The Cleveland Browns are facing a pivotal moment with their offensive line, a unit that once anchored their success but now finds itself in need of a major overhaul. The departure of offensive line guru Bill Callahan marked the beginning of a decline, with injuries and age further complicating matters.
This offseason, the Browns are staring down the barrel of a complete rebuild of their offensive line. All five starters are either set to become free agents or are contemplating retirement, leaving the team with a significant challenge and few backup plans. This situation casts a critical spotlight on General Manager Andrew Berry's strategy and decision-making.
Joel Bitonio is weighing retirement, while guard Wyatt Teller has already declared his intention to test free agency. Meanwhile, Ethan Pocic and Cam Robinson are also heading into free agency, and Jack Conklin's restructured contract means he will be a free agent in 2026.
Robinson's exit might be a wise move, given his struggles in pass protection after being a stopgap replacement for the injured Dawand Jones. Conklin, although reliable when healthy, has battled injuries, appearing in just eight games last season. His future with the Browns might be as a rotational player rather than a starter.
Pocic, with a Pro Football Focus grade of 63.8, ranks 20th among centers. While serviceable in the run game, his performance hasn't been standout enough to secure his spot on a potentially revamped line.
The NFL Draft presents opportunities for the Browns to address these gaps. However, the prospect of entering free agency with five linemen simultaneously is daunting, especially with limited trustworthy options on the current roster. Teven Jenkins might be the only player capable of stepping up, but that's far from a sure bet.
Berry's handling of the offensive line situation has been criticized as shortsighted. Relying on Dawand Jones, who has endured three season-ending injuries in as many seasons, as a cornerstone is risky.
Berry's next moves are crucial. A splash in free agency or a strategic trade could stabilize the line and secure his legacy.
On the flip side, banking on rookies to fill these roles could either establish a winning foundation for years to come or lead to his departure if things go awry. The stakes are high, and the decisions made in the coming months will likely define the Browns' future-and Berry's career.