The Browns’ quarterback search is still the biggest storyline hanging over their future, but one popular draft site sees Cleveland taking a very different route at the top of the board before eventually circling back to the position later.
In Tank-a-thon’s latest NFL mock draft, three quarterbacks came off the board before the Browns were on the clock, and that opened the door for Jeremiah Smith to land in Cleveland. The site described Smith as “the best receiver prospect in a decade or more,” and pairing him with KC Concepcion, Denzel Boston, Harold Fannin Jr., and Quinshon Judkins would give the Browns a loaded young group of weapons.
That mock sent CJ Carr to the Pittsburgh Steelers with the 10th pick and Darian Mensah to the Minnesota Vikings at 13, leaving the Browns to wait on their quarterback answer.
They did eventually take one, just not until the final pick in Tank-a-thon’s projection. With the extra selection Cleveland received from the Los Angeles Rams in the Myles Garrett trade, the Browns used that pick on Drew Mestemaker out of Oklahoma State.
Mestemaker’s recent production is eye-catching. He threw for over 4,300 yards and 34 touchdowns last year at North Texas before transferring to Oklahoma State for the upcoming season. He followed the head coach who left North Texas to take the Cowboys job.
His route to this point has been unusual. Mestemaker did not begin his preps career at quarterback at Vandegrift High School in Austin, Texas, instead playing defensive back. He then arrived at North Texas as an unheralded walk-on in 2024 and spent much of his first year developing behind the scenes.
For Cleveland, the mock would leave the offense with an intriguing young foundation, headlined by Smith and Mestemaker. But it would also raise the same big question the Browns keep facing: if that’s the sixth quarterback selected in next year’s draft, is it really the answer?
In Other News...
Browns Defensive Tackle Room Faces A Verdict Fans Know Too Well
Training camp is the next checkpoint for a Browns defensive tackle room that looks sturdier on paper than it has in recent seasons, with Mason Graham and Maliek Collins lined up as the likely starters. The rest of the group is where the real evaluation begins, because Cleveland is trying to build more than just a serviceable rotation inside. Kalia Davis, signed this offseason, is part of that effort after being brought in to help fill the void left by Shelby Harris, while Adin Huntington gives the staff another developmental body to work with as the depth chart takes shape.
Mike Hall Jr. is the swing piece in all of it, and the Browns have to sort out whether he can become a meaningful part of the plan or remain more of a name than a factor. If the room stays healthy and the younger pieces settle in, there is a path for this group to look a lot better by 2026 than it does right now. If not, Cleveland may be back in the familiar spot of wondering whether the talent inside ever quite matches the promise. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Fans Face An Uncomfortable Cornerback Question Right Now
Terrion Arnolds sudden availability has created an awkward football conversation around the league, and it lands in Cleveland at a time when the Browns are still sorting through their cornerback and nickel depth under new defensive coordinator Mike Rutenberg. The former Detroit Lions draft pick was waived after his arrest in Florida, then released on bond and cleared to keep working out for NFL teams, a rare setup that leaves clubs weighing talent against everything that comes with it.
Arnold has already been in front of the Houston Texans and has more workouts lined up with the Seattle Seahawks, Indianapolis Colts and New York Jets, which only adds to the sense that a market is forming even before any team publicly shows its hand. For the Browns, the question is less about whether another corner could help than whether this is the kind of situation they are willing to entertain at all, especially with no official interest confirmed and the off-field backdrop still hanging over the players next move. [Read more 🡒]