The Bryce Underwood situation has reached the point where the next move feels bigger than the last one. After Michigan head coach Kyle Whittingham turned to Tommy Carr at halftime of the Penn State game, the door started swinging open.
Then Carr backed it up in his second start, leading a 28-21 win over Rutgers while completing 22-of-27 passes for 266 yards and adding 54 rushing yards and a touchdown. On Monday, Whittingham made it official, saying Carr would remain the starter moving forward for the “foreseeable future.”
What that means beyond this season is still up in the air, and it will hinge on how Carr handles the final month. But it is difficult to picture Underwood back in a Michigan uniform next season if Whittingham is still in charge. If Underwood does hit the portal, a few programs stand out as the most interesting landing spots.
Ole Miss makes immediate sense because the Rebels will need a new quarterback after Trinidad Chambliss moves on. Offensive coordinator John David Becker has already done strong work with Chambliss, and the system looks like a cleaner fit for Underwood.
At 6-foot-4 and 230 pounds, with elite arm talent and 4.4/4.5 speed, he has the kind of tools that can pop in the right setup. The Oklahoma game showed what he can do as a runner, and in a read-option system, he could really take off.
The old Urban Meyer style is the kind of environment where he feels built to thrive. His uneven season also makes you wonder how different things might have looked if he had gotten another year with Chip Lindsey.
It is fair to say the changes in offensive systems may have slowed his development more than people realized. In a better fit, Underwood could still become a successful quarterback, and Ole Miss could land a five-star talent at a bargain.
Missouri is another name that jumps out, and this one has a clear connection to Chip Lindsey. The key question is Austin Simmons, who is a senior but would have a fifth year available if he wants it.
Simmons has thrown 16 touchdown passes and only two interceptions this season, and while he has not done much as a runner, pairing Underwood with Lindsey would be intriguing. There is familiarity there, and Lindsey’s best games with Underwood came when Sherrone Moore was not coaching, which seemed to make him less conservative.
Simmons probably returns, but Underwood has already shown he can back up without creating issues. He might not want to sit for a year, though that path worked for Dante Moore, who was trending toward being a top-five pick before his recent injury.
Underwood could take a year to settle in, sharpen the basics, and still have two seasons left to prove himself.
Kentucky also belongs in the conversation. The Wildcats do not have the same NIL resources as some of their SEC peers, but that may not matter here because Underwood has already cashed in on NIL.
At this stage, the priority should be development for the next level. He is not currently on track to be a draftable quarterback, so the trajectory needs to change, and Will Stein could be the guy to help.
Stein worked with Moore last season and helped get him talked about as the potential No. 1 overall pick. Kentucky already has Kenny Minchey playing at a high level, with 16 touchdown passes and just one interception, and he also has another year left.
That could mean Underwood would have to wait. Still, that was the same setup that worked for Moore with the same coach, so if Underwood is willing, it is a strong fit for both sides.
Oregon has already shown it is willing to go after former five-star quarterbacks, so why not make it three? The Ducks landed Dante Moore, and that worked.
Moore is out for the rest of this season, and it is still unclear whether he will return or head to the NFL draft. Dylan Raiola’s hold on the job for next season is also unsettled.
If Moore leaves, Underwood and Raiola could end up competing for the starting role. Underwood is not as polished as a passer, but he is a far more dangerous runner, and that could even create a situation where both are used, at least until Underwood gets more comfortable throwing the ball.
Oregon also just fired its offensive coordinator, so that hire will matter a lot in the quarterback chase. If Moore comes back and Raiola decides to transfer to find a starting job elsewhere, Underwood could literally follow Moore’s path.
USC rounds out the list, and the fit is easy to see. Jayden Maiava is a redshirt senior, so he does not have another year left, and there is no obvious heir apparent waiting behind him.
The Trojans do have talented quarterbacks in the pipeline, but Lincoln Riley has already shown he can get big results out of quarterbacks, including Jalen Hurts. Underwood would need to learn a new system, but Riley has had success with dual-threat quarterbacks and would know how to use Underwood the right way.
In Other News...
Dabo Swinney Had A Brutal Message After Clemson's Latest Collapse
Clemsons latest stumble came with all the familiar warning signs and one new concern attached. The Tigers fell 20-6 to Georgia Tech, a result that stood out not just because of the score but because it was their first loss to a team with a losing record since 2010. The offense never found its footing, finishing with 228 total yards, while the defense spent too much of the afternoon chasing the Yellow Jackets on the ground.
The quarterback situation only made the day harder to sort through. Starter Tait Reynolds left early with a knee injury, forcing backup quarterbacks into action and leaving Clemson to piece together an offense already under pressure from Georgia Techs pass rush, which produced four sacks. On the other side, the Tigers had no answer for the run game, giving up 269 rushing yards and adding another frustrating chapter to a season that keeps finding new ways to go sideways. [Read more 🡒]
Clemsons Georgia Tech Loss Exposed A Much Bigger Problem
Clemsons trip to Georgia Tech turned into another frustrating afternoon, one that started with the loss of starting quarterback Tait Reynolds to an early injury and never really recovered. Senior quarterback Christopher Vizzina stepped in, but the Tigers still managed only six points in a 20-6 defeat, extending a troubling stretch in which the offense has gone two straight weeks without an offensive touchdown.
Even the bright spot came from the kicking game, where Nolan Hauser set a program record for field goals made in a single season. But that milestone only underscored the larger issue facing Clemson right now: the Tigers can lean on special teams for points, yet they are still searching for answers on offense, especially with Reynolds status now hanging over everything that comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Clemsons QB Situation Just Got More Concerning After Vizzinas Exit
Christopher Vizzinas night against Georgia Tech was already shaped by the ankle sprain he carried into the game, but Clemsons quarterback situation took a much more troubling turn late in the loss. Vizzina stayed in and kept battling through the pain, finishing with 133 passing yards, one interception and 18 rushing yards on six carries before the injury picture changed again in a way the Tigers could not afford.
Dabo Swinney said afterward that the issue was more serious than the ankle sprain, and Vizzina was taken to the hospital after suffering a head and neck injury. For Clemson, the concern goes well beyond one rough outing, because Vizzina had already been trying to play through multiple injuries and still gave the Tigers everything he had in a difficult spot. [Read more 🡒]
