The Reds left Wrigley Field with a 10-8 win Friday, but the biggest number from the afternoon belonged to Bill Miller.
The veteran home plate umpire was tagged on eight ABS challenges and lost every single one. Three came from Cincinnati, five from Chicago, and all eight pitches were overturned. For a game played under MLB’s Automated Ball-Strike challenge system, it was as rough a day as an umpire has had.
Miller’s first test came early, just nine plate appearances into the game, when Rhett Lowder fired an 0-1 four-seamer to the corner that should have been called a strike. From there, the challenge count kept climbing. By the time the ninth inning ended, seven more pitches had been challenged and all seven were changed.
Only two of the eight pitches had originally been called strikes.
Carson Kelly led the Cubs’ side of the challenge activity, while Jose Trevino had two calls overturned for the Reds. Each team also landed one successful batter challenge: Sal Stewart for Cincinnati and Seiya Suzuki for Chicago.
Notably, none of the challenges came from Reds catcher Tyler Stephenson, whose 88 overturns on 124 challenges lead all of baseball. Stephenson and Brewers catcher William Contreras are the only two players with at least 80 successful challenges this season.
For Miller, it was an ugly result in a game that may have set a new low mark under the ABS system. Using data from TapToChallenge.com, Friday’s contest is believed to be the worst goose egg by an umpire since MLB introduced the challenge system this season.
The previous high-water mark for overturned calls in a single game still belongs to Clint Vondrak, who had 11 of 16 challenges overturned on June 8 in a Brewers-Athletics game. That split included five challenges from Milwaukee and six from Athletics.
Even with Friday’s wipeout, Miller’s overall season numbers are not the worst in the league. He ranks ninth in total calls overturned with 70. Hunter Wendelstedt, Dan Iassogna, Malachi Moore, Lance Barrett and Manny Gonzalez sit ahead of him in that order.
This also wasn’t Miller’s first run-in with the Reds this season. In a mid-July game, Cincinnati second baseman Edwin Arroyo collided with Miller while trying to field a grounder, which led to a longer inning for Caleb Ferguson.
The left-hander responded with an expletive-filled rant that Mariners television caught. Ferguson apologized the next day, saying, “It’s just a very unprofessional thing on my part,” and adding, “I know these things happen in the game, but I don’t like that I was kind of the centerpiece of what was going on.”
As Stewart put it at the All-Star Game: “These umpires have a really, really, really difficult job,” Stewart told The Athletic at the All-Star Game. “I only have to know my zone; they need to know the whole league’s zone.
… I just want to say, man, the umpires have done a great job. This system, it’s not easy.
They have to know a lot of people, different heights.”
In Other News...
Matt McLain Just Put Reds Fans On Notice About MLB's Fight
The labor tension around baseballs next Collective Bargaining Agreement is already spilling into the player conversation, and Reds infielder Matt McLain has made it clear he expects a real fight ahead. With the current deal set to expire on Dec. 1 and negotiations still ongoing between MLB and the Players Association, McLain said on a podcast that he believes a lockout is likely, while also signaling that players are prepared to absorb missed games if it comes to that.
For Cincinnati, it is another reminder that the offseason could be shaped by more than roster moves and spring training planning. MLB owners have floated a salary cap and floor system that players strongly oppose, even as commissioner Rob Manfred has continued to sound optimistic about getting through to next season without major disruption. The gap between those positions remains wide, and McLains comments underscore how seriously players are taking the possibility that the standoff could carry into the games themselves. [Read more 🡒]
Francona Calls Out Reds Leak As Two Roster Decisions Turn Awkward
The Reds spent a tense day trying to manage two roster decisions that were supposed to stay quiet, only to have the news spill out before the club could control the message. Eugenio Suarez and TJ Friedl both landed on waivers, and Terry Francona did not hide his frustration over the leak of confidential information as Cincinnati tried to move through a delicate stretch with the deadline of a game against the Chicago Cubs still hanging over the clubhouse.
Suarez was still in the lineup against Chicago, while Friedl was absent, giving the situation a strangely normal look on the surface even as the backdrop remained awkward. Hector Rodriguez also returned to the lineup after a recent two-homer game, adding another layer to a day that felt more like roster management under a microscope than a typical game day in Cincinnati. [Read more 🡒]
Why The Reds Put Two Familiar Veterans On Waivers
The Reds made a noteworthy roster move when they placed Eugenio Surez and TJ Friedl on waivers, a procedural step that can sometimes open a path to salary relief or a possible change of scenery if another club bites. Instead, both veterans passed through unclaimed and cleared outright waivers, keeping them in Cincinnati and leaving the club to proceed with the same group it had in hand.
Surez and Friedl were told they would remain with the team, and both were in the lineup for the next game. For the Reds, it was a reminder that waiver decisions can create plenty of noise without necessarily changing the picture on the field, even when familiar names are involved. [Read more 🡒]