The Reds still need a catcher who can help shoulder the load with Jose Trevino and, for now, serve as a bridge to top prospect Alfredo Duno, who likely won’t be ready until 2028. A reunion with Tyler Stephenson on a two-year deal would have been the cleanest answer, but that path looked shaky from the start.
That outlook took another blow before the November 17 qualifying offer deadline, when Ryan Jeffers unexpectedly accepted the one-year, $23.15 million deal to stay with the Minnesota Twins. With Jeffers off the market, Stephenson stands alone as the top free-agent catcher, which only strengthens his negotiating position and makes him look increasingly out of Cincinnati’s price range.
But November 17 also brought another roster crunch around the league, as teams had to add prospects to their 40-man rosters to protect them from the Rule 5 Draft, if it happens. That created the usual wave of roster trimming, and one player who got squeezed out by the Chicago White Sox was veteran catcher Joey Bart.
Bart isn’t a headline-grabber, but he does add another name to the catching market, and he could be exactly the kind of inexpensive gamble the Reds should consider.
Trying to pin down what Bart really is has been difficult. The San Francisco Giants took him with the No. 2 overall pick in the 2018 draft, but he largely never settled in there before being traded to the Pittsburgh Pirates in April of 2024.
His two seasons in Pittsburgh came with very different shapes. In 2024, Bart hit .265/.337/.462 with 13 home runs across 80 games, leaning more into power. In 2025, the pop faded, but his patience improved, with his walk rate jumping from 7.8% to 12% on the way to a .249/.355/.340 line and four homers in 93 games.
Then came 2026, and the picture got even messier. Bart missed major time first because of a nasty foot infection that required IV antibiotics, then later after being hit by a pitch in August and suffering a fractured left hand. Along the way, the Pirates dealt him to the Atlanta Braves in June, and the Braves sent him to the White Sox at the August 3 deadline.
All of that turbulence left him with only 44 games played and a disappointing .214/.305/.357 line. It’s tough to pin that production entirely on him when he never had a chance to settle in and was moved twice.
Even so, Bart still brings former top-prospect pedigree, some recent production, and a price tag that should be manageable. That makes him the kind of upside play Cincinnati should be willing to make. Paired with Trevino, who is the better defender and does bring some offensive value, the Reds could squeeze average or better production out of the position.
The point for Cincinnati isn’t to chase the single best player at every spot if the budget won’t allow it. It’s to stretch the money far enough to cover as many holes as possible and build a roster that works better together than it does on paper.
Bart’s track record as a league-average or better hitter in 2024 and 2025, along with whatever upside remains from his draft status, gives the Reds more ceiling than most alternatives at the same price. That alone makes him a worthwhile roll of the dice.
In Other News...
Reds Just Got More Pressure In A Tyler Stephenson Decision
Ryan Jeffers taking the Twins one-year qualifying offer has already shifted the catching market, and it only makes the next few weeks more interesting for Cincinnati. With one of the more reliable names off the board, Tyler Stephenson suddenly looks even more valuable as a starting-caliber option for teams searching behind the plate. For the Reds, that raises the stakes on an offseason decision they were already going to have to make carefully.
Stephenson has been part of the clubs core conversation for a while, but a thinner market can change the price quickly. Cincinnati now has to weigh the comfort of keeping a known piece in place against the possibility of outside interest pushing the bidding higher, all while sorting through other catcher alternatives. The longer this plays out, the more it feels like a decision the Reds cannot afford to treat casually. [Read more 🡒]
Matt McLain May Be At Center Of A Reds Roster Shakeup
The Reds are heading into a busy stretch of roster housekeeping, with the non-tender deadline on Nov. 20 forcing some hard choices before the offseason really gets moving. Cincinnati has several players in the mix as it weighs the 40-man roster, and the discussion stretches beyond simple cuts or keepers. It is the kind of deadline that can reshape a clubs depth chart quickly, especially when arbitration projections and recent performance start pointing in different directions.
Matt McLain is among the names drawing attention as the Reds sort through those decisions, alongside Tony Santillan, Brandon Williamson, JJ Bleday and Noelvi Marte. The broader challenge for Cincinnati is figuring out which players still fit its plans and which ones might be better used as trade pieces or moved off the roster altogether before the offseason pause tied to the looming lockout changes the timing of everything. [Read more 🡒]
Reds May Have A Costly Answer To Their Third Base Problem
Christian Encarnacion-Strands departure from Cincinnati has only added to the Reds questions at third base, especially after he has settled in and performed well for Baltimore. Now the Orioles crowded infield picture has created a possible opening, with Jordan Westburg drawing trade interest from multiple teams and emerging as a name the Reds could circle as they look for a more reliable answer on the left side of the infield.
Westburg would fit the kind of upgrade Cincinnati has been hunting, but there is a catch beyond the acquisition cost. The Reds are weighing him as a potential solution at third, yet there are durability concerns attached to the fit, which makes this less of a clean fix and more of a calculated gamble for a club still trying to stabilize the position. [Read more 🡒]
