Hunter Greene, the Cincinnati Reds' dynamic starting pitcher, is facing a significant setback as he prepares for arthroscopic surgery on his right elbow. This procedure, aimed at removing bone chips and loose bodies, is expected to sideline him for 14-16 weeks, with a return anticipated around July.
Greene himself revealed last week that he had been experiencing elbow discomfort during the final month of the 2025 season. This revelation has left Reds fans frustrated, sparking questions about why the surgery wasn't addressed during the offseason.
Was there a lapse in communication within the Reds' medical team? According to Reds manager Terry Francona, the team was unaware of Greene's condition.
Francona shared, “He never told me (directly) any of that,” in a conversation with Cincinnati reporter Charlie Goldsmith. “I know he has mentioned it to (pitching coach Derek Johnson).
He was always telling me he was good. I liked the way he was pitching.
The trainers, we’re never going to send somebody out there if they shouldn’t pitch or play. Ever.”
The delay in addressing Greene's injury has added to the ongoing concerns about his durability. Last season, Greene started just 19 games due to a persistent hamstring issue, missing significant time on the injured list. His goal of being a consistent presence on the mound has been elusive, with an average of just 22.8 starts and 123.8 innings pitched over his four big-league seasons.
Trade rumors swirled during the offseason, fueled by doubts about Greene's ability to stay healthy. While the Reds front office eventually dismissed these rumors, one can't help but wonder if they were waiting for an irresistible offer from another team.
Critics have questioned Greene's commitment and resilience in the past, and he hasn't shied away from defending himself. Earlier this spring, Greene pushed back against a reporter's comments, labeling them a "defamation of character."
Until Greene can consistently overcome these injury hurdles, the narrative around his reliability will persist. The title of "ace" is reserved for those who can consistently answer the call, and so far, Greene has struggled to meet that mark.