The biggest unanswered question from Cleveland’s season-ending loss wasn’t about the bats or the bullpen order. It was about Tanner Bibee, the Guardians’ Opening Day starter and their workload leader during the regular season, who never got onto the mound in the American League Championship Series against the Tampa Bay Rays.
That absence was even more noticeable in Game 6, when Cleveland used eight pitchers in a 7-3 loss that brought the season to a close. MLB Network’s Chris Rose called Bibee’s lack of work one of the series’ great mysteries, and Stephen Vogt addressed it directly after the game.
“Had we advanced the usage could have looked a lot different…. We wanted Tanner to pitch, the spot never presented itself,” Vogt said.
Vogt said the plan was to keep Bibee available for a game that might stretch into extra innings, where he could provide length out of the bullpen. That kind of spot never came.
None of the six games in the series went beyond nine innings, so Cleveland never had to tap into that specific option. Vogt also said Bibee’s usage would have likely changed had the Guardians reached the World Series, and he described the situation as unfortunate.
The explanation helps clear up a decision that left a lot of fans scratching their heads. Bibee appeared in just one postseason game, when he came out of the bullpen in Game 4 of the division series against the White Sox. He walked two of the three batters he faced, both runners scored, and he did not pitch again over the final eight games of Cleveland’s playoff run.
Meanwhile, the Guardians leaned hard on other arms. Shawn Armstrong started Game 6 after pitching on each of the previous two days, making him the first pitcher in postseason history to do that.
Matt Festa appeared in two ALCS games, including Game 4, when Yandy Díaz took him deep for a two-run homer in his first postseason outing. Cade Smith and Hunter Gaddis, both of whom had been excellent for most of October, each surrendered two-run homers late in Game 6.
There were reasons for Cleveland to be careful with Bibee. He stumbled through September with a 7.36 ERA across five starts, and his lone October appearance was rough. At the same time, the Guardians were getting useful work from other pitchers, including Foster Griffin, who struck out fifteen batters in 10 1/3 postseason innings, as well as Daniel Espino and Joey Cantillo.
Still, Bibee’s regular season was as strong as anyone in the rotation. He made all 33 starts, logged a team-high 188 innings and finished with nineteen quality starts, the most by a Cleveland pitcher since Shane Bieber in 2022.
Earlier this month, he was also named a Gold Glove finalist, with the winners set to be announced on Nov. 1.
For now, Vogt’s comments make one thing clear: the Guardians were not abandoning Bibee. The matchup simply never created the opening they were waiting for. Now the 27-year-old heads into the offseason looking to put a frustrating finish behind him and reclaim his place in a rotation that should remain one of the team’s biggest strengths next year.
In Other News...
Browns Enter A Stretch That Could Define Their Playoff Push
The Browns are heading into a demanding part of the schedule with a trip to Tennessee that opens three straight road games, a stretch that will say plenty about how real their playoff push is. Cleveland has already stumbled away from home this season, going 1-2 on the road, so this run will test whether the team can clean up those issues fast enough to stay in the thick of the postseason race.
Beyond the immediate task of surviving the road swing, there is also a longer view creeping into the picture. Cleveland will soon have to make quarterback roster decisions for the 2026 season, adding another layer to a stretch that already feels consequential. For a team trying to keep its present season on track while planning for what comes next, the next few weeks may carry more weight than usual. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Rookie Tackle Is Already Easing One Big Cleveland Fear
The Browns have spent plenty of time trying to solve their left tackle problem, so Spencer Fanos early run has offered a welcome bit of stability. The rookie offensive lineman has already started six games and, despite the usual rookie bumps, has looked capable of handling one of the leagues toughest jobs while holding up well in front of Deshaun Watson.
Pro Football Focus has credited Fano with a 69.3 overall grade, and he has allowed 12 pressures across those six games. For a Cleveland team that has been looking for dependable pass protection, that kind of start is encouraging, even if the broader question of how steady the edge of the line will remain is still part of the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Rookie Carson Schwesinger Is Entering A Much Bigger Conversation
Carson Schwesinger keeps stacking up the kind of games that make a rookie look less like a newcomer and more like a centerpiece. Even while dealing with an ankle sprain against Baltimore, the Browns Defensive Rookie of the Year put together 13 tackles and forced a fumble, adding to a stretch that already included a strip-sack in Week 5 and a season total of 56 tackles through six games.
For Cleveland, the bigger picture is becoming hard to ignore. Schwesingers steady impact has pushed him into a conversation that usually belongs to the leagues most disruptive defenders, and the way he has produced so far has prompted comparisons to past Defensive Player of the Year winners. The question now is less about whether he has been one of the Browns best defensive players and more about how far that level of play can take him over the rest of the season. [Read more 🡒]