As the 2026 NFL Draft approaches, the Cleveland Browns find themselves in familiar territory-searching for a quarterback. This year, the challenge is intensified by the apparent gap between Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza, the likely No. 1 pick, and the rest of the quarterback class.
General Manager Andrew Berry and Head Coach Todd Monken face a pivotal decision: stick with their current quarterback lineup, which ranks as the league's worst, or take a chance on a new prospect. Building other areas of the offense this year and waiting until 2027 for a quarterback could be tempting, but it’s a gamble that carries significant risk, particularly for Berry.
Enter Ty Simpson from Alabama. Standing at 6-foot-1 and weighing 211 pounds, Simpson is projected as a second-round pick, sitting at 33rd on the average “Big Board” according to the Mock Draft Database.
Lance Zierlein from NFL.com offers insights into Simpson’s potential. A former five-star recruit, Simpson waited his turn at Alabama and made a mark in his single season as a starter.
His mechanics, particularly footwork and release, provide a solid foundation. While his decision-making is above average, his timing and anticipation need refinement.
Simpson’s arm talent is serviceable, though not standout, but his ability to attack intermediate zones decisively is noteworthy. His mobility adds another dimension, though he must learn to avoid unnecessary sacks.
With only one season as a starter, his development will require patience and a clear plan.
Dave Richard from CBS Sports adds another layer to the analysis, highlighting Simpson’s ability to process defenses and his pro-style arm. Despite his smaller stature, Simpson’s football intelligence and footwork make him an intriguing prospect. His adaptability to any offense is a plus, but teams must weigh his limited experience and develop him without haste.
For the Browns, Simpson presents an interesting fit. His experience against top-tier college competition and his football pedigree-being the son of a head coach-are appealing.
However, his limited playing time in college raises concerns. If the Browns can be patient and develop Simpson under Monken’s guidance, he might just be the answer they’re seeking.
Should the Browns draft a quarterback, the dynamics in Cleveland could shift significantly. Dillon Gabriel might find himself on the way out, and Shedeur Sanders could be exploring new opportunities. The Browns’ decision at the draft will undoubtedly shape their future, and Simpson might be the piece they need to complete their puzzle.