Reds Suddenly Have A Ninth-Inning Problem They Didn't Expect

Emilio Pagan departs the Reds for a one-year, $11 million contract with the Tigers, a decision that raises questions about his motivations and leaves Cincinnati seeking a new closer.

Emilio Pagan’s run as the Reds’ closer is over, and the next stop is Detroit.

According to MLB insider Jon Heyman, Pagan has agreed to a one-year, $11 million deal with the Tigers after turning down his $10 million player option with Cincinnati and entering free agency. The move means the Reds will need a new answer in the ninth inning for 2027.

What stands out most is the length of the contract. Pagan appeared to be aiming for something longer after two strong seasons in Cincinnati, but the market brought him a one-year deal instead. In practical terms, he’ll make only $1 million more than he would have earned by simply staying put.

There is a chance the contract includes an option, though no reports had confirmed that as of 12:39 a.m. Eastern time on Wednesday morning.

Pagan was a steady presence for Cincinnati over the last two years. In 2025, he saved 32 games and posted a 2.88 ERA in 70 appearances. He followed that in 2026 with a 3.38 ERA and 25 saves in 45 outings, even while dealing with a hamstring injury that sidelined him for nearly two months.

Once he came back from the injured list, he was excellent. Over his final 30 appearances, Pagan put up a 1.88 ERA and nailed down all 19 of his save chances.

That makes the decision to leave for a one-year deal worth only a modest bump all the more notable. It’s possible Pagan saw a better path to winning in Detroit, though that remains speculation. The Reds are coming off a 75-87 season and have plenty of roster questions to sort through, so there’s no guarantee they’ll be in the playoff mix next year.

It’s also unclear whether Cincinnati tried to bring him back after he declined his option. Detroit may simply have been the best fit available.

Either way, the Reds now have another major offseason task on their hands: finding someone who can handle the ninth inning. That could come from inside the organization or via free agency.

Pagan gave Cincinnati quality work, but a long-term commitment to a reliever who will soon be 36 carried real risk. With so many other needs to address, the Reds may have decided to move on. Still, seeing him land on a one-year, $11 million deal makes the whole situation a little more surprising.

In Other News...

Reds May Have Just One Ke'Bryan Hayes Escape Route

The Reds long-term commitment to KeBryan Hayes has already become one of the trickier financial pieces on the roster, with the club on the hook for the remaining $23 million on his deal through the 2029 season. For a team that has tried to keep its payroll flexible, that kind of money attached to a player whose fit has not yet fully settled naturally invites trade chatter, even if the market for a move like that is thin.

One idea floating around would require another club willing to take on salary in a way that helps both sides, but the practical obstacles are obvious. Any swap built around a veteran pitcher with his own contract baggage would have to make sense for the other team as well, and the Reds are not exactly in a position to expect a clean escape from Hayes deal. For now, the most realistic path may be waiting for a partner with a very specific need, because the list of teams able and willing to absorb that much money is not a long one. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Could Get A Second Chance To Cash In On Spencer Steer

The Reds never got the chance to move Spencer Steer before his season-ending wrist injury changed the conversation around his value, but his name may not be gone from the rumor mill for long. Cincinnati still has a roster decision to make with a versatile hitter who had drawn interest before the injury, and the possibility of a winter market shaped by Seattles outfield uncertainty could put Steer back into the frame.

For the Reds, the appeal is straightforward: if they are going to deal from a position player surplus, they would want pitching back in return, especially a starter who can help stabilize the rotation. Seattle has the kind of arms that could fit that ask, and Steers profile still gives Cincinnati a trade chip worth revisiting, even if the timing and the health questions make the next round of talks far more complicated than the last. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Mourn The Loss Of A Former Manager And Baseball Lifer

Bob Boone, a familiar name to Reds fans from an earlier era, has died after a long baseball life that stretched from the field to the dugout. Before he ever managed in Cincinnati, Boone built his reputation as a catcher over a 19-year playing career, one that earned him four All-Star nods and six Gold Glove awards, and he later moved into managing with the Kansas City Royals before arriving in Cincinnati.

For the Reds, Boone represented a direct link to a different chapter of the franchise, one shaped by a baseball man who understood the game from behind the plate and from the managers seat. His time in Cincinnati came in the early 2000s, and his passing adds another name to the list of former Reds figures whose impact is remembered not just for what happened in the standings, but for the steadier imprint they left on the organization. [Read more 🡒]