looking for a win that can help steady things, and getting a key interior piece back against Charlotte gives the Cavaliers a better chance to do it while also deepening the frontcourt options at a useful moment. [Read more 🡒]