The Cincinnati Reds are drifting toward a season nobody in the organization wanted, and that reality could end up forcing Terry Francona into a major decision.
FanGraphs has the Reds’ playoff odds at 3.5%, and with injuries piling up and the team failing to live up to its upside, the outlook is bleak. Francona didn’t sign up for a three-year run to watch things unravel this quickly, but that’s where the season appears to be headed.
His first year in Cincinnati created real momentum. The Reds made the postseason, even if the ending was disappointing, and Elly De La Cruz kept climbing toward superstardom. It looked like Francona had found the right touch.
That hasn’t carried over to 2026. The Reds have fallen well below .500, and that kind of slide could push the front office into a sell-off before the August 3 trade deadline. If that happens, it would only add to the sense that the team is heading away from contention rather than toward it.
Francona has made no secret of how much the collapse has worn on him. He has held team meetings, vented publicly, and even said he’s lost sleep over the Reds’ struggles. For a manager who stepped away from baseball once before because of health concerns, this kind of grind has to hit hard.
There’s also the uncertainty hanging over next year. The MLB Players Association and Major League Baseball are still far apart in labor talks, and a lockout next spring remains a real possibility. If that happens, Francona could find himself in a temporary retirement anyway, and it wouldn’t be hard to imagine him deciding not to come back for a shortened, chaotic season.
If this is the end, it isn’t the ending Francona should get. A future Hall of Famer deserves better than this.
He deserves a proper sendoff, some dramatic wins, and maybe even one more miracle run like the one Cincinnati pulled off at the end of last season. He deserves to go out with a winner one last time.
In Other News...
The Reds Draft Regret That Keeps Looking More Brutal
The 2022 draft still looks like a pivot point for Cincinnati, especially when you line up the Reds early picks against how the board turned out. The club came away with Cam Collier, Sal Stewart and Logan Tanner, a group that at the time represented a mix of upside and organizational need, but the conversation around that class has only gotten louder as the years have passed.
Logan Tanners path has been the hardest to read, with his development stalling before he could get beyond High-A and the organization eventually shifting him from catcher to pitcher. He has yet to make that first mound appearance after landing on the 60-day injured list in March, while the arm the Reds let go elsewhere has surged into one of the most compelling starting pitchers in the league and a legitimate Cy Young threat. [Read more 🡒]
Emilio Pagan Is Suddenly At Center Of The Reds Bullpen Tension
Emilio Pagan took another step toward rejoining the Reds on his rehab assignment, working a clean inning in just nine pitches in his second outing. The right-handers brief tune-up comes at a time when Cincinnatis bullpen has been stretched in several directions, with Graham Ashcraft and Tony Santillan on the injured list and Pierce Johnson and Julian Garcia only recently back in the mix.
For a group already juggling late-inning roles and fresh arms, Pagans progress matters even more because the Reds have had to absorb other hits around the roster as well, from Eugenio Suarez leaving after being hit by a pitch to Blake Dunn going on the injured list and KeBryan Hayes continuing his rehab work. The next question is how soon the club decides it has seen enough from Pagan, and what move follows when the bullpen finally gets one more experienced option back in the door. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Let Another Winnable Game Slip As Brewers Pressure Builds
The Reds had another chance to steady themselves Sunday in Pittsburgh, but the series finale slipped away early and never really came back. Brady Singer took the ball after showing some recent promise, yet the second inning turned into another reminder of the volatility that has followed him at times this season, and Cincinnati was left chasing a 9-4 loss at PNC Park.
Tyler Callihans three-run homer put the Pirates in control, and the Reds could not answer enough to change the feel of the afternoon. A rain delay only added to the frustration, as Pittsburgh came back out and kept widening the gap, leaving Cincinnati at 39-43 and still searching for a way to stop these winnable games from getting away. [Read more 🡒]