The Browns have bought themselves some breathing room with wins, but the quarterback situation still has a hard deadline attached to it.
Deshaun Watson’s status has shifted as the season has gone on. What started as talk of him being benched by the home opener moved to questions about whether he would even start the next game, then to the idea that his runway had stretched out. Now the picture is simpler: Watson is expected to remain the starting quarterback for the rest of the season unless he gets hurt.
That change in tone comes with Cleveland sitting first in the AFC North after Sunday’s win over the Baltimore Ravens. Winning tends to quiet a lot of noise in the NFL, and the Browns are living proof of that.
Watson’s individual numbers still tell a rough story. ESPN’s Ben Solak pointed out that he is fourth in interception/sack rate per dropback at 11.8%, third worst in explosive pass rate at 9.1%, and second worst in completion percentage over expectation. Solak also noted that the offensive line has not exactly made life easier, with Watson facing the fourth-highest pressure rate among all quarterbacks at 40%, while the rushing attack sits last in the league by success rate at 34.4%.
How much of that pressure is on the line and how much is on Watson for holding the ball is up for debate. What is not really in dispute is that he has played a part in dealing with pressure.
Still, the Browns are not done making quarterback decisions. In fact, another one is about to land on general manager Andrew Berry and head coach Todd Monken.
The club opened the 21-day practice window for Dillon Gabriel on October 6, which means that window closes on October 27. By then, Cleveland has to decide what the quarterback room looks like for the rest of the season.
That gets tricky because Shedeur Sanders and rookie Taylen Green are also on the roster. The Browns have to decide whether it makes sense to carry four quarterbacks, especially with injuries affecting other important spots on the team.
When Gabriel was first activated from injured reserve, Monken was asked about the possibility of keeping four quarterbacks. His answer was simple: he did not have to deal with that question for three weeks.
One option would be to release Green and bring him back to the practice squad if he clears waivers. That would come with the usual risk, but it would also stop the ongoing calls from media members who want the team to dedicate practice time to a “Taylen Green package” meant to surprise defenses.
The Browns could also explore whether another team has interest in Gabriel, who is often viewed as a future reliable backup. So he has that going for him.
Then there is Sanders. He hired an agent last week in what was framed as “nothing to see here, just everyday stuff,” but the move still stands out.
Sanders does not appear likely to play this season, and the Browns are expected to have a different quarterback room in 2027, which raises the question of whether his agent might start looking for a trade or another deal. That becomes even more interesting when you consider that every week seems to bring another team dealing with quarterback issues.
Philadelphia is one of those teams. The Eagles are in a lost season after putting Jalen Hurts on injured reserve for the rest of the year. Berry’s twin brother, Adam, is the assistant general manager there, which at least makes for an easy phone call if both sides want to talk about a move.
For now, though, it’s all just speculation. The Browns have been too busy winning close games to let the quarterback room take over the conversation.
But the deadline is real, and by this time next week, Cleveland will have to make its choice.
In Other News...
Browns Suddenly Have Two Young Players Forcing A Tough Rotation Call
With the Browns sitting at 4-2 and alone atop the AFC North after six weeks, the attention in Cleveland has started to shift from the standings to how the rotation holds up as the season wears on. One of the more interesting questions inside the building now centers on how much more work running back J. K. McLaughlin might earn after making the most of limited carries, especially with head coach Todd Monken weighing the eventual return of Quinshon Judkins and Dylan Sampson.
The same kind of squeeze could be coming in the secondary, where McNeil-Warren has also played his way into the conversation for a larger role. Injuries have opened the door for both players, and their recent performances have made it harder to simply hand those snaps back once the roster gets healthier. Monken has said he is hopeful Judkins and Sampson will return, but Cleveland now has a pair of young players making a strong case that the answer to the rotation question is not as simple as it looked a week ago. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Face One Test That Could Decide Their Playoff Push
At 4-2 and sitting atop the AFC North, Cleveland has put itself in a far better position than many expected, with wins over both the Steelers and Ravens giving the Browns an early edge in the division race. The schedule ahead looks manageable on paper, with most of the remaining opponents carrying losing records, which only sharpens the sense that this is a team with a real chance to stay in the playoff hunt deep into the season.
Still, the path is far from simple for a club that has historically had trouble finishing off divisional sweeps and turning hot starts into postseason security. The Browns only have a couple of games left against teams that present a more obvious challenge in the Giants and Raiders, and if they want to convert this strong opening into a berth, handling the games they are expected to win may end up mattering just as much as the head-to-head battles that have already gone their way. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Suddenly Own The AFC North And The Pressure Is On
The AFC North looks upside down through six weeks, with Cleveland sitting atop the division even while carrying the worst point differential among the four clubs. It is the kind of early-season twist that keeps the standings interesting and the rest of the division close enough to make every snap matter, especially with Baltimore still hanging around the playoff picture and Pittsburgh trying to build on an overtime win despite some uneven play.
Cincinnati, coming out of its bye week, now finds itself in a more difficult spot as it tries to close the gap and steady an offense that has not found an easy rhythm. For Cleveland, the bigger issue is not just holding first place, but proving it can keep it while the pressure ramps up from rivals that have already shown they can stay in the race. [Read more 🡒]