The Cleveland Browns may already be setting the table for a quarterback switch, and Sunday’s game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers could be the hinge point.
At 0-1 after a rough Week 1 showing, Cleveland heads into Week 2 with Deshaun Watson under the brightest spotlight on the roster. The Browns are set to face Baker Mayfield and Tampa Bay, but the conversation around the team is really about whether Watson can hold onto the starting job. Another uneven outing, and the door appears to be open for Shedeur Sanders to take over before Cleveland’s home opener in Week 3.
That possibility is not just fan chatter. It has been gaining traction through reporting from people who are usually close to what’s happening inside the Browns’ building.
Mary Kay Cabot, a longtime Browns beat writer, put out three separate pieces that all pointed in the same direction. On Friday, she wrote about how Sunday’s start in Tampa Bay could be Watson’s last for Cleveland, while also revisiting the training camp struggles that were easy to overlook until they showed up in Week 1.
On Saturday, she followed with a piece focused on Sanders and the expectation that he should play much better than he did as a rookie when he gets another chance. Then on Sunday morning, she published another story examining what comes next for Watson once Sanders is installed as the starter.
That sequence has fueled the idea that the Browns are quietly preparing everyone for a change.
A Sunday morning report from veteran NFL insider Ian Rapoport added more weight to that view. Rapoport said Cleveland is planning to evaluate its quarterback situation after Sunday’s game.
"If Watson plays well and leads Cleveland to a victory, the Browns have an easy decision. If it does not go well for Watson in a loss, a change could be coming.
The middle ground is the area where it's less clear."
Ian Rapoport
The timing of all this is hard to ignore. When respected reporters start laying out the same possibilities before the game even kicks off, it usually means the conversation is already happening behind the scenes. In this case, that conversation appears to be about whether Cleveland is ready to move on to Sanders as soon as Week 3.
For Browns fans, that would be a welcome turn. The frustration with Watson is already out in the open, and the idea of going back to Cleveland’s home opener at 0-2 with him still under center would not sit well.
That makes Sunday feel like more than just another early-season game. For Watson, it looks like a line in the sand.
In Other News...
Browns Fans Can Already See Where This QB Talk Might Be Going
The latest Browns quarterback chatter is already drifting beyond the usual offseason noise, and it centers on a name that naturally grabs attention in Cleveland: Arch Manning. According to NFL insider Jason La Canfora, an NFL personnel executive says owner Jimmy Haslam wants the Texas quarterback, while Deshaun Watson reportedly wants out, adding another layer to a situation that has been unsettled for a while.
ESPN Clevelands Tony Rizzo also reported that Haslam is pursuing Nick Saban for a non-coaching role that could potentially align with Manning, which only adds to the sense that the Browns long-term direction is being discussed in more than one room. None of it amounts to a confirmed plan to draft Manning or bring in Saban, but the speculation alone is enough to make fans wonder whether the next major Browns move is already taking shape behind the scenes. [Read more 🡒]
Quinshon Judkins Just Made One Browns Concern Even Harder To Ignore
Quinshon Judkins entered the 2025 season with a chance to reset the conversation around Clevelands ground game, especially after the Browns invested in improving the offensive line. Instead, his opener offered more of the same concern from last year, when his rookie rushing production trended the wrong way and the efficiency never quite matched the expectations around him.
The line did its part in Week 1, ranking seventh in run-block win rate, which makes Judkins 2.8 yards per carry harder to brush off as a blocking issue. For a Browns offense that wants stability and balance, the question is getting tougher by the week: whether the problem is the support around him, or whether Cleveland is now looking at a back whose own play is becoming the bigger issue. [Read more 🡒]
Deshaun Watson Is Closing In On A Browns Mark Fans Dread
Deshaun Watsons latest stretch in Cleveland has put an unwelcome number on the board for the Browns. After six straight losses as the teams starting quarterback, he heads into an upcoming matchup with the Buccaneers carrying the kind of momentum no quarterback wants, and the possibility of adding another defeat to a skid that has already lingered longer than anyone around the team would like.
If the streak reaches seven, it would stand as the longest by a Browns quarterback since DeShone Kizers 15-game slide in 2017, a reminder of how quickly quarterback frustration can become part of the franchise backdrop. Watson has stayed publicly upbeat through it, expressing confidence and a determination to keep improving, but the longer the losses pile up, the more attention turns from what he says to what the Browns can actually reverse on the field. [Read more 🡒]