The Cincinnati Reds’ season unraveled in a way that showed up everywhere, but one number tells a big part of the story: their starting pitching fell apart.
The Reds finished 2026 with a losing record and last place in the division, and their rotation was one of the clearest reasons why. Cincinnati’s starters struggled badly in the areas that usually decide whether a pitcher survives a lineup or gets chased early, and now they’ve added another ugly mark to the ledger.
A stat shared by TJ Stats on X this week showed the Reds ranked 28th out of 30 MLB teams in team starters’ ERA. Only the Athletics and Rockies were worse. That’s the kind of number that leaves no wiggle room - especially when the rest of the league’s upper tier is packed with contenders.
Eight of the top 10 teams in starters’ ERA were playoff clubs: the Yankees, Dodgers, Brewers, Rays, Braves, Phillies, Red Sox, and Guardians. The only non-playoff teams in that group were the Tigers and Marlins. Cincinnati, meanwhile, was stuck near the very bottom with a starting staff that simply did not hold up.
That drop looks even sharper when you compare it to 2025. Just one season earlier, the Reds’ starters were a top-10 unit in baseball.
Andrew Abbott, Hunter Greene, and Nick Lodolo all turned in strong seasons that year, and the rotation was usually one of the club’s biggest strengths. In 2026, all three regressed noticeably.
The difference in run prevention was huge. Cincinnati’s starters posted a 3.85 ERA in 2025, more than a full run better than what the team managed in 2026.
Injuries to Greene and Lodolo at the start of the season certainly didn’t help, but depth quickly became a problem too. Brandon Williamson was healthy for only 11 games, Jose Franco spent most of the year in Triple-A, Chase Petty was moved to relief, and Julian Aguiar was designated for assignment and claimed by a division rival.
For a club that usually counts on its rotation to set the tone, it was a rough year from top to bottom. And if the Reds want to be competitive in 2027, their starters are going to have to bounce back in a big way.
In Other News...
Reds Face Tough Calls On Several Familiar Names This Offseason
The Reds winter already has the feel of a roster reckoning after a 75-87 finish left them outside the postseason again. Cincinnati has a handful of familiar names to sort through, and the decisions are not limited to one corner of the roster. Eugenio Suarez, Brady Singer, Tyler Stephenson, Brock Burke, TJ Friedl, Pierce Johnson and Will Benson all sit somewhere in the mix as the front office weighs recent performance against contract status and future value.
For a team that needs more consistency, the challenge is figuring out which veterans still fit and which spots have to be turned over. Some of those calls will hinge on performance, others on potential free agency or contract options, and the Reds do not have the luxury of getting them wrong. The offseason should tell a lot about how aggressively Cincinnati plans to reshape a group that fell short of October and now has to decide which familiar faces are worth keeping around. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Face One Costly Free Agency Decision They Can't Get Wrong
As the Reds sort through a disappointing season and try to find a cleaner path forward, the front office is staring at a familiar kind of offseason squeeze: how to improve the lineup without boxing itself in financially. Two familiar names sit near the center of that conversation, catcher Tyler Stephenson and pitcher Brady Singer, and both decisions matter because Cincinnati does not have a lot of room for error as it tries to get better without overspending.
Stephenson, though, stands out as the tougher player to replace if he reaches free agency, especially because of what he brings offensively at a premium position. Singer is a different kind of call, one that hinges more on the price tag and how much payroll flexibility the Reds want to preserve. For a club that needs impact bats and still has to watch the bottom line, getting the balance right on these two could shape the rest of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Face Big Veteran Decisions Before Free Agency Gets Messy
With the 2026 season in the books, the Reds are staring at one of those offseasons that can quietly reshape a roster before the winter even really begins. The front office has already kept its top decision-makers in place, with president of baseball operations Nick Krall still guiding the process, and now the focus turns to a veteran group that is about to test the market as the club weighs what to keep and what to let walk.
There are six Cincinnati players headed for free agency, which gives the team a clear early list of priorities even before the broader labor picture comes into focus. With Collective Bargaining talks looming and the possibility of a lockout hanging over the sport, the Reds will have to sort through who fits their next phase and who might simply be too expensive or too uncertain to bring back, making this a winter with more pressure than the usual roster churn. [Read more 🡒]