The Browns came into the season with a set of young offensive pieces that looked built to grow together. Instead, Week 1 against Jacksonville showed how much the quarterback spot still drives the whole conversation.
Cleveland’s 34-10 loss to the Jaguars left little to celebrate on offense. The Browns got three points off a 74-yard kickoff return by Raheim Sanders, and their only touchdown didn’t come until just under two minutes remained, with the game already out of reach at 34-3.
That kind of outing only sharpened the question around Deshaun Watson and Shedeur Sanders. The Browns have a new offensive line and a promising collection of pass catchers, including first- and second-round wide receiver additions KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston, along with tight end Harold Fannin Jr., running backs Quinshon Judkins and Dylan Sampson, and wide receiver Isaiah Bond. But talent around the quarterback only matters if the quarterback can actually get it moving.
Right now, Watson is QB1. Still, the bigger issue is whether he’s the best option to help this group develop and produce. Based on what both quarterbacks have shown in recent years, Shedeur Sanders looks like the one more likely to jump-start the Browns’ young weapons.
Sanders has already built a reputation for finding his targets and staying with them once he identifies a dependable playmaker. He did it in college, where he helped Travis Hunter win a Heisman and formed strong connections with LaJohntay Wester, Jimmy Horn Jr., Will Sheppard, and Xavier Weaver.
That carried over when he got his chance with Cleveland. In his rookie season, Sanders took over as the starter in Week 12 of the 2025 season and helped Fannin and Bond post their best stretches of football.
Fannin was already Cleveland’s top weapon, and he put together the best game of his young career in Week 14, catching eight passes for 114 yards and one touchdown against the Tennessee Titans. Before an injury cut his season short, he scored in four of the six games he started with Sanders, and Sanders threw his way an average of 7.3 times per game.
Watson’s usage of Fannin in Week 1 told a much different story. He targeted the tight end just three times, and Fannin finished with two catches for 21 yards. The only comparable stretch with Sanders came in Week 17 against the Pittsburgh Steelers, when Fannin had two receptions for 30 yards and a touchdown, but that came on only 12 snaps before he left with an injury.
Bond’s numbers also point in the same direction. In the first eight games Sanders did not start, Bond had 11 catches for 123 yards. In the seven games Sanders was under center, Bond finished with seven receptions for 215 yards, a stretch that highlighted his deep-threat value.
Bond didn’t record a catch in Week 1, but he was on the field for only seven offensive snaps. The rest of the receiver group didn’t exactly light it up, either.
Boston was targeted four times and caught two passes for 59 yards and a touchdown, though most of that production came on a 46-yard score with under two minutes left. Concepcion was targeted five times and hauled in four catches for 43 yards, while Jerry Jeudy caught two of his four targets for 26 yards.
The offense as a whole was off. But the film, as the source material points out, also showed plenty of chances to involve the pass catchers more often. That’s where the quarterback matters most.
It was only one game, but nothing from Watson in training camp or in his limited recent action suggests a major shift is coming. If the Browns want the best chance to get this group rolling, Shedeur Sanders is the quarterback on the roster who has already shown he can give his pass catchers that opportunity.
In Other News...
Browns Rookie Tackle Faces A Tough Truth After Uneven Debut
Spencer Fanos first game at left tackle for the Browns came with the kind of immediate stress test that can shape how a rookie is viewed around here. Against the Jaguars, he ran into a tough matchup and spent plenty of snaps dealing with pressure, with Deshaun Watsons play style only adding to the challenge. It was the sort of debut that reminded everyone how unforgiving the position can be, especially when a young lineman is being asked to hold up in less-than-ideal circumstances.
The reviews reflected that reality, with analysts offering mixed assessments of how Fano handled the assignment and where the pressures came from. For Cleveland, the bigger question is not whether the debut was uneven but how quickly he can translate a rough start into growth. The Browns do not need perfection from a rookie tackle right away, but they do need signs that he can adapt, clean up the leaks and keep improving as the season unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Deshaun Watson Put Browns Fans Through Another Brutal Spotlight
Deshaun Watsons latest press conference only widened the spotlight on a Browns season that already feels like it is under a microscope. After the loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars, Watson drew criticism from Stephen A. Smith, who took aim at the quarterbacks play and said the focus should be on what happens on the field, not on complaints about media attention.
Watson is still lined up to start Week 2 against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, but the patience around him is not exactly limitless. For Cleveland, the bigger issue is simple: if the performance does not improve quickly, the conversation around Watson is only going to get louder, and the questions about his place as the starter will keep following the Browns everywhere they go. [Read more 🡒]
Josh Allen Is Making An Old Browns Mistake Look Even Worse
Josh Allens fast start to the 2026 season is only adding to the old ache around the Browns quarterback history. Through two games, the Bills star has piled up nine total touchdowns and 582 passing yards, a reminder of how different things might have looked in Cleveland had the draft gone another way back in 2018. Instead, the Browns chose Baker Mayfield, and the franchise has spent years living with the familiar churn that comes from missing on the most important position in the sport.
The latest surge from Allen has also revived a curious little footnote from that draft cycle, when Jenna Jameson reportedly urged the Browns to take him before the selection was made. It is anecdotal, not an official team position, but it fits the broader pattern in Cleveland: the warning signs were there, the debate was real, and the consequences still linger. Every big Allen performance now works like a fresh reminder of how expensive quarterback instability can be when a team gets the decision wrong. [Read more 🡒]