The Browns’ defense entered 2026 with a lot of noise around it. Myles Garrett was shipped to the Los Angeles Rams.
Jim Schwartz was out after not getting the head coaching job. On the surface, that looked like the kind of offseason that could knock a unit off its perch.
Instead, Cleveland is sitting at the bye looking like a defense that has simply reloaded around the edges and kept rolling.
The biggest change, of course, was losing Garrett and Schwartz. In the Garrett trade, the Browns landed defensive end Jared Verse, a 2024 Defensive Rookie of the Year and two-time Pro Bowler who has shown he can be a strong edge rusher in Los Angeles, even if he’s not Garrett. Cleveland also brought in Atlanta Falcons passing game coordinator Mike Rutenberg to run the defense.
That move raised plenty of questions. Would the scheme change?
Would the Browns lose the identity that made them so tough a year ago? The answer so far has been no - at least not in any dramatic way.
Rutenberg, or Rudy, has kept the core of the system intact and made tweaks rather than tearing it down. Schwartz’s defense was never loaded with disguise or heavy coverage variation, and it could get exposed when better offensive minds figured it out.
Rutenberg has adjusted without tossing out the foundation.
The result is a defense that is still very much in the top tier.
At the bye last season, Cleveland ranked 5th in EPA/per play, 3rd in Defensive Success Rate, 15th in Defensive Dropback EPA/per play, 14th in Defensive Dropback Success Rate, 2nd in Defensive Rush EPA/per play and 1st in Defensive Rush Success Rate. This season, the numbers have shifted, but not in a way that screams collapse: 10th in EPA/per play, 8th in Defensive Success Rate, 9th in Defensive Dropback EPA/per play, 4th in Defensive Dropback success rate, 26th in Defensive Rush EPA/per play and 17th in Defensive Rush Success rate.
That’s a dip from elite to merely very good, and for most teams that would be a win.
What stands out most is how little the roster has actually changed beyond the obvious departures. Devin Bush left in free agency, and Quincy Williams came in to replace him.
Martin Emerson also moved on. Outside of those moves, Cleveland brought back most of the group from last season.
And some of the returnees have been major reasons the defense has stayed afloat. Mason Graham has become the best player on the defensive line.
Carson Schwesinger looks like he could be a top 10 linebacker in the league, maybe even top 5. Denzel Ward’s extension made sense then and looks even better now, with Ward playing at a top-5 level and tracking toward All-Pro honors.
Grant Delpit has continued to be one of the more underrated safeties around. Tyson Campbell, acquired in a trade with the Jacksonville Jaguars last season, has settled in well in his second full year with the Browns.
Even after losing Garrett, Cleveland is still top 10 in pressures, which says plenty about the depth and talent up front. Isaiah McGuire, Adin Huntington and Maliek Collins have all helped keep the heat on quarterbacks.
The back end has held up too, and the Browns are still playing man coverage more than anyone else in the league. They’re also doing it well. Rookie safety Emmanuel McNeil-Warren has started to pop, and it feels like only a matter of time before he becomes a full-time starter.
One of the more interesting developments has been at slot corner. That spot was viewed as a weakness before the season, but Myles Harden may have solved it.
Harden has made his presence felt as a blitzer, but his coverage has been the bigger story. He had a rough training camp, then bounced back and has given Cleveland real value.
Opposing teams will keep testing him, but that says as much about Ward and Campbell as it does about Harden.
The one area that still needs work is the run defense.
It’s not a crisis, but it has slipped from last season. Cleveland’s front is quick off the ball, but it doesn’t have much size on the interior, and that has left it vulnerable against trap and wham concepts that can create big gains. Tackling has also been an issue, though some of that comes with the aggressive style the Browns play.
Verse is another player who still has room to grow. He hasn’t produced the kind of season he wanted, and the next step is turning pressures into sacks. Against the Texans last Sunday, he put together one of his best games as a Brown, and Cleveland needs that to become the baseline, not the exception.
So while the Browns no longer have Garrett and are no longer chasing the exact same numbers they posted a year ago, the bigger picture is clear: this is still a top 10 defense. Rutenberg has been an upgrade over Schwartz, the unit has held together better than many expected, and the idea that this group would fall apart has not come close to happening.
In Other News...
Former Browns Preseason Standout Just Landed An Interesting New Opportunity
Luke Florieas path since his Browns preseason stint has taken another turn, and it comes with a fresh chance to keep his pro football career moving. After not landing on Clevelands final roster or practice squad, the former Browns receiver was selected in the ninth round of the United Football League draft by the Columbus Aviators, a new franchise set to begin play in 2026.
For Floriea, it is another opportunity after a previous tryout with the Seattle Seahawks also came and went without a roster spot. The Aviators are still building their identity, and Floriea will be part of that early foundation alongside former Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia, giving him a new stage to try to turn preseason promise into a longer-term role. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Bye Week QB Talk May Have Clarified Clevelands Next Plan
The Browns head into their Week 11 bye at 6-4, and the quarterback conversation around the team has taken on a different tone than it did earlier in the season. Deshaun Watson has been a key part of Clevelands success, while the rest of the room has given the staff plenty to sort through as the season pauses for reflection and planning.
Todd Monken recently laid out how he views the four quarterbacks in the building, and the distinctions were hard to miss. Watson is the veteran leader, Shedeur Sanders is still in the development phase, Dillon Gabriel looks like the dependable backup type, and Taylen Green remains the wild card in the group. Taken together, it sounds like Cleveland is starting to clarify not just who it has, but what each quarterback might mean for the next step. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Rookies Are Fueling This Start And One Pick Stands Out
The Browns have leaned on their 2026 rookie class to help get them to a 6-4 record heading into the bye week, and the group has already become part of the conversation around how this team has steadied itself early. Wide receivers KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston have added to the mix, while safety Emmanuel McNeil-Warren, tackle Spencer Fano and guard Austin Barber have all given Cleveland useful early returns from a class that has been asked to contribute right away.
Among that group, McNeil-Warren has stood out in a way that shows up in the advanced numbers as well as on the field. PFF has him second among Browns rookies with an 86.7 grade, and Fano and Barber have also drawn strong marks, while Boston sits 12th among rookies. For a team heading into its bye with momentum, the early impact from this class is one of the more encouraging signs, even if the full picture of how high it can rise is still coming into focus. [Read more 🡒]
