Reds Rotation Woes Just Made One Offseason Need Impossible To Ignore

As the Reds look to rebound from a tough 2026 season, potential upgrades and internal improvements will be critical for revitalizing their pitching rotation in 2027.

CINCINNATI -- The Reds spent 2026 learning the hard way that rotation depth can disappear fast.

They opened the season feeling good about the group they had built, but that confidence didn’t last long. Injuries hit during Spring Training, the staff kept getting thinner, and by mid-May the rotation was worn down. President of baseball operations Nick Krall made it clear last week at the General Managers Meetings that Cincinnati plans to address the problem for 2027.

“Just because you have five starters doesn’t mean you’re going to have five starters throughout the year," Krall said. "We thought we had eight guys coming into the season [this] year. Obviously, we struggled at times to keep everybody on the field.

"It’s something that we just have to add pitching, no matter how it is. Starters might give you more length. It might give you more flexibility with your bullpen.”

The numbers tell the story. Cincinnati’s rotation finished 28th in ERA at 4.97 in 2026, a steep drop from ninth at 3.85 in 2025. The staff also ranked third in walks and fifth in homers allowed this season.

The injury list was brutal. Hunter Greene needed right elbow surgery to remove bone chips in Spring Training, then underwent Tommy John surgery in August after making only five starts.

He won’t be back until 2028. On the final day of camp, Nick Lodolo suffered a blister on his left index finger.

Brandon Williamson missed four months with left shoulder fatigue, and Rhett Lowder was sidelined nearly a month with right shoulder pain.

Even when the Reds had arms available, consistency was hard to find. Lodolo, Lowder, Williamson and a healthy Andrew Abbott all had stretches of struggle.

Brady Singer had a rough season, but he was the only Reds pitcher who did not miss a start because of injury over 2025 and 2026. Singer is now a free agent, and while most of his 2026 production wouldn’t be something to chase, his durability stands out.

The market does offer names, though the top of the free-agent class is likely out of Cincinnati’s range. Tarik Skubal, Freddy Peralta and Michael King headline the group, but the Reds probably won’t be shopping there.

That leaves a more realistic list of possibilities, and four names stand out.

Shane Bieber fits the bounceback category. The right-hander was limited to 18 starts over his last two seasons with the Blue Jays, posting a 4.03 ERA, with arm injuries including right shoulder inflammation in 2026.

Bieber, a former All-Star and Cy Young winner with Cleveland, also had Tommy John surgery on his right elbow in 2024. He needs a healthy year to reestablish himself, and Cincinnati could be a place where that happens.

Cal Quantrill brings flexibility. He’ll turn 32 in February and opened last season in the Rangers’ bullpen before moving into the rotation, where he posted a 2.86 ERA over 32 games, including 15 starts. He also spent four seasons with Terry Francona and new pitching coach Joe Torres in Cleveland from 2020-23, which gives him familiarity with both men.

Zac Gallen is another name to watch. He was a steady presence in Arizona for eight years, including an All-Star 2023 season when he threw 210 innings over a career-high 34 starts.

He has reached at least 30 starts and 180 innings three times in his career, and he logged 192 innings in 2025. But 2026 went sideways, with a 6.07 ERA over 105 1/3 innings and 22 games, 20 of them starts.

He finished the year in the bullpen.

David Peterson also has a split story. The 2025 All-Star fell apart with the Mets this season, including a rough outing against the Reds in May, and posted a 6.09 ERA in 16 games, eight starts, before moving to the bullpen. The Cubs traded for him in June, and he responded with a 6-2 record, a 3.70 ERA and a 114 ERA+ over 16 games, 15 starts, to close the year.

Free agency and trades are part of the answer, but the Reds also need internal improvement. That means better seasons from Abbott, Lodolo, Lowder and Williamson. It also means another strong year from Chase Burns, who enters the first season of his seven-year, $105 million extension as Cincinnati’s new ace.

“When you look at our starters -- besides Chase Burns -- I think everybody took a step backwards this year," Krall said. “We need to have consistency.

Those guys are all going to come in and fight for jobs. Yeah, we do need starting pitching.

I think that’s everybody, every year. But we do need to figure out if there’s a way to either add a starter to the mix or add some competition to this mix somehow.”

In Other News...

Former Reds Ace Luis Castillo Just Entered A Strange New Chapter

Luis Castillos career has taken another unexpected turn, with the White Sox sending the former Reds ace to the Rockies in a deal that also included Davis Martin and brought back two prospects. Colorado is taking on Castillos entire contract, a notable commitment for a pitcher whose recent season was marked by a 5.85 ERA and some troubling performance indicators. For Cincinnati fans who remember his peak years on the mound, it is a reminder of how quickly the business side of baseball can rewrite a familiar name.

The contract piece makes this move especially unusual, because the Rockies are not just adding a veteran arm, they are absorbing a deal that carries real long-term weight, including a vesting option for 2028. Castillo now finds himself in a new setting with new expectations, and the trade adds another layer to a career that has already seen plenty of twists since his days anchoring the Reds rotation. What happens next will say a lot about whether this is a reclamation project or simply the latest stop in a winding path. [Read more 🡒]

Reds May Have Found A Cheap Rotation Fix In Boston

The Reds spent the offseason looking for ways to shore up a rotation that could use more depth, and Boston may have created a market worth watching. After both Cincinnati and the Red Sox missed out on Sonny Gray, the two clubs are now in very different spots, with Boston carrying several starting pitchers who could be moved as the non-tender deadline approaches.

Johan Oviedo, Tanner Houck and Kutter Crawford are all reportedly available for trade, a development that could give the Reds a cheaper path to adding help on the mound. With injuries and roster crunches shaping Bostons decisions, Cincinnati may find more value in exploring the trade market than chasing another free-agent splash. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Quietly Add An Outfield Option As Roster Pressure Builds

The Reds have added another outfield option to the mix, signing Dominic Fletcher to a minor league contract with an invitation to big league spring training. It is the kind of low-risk move clubs make when they want to keep the depth chart flexible, especially with roster pressure always looming once camp opens and decisions start stacking up.

Fletcher is no stranger to the organization, having spent the end of 2026 with Cincinnatis Triple-A affiliate after already logging parts of three MLB seasons. He has not appeared in the majors over the most recent season, but the Reds will get another look at him in camp as they sort through who can help them handle the outfield mix heading into the year. [Read more 🡒]