The Browns got a long look at their second unit against Buffalo, and the early read was pretty clear: the depth up front held up, a few defenders kept flashing, and the quarterback situation still looks like the biggest issue on the roster.
Cleveland opened with its second-team offense, with Shedeur Sanders starting after Deshaun Watson opened the first preseason game. Most of the night was backups against backups, but that didn’t make it meaningless. These are the reps that help sort out who stays when the roster gets trimmed from 90 to 53, and who’s out by August 30.
One of the biggest positives came from the offensive line. The Browns rolled out RT Dawand Jones, RG Austin Barber, C Luke Wypler, LG Zak Zinter and LT LT Leveston, with TE Blake Whiteheart in the mix, and that group worked well together.
The best example came on a third-and-15 from Cleveland’s 49-yard line with 7:51 left in the first quarter. Sanders had time forever, the protection held up cleanly, and he found WR Luke Floriea for 16 yards to the Bills’ 25.
It was the kind of snap that showed everything working in sync: the chips, the route, the clear-out and the throw. That drive eventually ended with seven points.
That same theme carried over on the touchdown pass to Floriea later in the first quarter, when Sanders again had all day and no pressure at all.
Jones also continued to look solid. He remains in line to start at either tackle spot if something happens to rookie Spencer Fano at left tackle or Tytus Howard at right tackle. His length showed up the way it’s supposed to - he gets hands on first and keeps driving defenders farther and farther from the pocket.
Barber may have been the most impressive of the group. He did a nice job pulling, and he got out in front of a screen to RB Ahmani Marshall with 4:53 left in the first quarter for an 11-yard gain to Buffalo’s 10. He also missed the tackle on CB Damar Hamlin after the interception, but that’s not exactly his job description.
Zinter, though, had a rougher look on that same screen. He and Barber released their men and got downfield, but while Barber picked up the first defender he saw, Zinter ran ahead without touching anybody.
Defensively, there were a few names that jumped off the page. Mike Hall showed up at left outside defensive end, worked inside against backup OT Jude Bowry and got to Kyle Allen for a nine-yard sack.
S Donovan McMillon was all over the field, finishing second on the team with eight tackles and adding a tackle for loss. He’s battling for that fourth safety job and looked like a player who never took a snap off.
The linebacker group piled up numbers too. Bookie Watson had 10 total tackles, Winston Reid added six, and rookie LB Justin Jefferson was active with four. None of them are starting, but dependable tackling matters on punt coverage and in the depth chart behind the starters.
There were also some clear problems on the back end. CB Tre Avery struggled as a tackler in space, and CB Michael Coats, Jr. made his presence felt with four tackles in two quarters. After Cleveland tied the game in the first quarter, kickoff returner Mecole Hardeman found a crease, but Coats shut it down.
The quarterback issue, though, is still hanging over everything. Sanders looked sharp when the pocket stayed clean, but once pressure arrived, things got messy. His interception came on a ball intended for backup TE Jermain Terry, who was turning to catch it when it hit off his arm and into the defender’s hands.
And while Sanders had time on several snaps - including one where he had 6.2 seconds - that came against Buffalo’s second-string defense. Cleveland’s second-team line clearly had the upper hand against the Bills’ backups, which leaves the real question unanswered: what does Sanders look like against a first-string defense? That still hasn’t been seen this preseason.
Watson, meanwhile, is still the most established of the group, but that’s not saying much. He looked bad against third-stringers, and his press conference only created more questions. The expectation that he could recapture the elite form he once had has faded fast.
Gabriel, according to the current outlook, is likely to be traded before he could be waived.
There are reasons to think the offense can improve. The new receiver twins, the revamped offensive line, Fannin moving up to TE1 and the return of Quinshon Judkins all point in a better direction. But the Browns’ quarterback situation remains the glaring weakness, and that looks like the one thing that could keep the whole thing from coming together.
In Other News...
Browns Preseason Rout Put One Young QB Suddenly In Focus
The Browns preseason trip to Buffalo ended in a 31-7 loss, but the score line did not tell the whole story for Clevelands quarterback room. Shedeur Sanders made the most of his snaps, throwing with enough rhythm to complete a high percentage of his passes and guide a scoring drive, the kind of showing that can shift the conversation even in August.
Deshaun Watsons third-quarter work did not have the same clean look, which only sharpened the contrast on a night when Cleveland still found encouraging signs elsewhere. Mike Hall Jr., Luke Floriea, Donovan McMillon and Kole Wilson also turned in positive moments, but the bigger question now is whether Sanders performance was just a preseason flash or the start of something more interesting for the Browns. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Fans Are Suddenly Split Over Shedeur Sanders Noise
Shedeur Sanders has quickly become one of the more talked-about names around the Browns, and not just because of what he might do on the field. Since Cleveland selected him in last years draft, the quarterback has drawn a growing split between parts of the fan base and the local media, with some supporters pushing back hard against the criticism they feel he is getting.
Todd Monken added another layer to the conversation by saying the Browns will announce their starter soon, with the opener against the Jacksonville Jaguars set for Sept. 13. For now, there has been no official word on any roster move involving Sanders, but the noise around him has only made the quarterback discussion feel more charged as the regular season gets closer. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Edge Rush Suddenly Has A Problem Fans Can't Ignore
The Browns had already spent the offseason trying to stabilize the edge, and then Alex Wrights injury turned a lingering need into a real problem. Wright is expected to miss the season with an Achilles injury, leaving Cleveland to reshuffle a defensive end group that had counted on his development since the team drafted him in 2022. Over 51 games, he had become a familiar part of the rotation, which made the timing especially difficult for a defense still trying to find its best shape.
Derek Barnett is the latest answer, giving Cleveland a veteran presence with nine NFL seasons behind him. It is the kind of move teams make when they need someone who can step in quickly and understand the job without much ramp-up time, and it adds a proven body to a position that suddenly looks thinner than it did a few weeks ago. The bigger question now is how the Browns plan to manage the rest of the edge depth as they wait to see how the rest of the room settles. [Read more 🡒]