The Browns have spent the offseason adding bodies and making noise, but no move has drawn more heat than the one that brought Zion Johnson to Cleveland.
That reaction has been loud, and it’s easy to see why. Johnson’s three-year, $49.5 million deal with over $32 million in guarantees stands out in a hurry, especially when you line it up against the rest of the Browns’ additions. Aside from Tytus Howard, who came over in a trade, Johnson is set to make more than any other Cleveland acquisition over the life of his contract by a wide margin.
That price tag has made him a favorite target for criticism. Johnson didn’t exactly leave Los Angeles with a reputation as a dominant force, and if he had fully lived up to being the No. 17 overall pick, the Chargers probably would not have let him reach free agency in the first place.
Still, the Browns didn’t make him a centerpiece of their offseason just to invite national ridicule. There are real reasons they moved quickly to land him, and they start with what Cleveland was dealing with up front last season.
The Browns’ offensive line never had a chance to settle. Last summer, the expectation was that Dawand Jones, Joel Bitonio, Ethan Pocic, Wyatt Teller, and Jack Conklin would form a veteran-heavy starting group.
Instead, injuries wrecked the plan almost immediately. That unit played together for only 20 snaps, and the run ended in Week 1 after Conklin suffered a freak eye injury.
Jones then went down for the season in Week 3. In all, that group combined for just 54 starts, or 63.5 percent of the season’s total, and no lineman outside of Bitonio started more than 13 games.
Against that backdrop, Johnson’s availability jumps off the page. While he bounced around the Chargers’ line, he was rarely out of the lineup for Justin Herbert.
Pro Football Focus says he played more than 1,000 offensive snaps in each of his four seasons in Los Angeles, and he appeared in 69 of a possible 71 games, playoffs included. He started 68 of those contests.
That kind of reliability matters after a year when Cleveland’s line kept breaking apart in real time.
There’s also the run game, where Johnson took a real step forward under Jim Harbaugh. Herbert took plenty of punishment last season, and Johnson was part of that interior group, but his work as a run blocker improved.
ESPN analytics had him second among all NFL run-blockers with a 79.3-percent win rate in 2025. That fits what the Browns want to do with Todd Monken calling plays, especially with Monken having run an offense for a Baltimore Ravens team that led the NFL in rush play percentage over the past three seasons.
Then there’s the leadership piece. After signing, Johnson called the Browns a “team on the rise” and said he was excited about the chance to work with young running back Quinshon Judkins. Cleveland has embraced its youth movement, and players like Spencer Fano, Austin Barber, and Parker Brailsford need veterans who can show them how to handle the job.
Johnson has been through some adversity in Los Angeles and still started three playoff games. He also comes across as steady and experienced when he speaks. That matters in a room that needs direction as much as talent.
None of this means the contract is beyond criticism. Johnson still has to prove he can hold up in pass protection, especially against stunts and games from defensive linemen. ESPN ranked him as the fifth-worst guard in pass block win rate at 87.4% last season, and that’s the kind of number that keeps the skeptics talking.
But the Browns are betting on more than one season of tape. Johnson is 26, durable, and athletic enough to move and drive smaller defenders in the run game. He’s been projected as the starting left guard since the spring, but Cleveland could flip him to the right side if needed, just as he started his first two NFL seasons at right guard for the Chargers.
Was the deal an overpay on paper? Probably. But the Browns clearly believe they’re paying for fit as much as production, and they’re comfortable doing that when they think a player matches the roster and the culture.
The bigger point is that this judgment is arriving before training camp has even opened. Johnson is walking into a completely different situation in Cleveland, and a lot of the criticism around him is built on old projections that don’t necessarily apply to the 2026 Browns.
In Other News...
Browns May Have Found The O-Line Answer Fans Were Bracing Against
The Browns found a way to address a glaring need up front without paying the kind of premium that usually comes with it. Cleveland signed veteran lineman Elgton Jenkins to a two-year, $24 million deal with $15 million guaranteed after his release from Green Bay, giving the offense a proven, versatile blocker who can help stabilize the interior and compete for a starting job at center or right guard.
For a team that has spent plenty of time searching for answers along the offensive line, the appeal is obvious because the move did not cost draft picks. There is still risk attached, of course, since Jenkins is working back from a serious leg injury, but the Browns now have a veteran option in place and a chance to see whether he can become the kind of fix they were bracing to chase all offseason. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Draft Gamble Suddenly Feels Like The Answer Fans Wanted
The Browns spent the 2026 offseason trying to clean up two of the biggest issues on the roster, reinforcing the offensive line in free agency and then turning to the draft for help at wide receiver. What stood out was the way they attacked the position, using back-to-back picks on KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston, a pair of rookies who have already earned positive reviews coming out of minicamp and given the front office an early reason to feel better about the plan.
Concepcion brings the kind of big-play speed that can change how defenses line up, while Boston offers a more physical, bully-ball presence and a red-zone target the offense has lacked. Early buzz has been strong enough that some around the league are already talking about both as potential rookie award candidates, but the real question for Cleveland is whether this is just a promising spring story or the start of a much longer answer at receiver. [Read more 🡒]
4 Browns Veterans Suddenly Feel Far Less Safe This Summer
The Browns are heading into camp with more than a few jobs still up for grabs, and that uncertainty is spreading to some familiar names. Deshaun Watson, Jones, Tillman and Wypler are all in the mix as Cleveland sorts out its preseason depth chart, with head coach Todd Monken declining to lock in starters before he gets a longer look in training camp and preseason games.
For veterans, that makes this summer feel a lot less comfortable than usual. Jones is trying to hold off the effects of last seasons LCL tear while the Browns have added more competition around him, Tillman has younger receivers pressing for snaps, and Wypler is facing a challenge at center after the team brought in another rookie in April. Even Watsons place remains part of the evaluation, which is a reminder that nothing is being handed out in Cleveland right now. [Read more 🡒]