The Browns have spent plenty of seasons with the backup quarterback becoming the loudest name in the building. This year is different.
Cleveland is 6-4, in playoff position if the season ended today, and Deshaun Watson has given the offense some real life with three straight 300-yard games. Against a strong Houston Texans defense, the unit looked like it had found its rhythm.
That reality has changed the conversation around Shedeur Sanders, even if Watson has the job locked down for now. Todd Monken picked Watson as the starter after an offseason competition with Sanders, saying Watson gave the Browns the best chance to win. That call drew plenty of frustration from outside the locker room, especially with Watson’s preseason showing on and off the field.
Sanders did get his chance in New Orleans, and it was a meaningful one. He made his lone start there and came up just short of another comeback win when the Browns failed on a two-point conversion. His outing looked a lot like Watson’s in terms of production, but the result went in the loss column.
Now Cleveland heads into its bye week with Watson firmly in control of the starting role. Monken said he hasn’t spoken with general manager Andrew Berry about Watson’s future, adding, “they have 7 games left and he’s only worried about walk-through on Wednesday.” Meanwhile, the team chasing the Browns for the final playoff spot just lost its starting quarterback, and Cleveland still has a difficult finish ahead.
Watson’s contract runs out after the season, but the Browns are winning too much to position themselves for a top quarterback in the draft. He’s already won six games for Cleveland, yet his overall play still hasn’t made a clear case for an extension. On top of that, his contract will continue to hit the salary cap for the next two years, which makes the need for a quarterback on a rookie deal even more obvious.
That’s where Sanders starts to look like the cleanest path forward. He’ll be on his rookie contract for the next two years while Watson’s cap hit remains in place, and he’ll also get a full year to learn under Monken. That matters, especially with Monken hired in part because of his belief that he could get production out of the quarterback room.
So far, Monken has been right. Watson has delivered his best season in a Browns uniform, and Monken’s decision-making has held up at every turn.
He also showed enough trust in Sanders to start him in New Orleans after Watson cleared concussion protocol. The offense looked familiar in structure, and when the Browns needed Sanders most, he answered.
Monken will now have an entire offseason to shape the attack around Sanders’ strengths.
The draft doesn’t offer much help either. If the season ended today, Cleveland would be picking 18th from the Los Angeles Rams and 20th overall. The quarterback class doesn’t appear as deep as it did earlier in the year, and there are several teams in front of the Browns that need a quarterback too.
That makes a mid-round swing feel less appealing, especially with three quarterbacks already on rookie deals. Free agency doesn’t look much better.
Kyler Murray would be the best option, but he would not cost much, and his tenure with the Minnesota Vikings was not as fruitful as hoped. Kirk Cousins is also available, but he wouldn’t be a long-term answer.
For now, the season belongs to Watson. But if Cleveland is looking beyond this year, Sanders may be the best answer it has. He showed enough in his lone start to keep that door open, and his fifth-round rookie contract gives the Browns a team-friendly option as they prepare to start extending their young talent after next season.
In Other News...
Browns Just Landed In Primetime With One Awkward Debate Already Brewing
The Browns are heading back into a primetime spotlight after the NFL flexed their Week 12 matchup against the Raiders into Sunday Night Football. The move pushed the Chargers-Patriots game out of the marquee slot and gives Cleveland a national stage at a point in the season when every late-game detail tends to get magnified.
It is also the kind of scheduling change that invites an immediate conversation about why the league made it. New Englands recent play and the injury to Drake Maye were part of the equation, and that leaves Cleveland in a game that now carries a little more visibility than it did a day ago. For a Browns team trying to keep its footing, the extra attention is welcome, but it comes with the usual primetime baggage. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Bye Week Could Bring A Defensive Move Fans Have Wanted
The Browns stood pat at the trade deadline, a sign they were not willing to pay for help unless the value made sense. Instead, the front office appears to be looking ahead, with the bye week offering a quieter window to explore ways to add to a defense that could use more punch up front.
One avenue worth watching is free agency, where Cleveland has been linked to several familiar names who could fit what it needs on the defensive line and beyond. Matt Milano, Larry Ogunjobi and Haason Reddick are among the options being discussed, and the next move may say as much about the Browns long-term planning as it does about the immediate push for the stretch run. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Just Got A Huge Break In The AFC Playoff Race
Drake Mayes ankle injury in Week 10 has quickly changed the look of the AFC playoff race, and the ripple effect reaches all the way to Cleveland. The Patriots quarterback is expected to miss an indefinite stretch, possibly the rest of the regular season, after an injury that has New England worried about a fracture and left him in Germany for further testing.
For the Browns, the timing could hardly be better. A Patriots team that had been hanging around the postseason picture suddenly looks far less threatening, and Clevelands path to a playoff spot has opened up in a meaningful way. It is the kind of break teams around the fringe of the bracket spend months waiting for, and the Browns now find themselves in the position of benefiting from it. [Read more 🡒]
