Andrew Berry’s run as Browns general manager has been judged through a harsh lens, and the draft record has taken plenty of the heat. But when you sort through the picks and strip away the noise, a clearer picture starts to emerge: the biggest damage to his draft haul traces back to the Deshaun Watson trade.
Berry arrived in Cleveland at a very different moment for the franchise. Baker Mayfield was still viewed as the answer at quarterback, Kevin Stefanski had just been installed as head coach, and Berry came in with an analytics-heavy background from the Philadelphia Eagles’ front office. He inherited a top-10 pick and seven total selections to work with, but for much of his tenure, the results didn’t look especially kind.
That changes when you zoom in on the last couple of drafts. The Browns have found real value, especially on defense, and the five best Berry picks tell that story.
At No. 5 is Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah, the 2021 second-rounder taken 52nd overall. His neck injury is the brutal footnote here, because before that setback he looked like a future star in Cleveland.
He brought speed, range, coverage instincts, and a violent edge that made him a perfect fit in Jim Schwartz’s defense almost immediately. The pick raised eyebrows at the time because of his size, and some even thought safety might have been a better position for him.
But on the field, he looked like a difference-maker.
No. 4 is Isaiah McGuire, a 2023 fourth-round pick at No. 126 overall who has outplayed the usual expectations for that draft slot. Working opposite Myles Garrett and alongside Alex Wright, McGuire has quietly become an important part of the pass rush.
He has forced four fumbles over the past couple of seasons and has piled up 18 tackles for loss and 17 QB hits in just 12 career starts. He may not be a full-time player, but the Browns have gotten starting-level production from him when he’s on the field.
Grant Delpit lands at No. 3, and his value has been easy to miss because safeties rarely get the spotlight. Drafted in 2020 in the second round at No. 44 overall, Delpit has been a steady force against the run and in coverage against faster receivers.
The source material notes that some might argue the Browns should consider moving on because of his contract situation and the addition of Emmanuel McNeil-Warren, but the bigger point is that Delpit has been the glue in the secondary. The case here is for an extension before training camp, not an exit.
The No. 2 spot goes to Harold Fannin Jr., the 2025 third-round pick at No. 67 overall. Berry took a swing on a playmaking tight end from Bowling Green despite questions about the level of competition, and it paid off immediately.
Fannin was a force in the middle of the field as a rookie, even with one of the league’s worst offenses around him. He’s described here as quarterback-proof, with elite hands, speed, crafty route-running, and the kind of yards-after-catch ability that gives him a chance to grow into a Travis Kelce-, George Kittle-, or Brock Bowers-type pass-catching tight end.
At No. 1 is Carson Schwesinger, the Browns’ 2025 second-round pick at No. 33 overall. He wasn’t even the first defensive player Cleveland selected that year, but he was the most impactful from day one.
The comparison in the source is lofty: the second coming of Luke Kuechly, with Hall of Fame potential. If he stays healthy, he could wear the Browns’ green dot for the next decade.
Even in a class where most teams would hesitate to take a linebacker in the first round, Schwesinger looks like one of the 10 best players from 2025.
That list also shows the broader pattern. Berry has clearly had a strong eye for defensive talent, while the offensive playmaking side of the ledger has been less consistent. And the roughest stretch of all came after the Watson trade, when Cleveland’s draft capital was stripped down and the margin for error disappeared.
That doesn’t absolve Berry of every miss, but it does matter. Not having first- or second-round picks makes it harder for any front office to land elite talent. Berry was part of the Watson trade, but he was also the one left to absorb the fallout.
No one could have known just how badly Watson’s time at the helm would go, and plenty of teams would have made that move at the time. Still, with the benefit of these recent drafts, Berry’s reputation in Cleveland deserves a little more context.
In Other News...
Johnny Manziel Just Dragged Browns Fans Back Into An Ugly Chapter
An old wound in Cleveland got reopened this week when a resurfaced podcast clip put Johnny Manziel back in the middle of a conversation he has never really escaped. The former Browns quarterback, drafted by the team in 2014, had already left behind a troubled pro football career by the time the clip started making the rounds again, but it was enough to pull his name back into the same uneasy orbit that has followed him since his time in Cleveland.
Tony Rizzo, the Cleveland radio host who questioned Manziels feelings toward the Browns on air, became the target of a public back-and-forth after Manziel reacted on social media. The exchange only underscored how much friction still lingers around one of the franchises most painful chapters, with Manziels response briefly turning a forgotten clip into a fresh reminder of how unfinished that story still feels. [Read more 🡒]
Browns Fans Wont Like The Latest Shot At Their Classic Look
A familiar debate around the Browns look resurfaced this week when Sports Illustrateds Mike Kadlick put Cleveland near the bottom of his NFL uniform rankings, slotting the classic brown-and-orange set 27th out of 32 teams. Kadlicks critique centered on the color scheme itself, a reminder that even with the franchise leaning back into its traditional identity, the Browns still draw plenty of outside skepticism about how their uniforms stack up leaguewide.
The ranking also put Cleveland behind its AFC North neighbors, with the Bengals and Ravens landing in the top five while the Browns came out last in the division. For a fan base that takes real pride in the old-school look tied to Paul Browns original vision, the latest shot at the uniforms is the kind of outside opinion that is hard to ignore, even if it doesnt change what the Browns wear on Sundays. [Read more 🡒]