Kyle McCord’s first NFL start for the Miami Dolphins landed in that middle ground quarterbacks so often find themselves in: not a breakout, not a disaster, just a clear enough look to know the story is far from finished.
McCord finished 17 of 32 for 209 yards with no touchdowns, no interceptions and a 73.6 passer rating. The line was ordinary, but the bigger takeaway was simpler - he didn’t look swallowed by the moment.
That matters. Plenty of quarterbacks have stepped into that spot and played like the stage was too large.
McCord didn’t.
The Dolphins also had a real chance to win, and maybe should have won, but Zane Gonzalez missed three kicks that cost the team seven points in a two-point loss. Even then, it’s fair to ask how much of that outcome would have rested on McCord anyway. Miami got a pick-six from rookie cornerback Chris Johnson, and its first touchdown came on a pass thrown by wide receiver Malik Washington.
McCord had to work through some issues up front, too. The Dolphins were missing their best offensive lineman, Aaron Brewer, and the three passes batted down at the line of scrimmage came when his replacement, Andrew Meyer, gave ground to a defensive lineman. That included the failed fourth-and-17 throw to Kevin Coleman Jr. on Miami’s final drive.
At the same time, this was a favorable setup for a first-time starter. Indianapolis came in as a defense that had just allowed 508 total yards to the Dallas Cowboys the week before, and the Colts were also missing two starting linebackers. Then, in the first half, they lost their two starting cornerbacks - and their two best defensive players - when Sauce Gardner and Charvarius Ward were injured.
So even with Brewer out, McCord had about as good a launch pad as a quarterback could ask for in his first start.
The numbers can be sliced a few ways, and some of them compare favorably to what the Dolphins have gotten from Willis. McCord’s 53.1 percent completion rate topped what Willis has posted in six of his eight starts, though Willis is at 58.2 percent on the season.
McCord’s passer rating didn’t reach Willis’ season mark of 76.1, which includes 130.7 and 92.1 against the Jets and Patriots before dropping to 50.1 against the Lions when he was clearly affected by the groin injury that sent him to injured reserve. McCord’s yardage total was above Willis’ season average of 176.1, though Willis has four games in the 208-to-220-yard range.
There were some analytics that leaned McCord’s way and others that favored Willis. But the clearest thing on tape was that Miami made the job easier for McCord. The Dolphins leaned into a simplified plan, and the screen game worked well.
McCord’s first NFL completion came on a short throw to fullback DJ Herman, who leaked out of the backfield and turned it into a third-and-7 conversion. He also hit a couple of impressive throws, including a sideline shot to Caleb Douglas and a deep middle crosser to Douglas. But he also dealt with drops and with a few plays where his receivers just didn’t separate.
That part of the performance looked a lot like what has dogged Willis all season. The difference is health: McCord was available, while Willis has spent most of the year on the injury report with one issue or another.
McCord will get at least three more starts before Willis is eligible to come back from injured reserve, and the early read is that he can at least keep the offense afloat. That was the baseline he set against the Colts. And because this was only his first NFL appearance, it’s still too soon to say that’s all there is.
In Other News...
Browns Just Earned A Stage That Says Everything About This Start
The Browns Week 12 home date with the Raiders is getting a bigger spotlight, as the NFL has flexed the game into Sunday Night Football. It is the kind of move that usually says as much about a teams relevance as it does about the matchup itself, and Clevelands 6-4 start entering the bye week has clearly put the club back into the national conversation.
For a team that has spent plenty of recent seasons trying to climb back into the leagues upper tier, landing in prime time is another sign that this start has changed the perception around the Browns. The schedule shift also raises the stakes a bit, since the national audience will get a closer look at a team that has shown real promise while still leaving enough questions about how far it can go. [Read more 🡒]
Todd Monkens Challenge May Have Saved Deshaun Watson In Cleveland
Deshaun Watsons early run in Cleveland came with plenty of noise, and not the good kind. After a rough preseason outing and a postgame comment that rubbed fans the wrong way, the boos started to follow him, leaving the Browns with a quarterback situation that felt as fragile as it looked.
Todd Monken handled it by putting the focus back where it belonged, on Watson earning the crowds respect with his play. Since then, the response around the quarterback has improved along with his performances, and that approach has helped steady his place as Clevelands starter when the situation could have gone the other way. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Offense Looks Better But One Doubt Still Lingers
The Browns have spent the 2026 season looking more like the offense Andrew Berry envisioned when he rebuilt the unit in the offseason. Cleveland has climbed in offensive EPA per play, success rate and passing-game explosiveness, and the changes around Deshaun Watson have helped the group play with more stability than it showed in previous years under Todd Monken.
Even with that progress, the offense still does not feel fully finished. The upgraded skill talent and better line play have given the Browns a clearer identity, but the running game remains the piece that has yet to catch up, leaving one lingering question about how complete this attack really is when the games tighten up. [Read more 🡒]
