The Browns made the expected roster moves after last week’s first round of cuts, but one decision stood out for all the wrong reasons: bringing in Noah Igbinoghene at the expense of Michael Coats Jr.
That swap is hard to square. Coats Jr. was one of the bright spots of camp and the preseason, yet Cleveland chose to push him toward the practice squad for a veteran corner who has never really delivered much at the NFL level. For a team that’s young and rebuilding, it feels like the wrong kind of bet.
Cleveland is at the point where leaning into youth should make sense. The Browns can chase small upgrades with veteran free agents here and there, but the bigger question is what that actually accomplishes. Igbinoghene doesn’t look like someone who changes the ceiling much, and it’s difficult to imagine him even lasting the full season on the active roster, let alone becoming a longer-term piece.
Igbinoghene entered the league as a first-round pick by the Miami Dolphins in 2020, but the promise never turned into consistent production. Miami moved on after three uneven seasons, shipping him to the Dallas Cowboys for Kelvin Joseph. In Dallas, he was inactive for 12 games and mostly showed up on special teams.
The last two seasons have been with the Washington Commanders, and the results haven’t shifted the conversation. Over his six-year career, he has never posted a Pro Football Focus grade above 55.6, which came in 2025.
He has also allowed passer ratings above 93.0 in five of his six seasons, with 2022 being the lone exception at 77.1. Even then, the Dolphins still gave up on him after that year.
This isn’t a case of Cleveland adding some rare athletic outlier who demands a second look. Igbinoghene is a solid athlete, not a freak, and his Relative Athletic Score of 8.04 ranks 498th out of 3,072 cornerback prospects since 1987. He should help on special teams, where he already has 600 snaps of experience, but that’s a tough sell when the cost is moving on from a younger player with more upside.
And the age gap doesn’t really help the logic. Igbinoghene is 26, while Coats Jr. is 25, only 19 months younger. That only underscores how unusual this choice looks, especially for Andrew Berry.
Coats Jr. had earned attention the hard way. In limited preseason work against the Chicago Bears and Buffalo Bills, he posted eye-opening numbers, including an 83.7 PFF grade that ranked second among Browns defenders.
He also allowed a stunning 2.8 passer rating in his coverage area. Fans were ready to see whether that carried into real games, but for now, they’ll have to wait.
In Other News...
Browns QB Pressure Is Building Faster Than Fans Expected
With Week 1 approaching, the Browns quarterback conversation is already drifting well beyond the usual backup chatter. Mary Kay Cabot of Cleveland.com has been weighing the possibilities behind Deshaun Watson, including rookie Taylen Green as a candidate for QB2 and the chance that Shedeur Sanders could wind up inactive when the season opens.
Watson is still the starter, but the early part of the schedule is going to shape how long that remains unquestioned. The larger intrigue is what happens if the offense stumbles out of the gate, because Cabots reporting suggests Sanders could become part of the mix sooner rather than later if Watson does not deliver early. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Just Reopened A Backup QB Battle Behind Deshaun Watson
With the Browns working through the final stretch before Week 1, Todd Monken left the door open to a backup quarterback competition behind Deshaun Watson. The roster already has four quarterbacks on it, with rookie Taylen Green now in the conversation alongside Shedeur Sanders, while Dillon Gabriel is on injured reserve and not part of the immediate mix. Watson is coming back after multiple injuries, which has made the depth chart behind him a topic worth watching.
Monken said it is possible Cleveland could activate three quarterbacks on game day, though he stopped short of saying that will happen. That leaves the Browns with a little more uncertainty than teams usually want heading into the opener, especially with two young passers trying to carve out a role behind a starter still proving he can stay on the field. For now, the backup job remains unsettled, and the next few practices will matter for anyone hoping to dress on Sunday. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Have 3 Defensive Starters Berry Should Lock In Now
The Browns have already done some of their important defensive housekeeping by locking up cornerback Denzel Ward and safety Grant Delpit, but the work in the secondary and along the front is far from finished. With 17 players scheduled to hit unrestricted free agency after the season, Cleveland is staring at another round of roster decisions, and the defense again figures to be at the center of it. The good news for the Browns is that they do have cap space and enough depth at these spots to give themselves some breathing room.
Among the names worth watching are Maliek Collins, Ronnie Hickman and Isaiah McGuire, three starters whose futures could soon come into focus. Cleveland does not need to rush every decision, but the front office has the flexibility to start getting ahead of the market now rather than waiting until the offseason gets crowded. For a team trying to keep its defensive core intact, these are the kinds of extensions that can shape the next phase of the roster. [Read more 🡒]