The Cincinnati Reds had a full day on their hands at Great American Ball Park, and it got even longer when Monday’s series opener against the Cleveland Guardians was pushed to Tuesday afternoon because of weather. That turned the day into a doubleheader, and the first game didn’t break the Reds’ way.
Game one turned into a back-and-forth slugfest, with both offenses finding plenty of life. In the end, though, it was the Guardians who came away with the 6-5 win.
The second game started with the Reds leaning on the bullpen, as Caleb Ferguson and Julian Garcia handled the early work. The plan was for Jose Franco to cover the bulk of the outing, and for a while, he was doing exactly that.
Franco was sharp before things took a turn. He worked 3.2 innings, allowed one hit and struck out two before leaving with an injury in the top of the seventh.
After throwing a pitch, he immediately signaled for the trainer. Not long after the visit to the mound, Reds manager Terry Francona went to Tejay Antone out of the bullpen.
On the broadcast, Jim Day said he was hearing a lot of chatter that the issue involved Franco’s elbow. The Reds later made it official, announcing that Franco has right elbow discomfort.
It’s another tough blow for a pitching staff that has already taken hit after hit this season. Hunter Greene, Nick Lodolo, Brandon Williamson, Rhett Lowder, Emilio Pagan, Tony Santillan and Graham Ashcraft have all spent time on the injured list, leaving the Reds trying to piece things together on the mound.
For Franco, the timing couldn’t be worse. He had been putting together a strong outing and seemed to be carving out a place for himself in Cincinnati before the injury stopped him short.
Now the Reds have to keep grinding through the rest of the second game of the doubleheader, just as they’ve had to grind through so much of this season. Nothing has come easy for them, and the first game of the day was another reminder of that.
Plenty of fans want the team to sell, and there’s no shortage of frustration. But one thing is clear: this group keeps showing up and giving everything it has.
In Other News...
Reds Face One Trade Deadline Dilemma That Could Shape 2027
The Reds are weighing a familiar deadline balancing act, with several veterans and short-term pieces drawing varying levels of interest as Mondays 6 p.m. ET cutoff approaches. Tyler Stephenson, JJ Bleday, Nathaniel Lowe, Eugenio Surez, Brady Singer and Brock Burke all sit in that gray area where a contenders need can create a market, but Cincinnatis own roster questions and longer-term plans matter just as much.
Bleday is the one who makes the decision feel especially tricky, because his value in a trade may not match his value to the Reds if they are still searching for everyday outfield answers beyond this season. The same kind of push-and-pull runs through the rest of the group, with Lowe offering left-handed balance, Surez bringing right-handed power, Singer supplying rotation stability and Burke giving clubs another bullpen option, leaving Cincinnati to decide whether the return now is worth the cost later. [Read more 🡒]
How The Reds 2025 Deadline Trades Are Looking Now
When the Reds moved three prospects at the 2025 deadline to land Ke'Bryan Hayes, Zack Littell and Miguel Andujar, the focus naturally fell on what Cincinnati was getting back for a push in the present. A few months later, the early returns on the players they sent out are starting to take shape. Sammy Stafura has made a noticeable jump with the Pirates minor league club, while Adam Serwinowskis arm has stood out in the Dodgers system even as his control remains a work in progress.
Kenya Huggins has had a tougher go of it with the Athletics at Double-A, which is part of the uneven picture the Reds left behind when they cashed in those prospects. Serwinowski and Huggins are both eligible for the Rule 5 draft this winter, adding another layer of uncertainty to how those deals will be judged in the long run. For Cincinnati, the deadline haul is still being measured against the upside it gave up, and that evaluation is only getting more interesting as the former Reds prospects continue down very different paths. [Read more 🡒]