The Reds’ second base picture still isn’t settled as they move into the second half, and the answer right now is a split job between Matt McLain and Edwin Arroyo.
McLain opened the season as Cincinnati’s everyday second baseman, but his offense has taken a step back in 2026. He’s still bringing elite defense, yet the bat hasn’t matched the expectations that followed a spring training full of optimism about a rebound to the All-Star level he showed in 2023.
“I’ve got to play better,” McLain said. “I’ve got to keep it simple, work hard and control what I can.”
Manager Terry Francona has kept backing him through the rough stretch.
“He has shown flashes of what he can do,” Francona said. “We all know it’s in there.
It just hasn’t been enough. But man, when you think somebody is a good player, you want to exhaust it.
You see guys who go somewhere else and find it. You want them to find it here, especially a guy who can defend like that.”
Over the last month, though, the Reds have started dividing the second base work with Arroyo, a rookie and former top prospect who was a key piece of the Luis Castillo trade in 2022. Arroyo has the kind of tools that jump off the field - the flashy defensive plays, the ability to collect base hits down the line - but he hasn’t been steady enough to lock down the position. McLain, in fact, has been more productive at the plate this season, and Arroyo has had trouble with some routine plays at second.
“I’m getting more consistent and getting used to the league,” Arroyo said. “Nothing really has changed much.
A couple of adjustments. Every pitcher is different with how they attack you.
Once I started to know them more, and they know me more, it’s a little different.”
The shuffle has also pushed McLain into a new role. With Arroyo getting more time at second, McLain has been seeing action in center field for the first time in his big league career.
That move comes at a time when Cincinnati badly needs help there. Blake Dunn and Dane Myers are both on the injured list, and TJ Friedl has had a down year, especially against left-handed pitching. So when the Reds face a lefty, McLain has been the one starting in center.
Outfield coach Collin Cowgill likes what he’s seen so far.
“With Matt, it’s really easy,” Cowgill said. “He’s a super athlete.
He has experience there from college and the Fall League. With his middle infield experience, he sees the ball well.
He understands the ball entering the zone and cheating toward the location of the pitch. He has the prerequisites.”
In Other News...
Reds Still Have One Lingering Roster Problem They Cannot Seem To Fix
The Reds could use a little more than a win over the Phillies to quiet the bigger questions around the roster, because the same old issue keeps surfacing in the outfield. Center field remains the spot Cincinnati has struggled to solve, and the organization still has not found a steady answer from within, even as it keeps cycling through options and hoping one of them sticks.
TJ Friedl was supposed to help anchor that group, but his bat has not given the Reds enough to lock him in as an everyday solution. With the 2026 MLB Draft approaching and Cincinnati holding the 18th pick, the front office will be watching the outfield market closely, since adding real talent there has become one of the clearest priorities on the board. [Read more 🡒]
Hctor Rodrguez May Force Reds Into Their Toughest Deadline Decision
The Reds deadline conversation has started to circle around one of the organizations most important young names, Hctor Rodrguez, whose strong run at Triple-A has only sharpened the questions about when Cincinnati will bring him up. With the front office weighing whether to simply move expiring contracts or lean into something bigger, Rodrguez has become more than a prospect to monitor. He is part of the decision tree.
And that is where the pressure starts to build for a club trying to balance the present with what comes next. Cincinnati has an outfield logjam to sort through, and the longer the Reds wait, the more they risk letting a current asset lose value while a top prospect keeps forcing the issue in Louisville. The deadline could end up being less about adding help than about choosing which version of the roster the Reds want to live with for the rest of the season. [Read more 🡒]