Cleveland Browns' general manager Andrew Berry faced a tough choice with linebacker Devin Bush hitting free agency. Bush, who had a standout 2025 season with 125 tackles and two pick-sixes, was a key figure in the Browns' defense. The dilemma was whether to re-sign him, hoping he maintains his peak form, or risk a return to his earlier struggles.
The Chicago Bears simplified the decision by signing Bush to a three-year contract. This left Berry to pivot towards Quincy Williams, a seasoned linebacker with All-Pro credentials who had fallen out of favor with the New York Jets. The Browns are betting on Williams rediscovering his prime performance under the guidance of defensive coordinator Mike Rutenberg, who has a history with Williams from their time with the Jets and Jaguars.
As the first week of free agency wraps up, let's dive into some expert opinions on the Browns' move to sign Williams.
Beacon Journal’s Chris Easterling: B
The Browns recently appointed Mike Rutenberg as their defensive coordinator and soon after, signed Quincy Williams, a familiar face from Rutenberg's tenure with the Jets. Losing Devin Bush to the Bears created a gap in the defense, and Williams is expected to fill that void. His presence not only adds skill but also strengthens the locker room dynamics with Rutenberg.
Pro Football Focus: Below Average
Williams had a stellar 2023 season, boasting an impressive 88.7 PFF coverage grade. However, that was the peak of his performance, as his recent 2025 season saw a significant drop to a 35.2 coverage grade, allowing five touchdowns in coverage. This inconsistency raises concerns about his ability to replicate past success.
The Sporting News: C+
Familiarity seems to be the key to this signing. Williams' first NFL linebacker coach was Mike Rutenberg, now the Browns' defensive coordinator.
Cleveland hopes this connection will help Williams regain his All-Pro form from 2023. While Williams offers solid tackling and versatility, he needs to prove he can consistently deliver like Bush did.
On paper, this may seem like a downgrade, but the cap savings and the potential for "splash plays" make it a calculated risk.
A to Z Sports’ Brandon Little: A-
Under linebackers coach Jason Tarver, the Browns have consistently enjoyed strong linebacker performances. Williams, stepping in as a starter at 29, is expected to continue this trend.
His best season in 2023 saw him rack up 139 tackles, two sacks, and several impactful plays. Despite a dip in 2025, Williams comes at a more affordable price than Bush's $30 million deal with the Bears.
With a strong supporting cast, especially alongside Schwesinger and an elite defensive line, Williams has the potential to thrive.
In summary, the Browns' decision to sign Quincy Williams is a strategic move that hinges on coaching and chemistry. While there are risks involved, the potential upside makes it an intriguing gamble for Cleveland.