The Cincinnati Reds already made one costly call on Ke’Bryan Hayes, and the front office can’t afford to turn that mistake into a second one at this year’s trade deadline.
Last July, the Reds sent left-handed pitcher Taylor Rogers and shortstop prospect Sammy Stafura to the Pittsburgh Pirates to land the third baseman from a division rival. Since arriving in Cincinnati, Hayes has hit just .192/.263/.285, a return that has made the deal look worse by the month.
That kind of swing-and-miss usually puts a general manager on the hot seat, but Nick Krall is still in place for now. Even so, the Reds cannot let the bad math of the Hayes trade spill into this deadline by attaching him to another deal and dragging down the value of a more important asset.
There are plenty of ways teams are expected to work the deadline. Some will chase prospects.
Others will target big leaguers. Some will focus on rentals, while others try to move unwanted contracts and accept less in return to make the money work.
That is exactly the trap Cincinnati has to avoid with Hayes.
Krall has done this kind of thing before. In 2022, the Reds paired then-breakout slugger Jesse Winker - fresh off an All-Star season - with Eugenio Suárez and the rest of Suárez’s six-year, $66 million extension in a deal with the Seattle Mariners before the season began. It was essentially a salary dump, and it cost Cincinnati one of its best players.
Now the Reds are being tied to a deadline approach that could include selling rentals such as Suárez, Nathaniel Lowe, and Brady Singer. Recent rumors have also put Hunter Greene in the mix among pitchers who might be available.
But Hayes should not be part of any package that includes Greene, or any other heavily sought-after Reds player, if the goal is to unload the third baseman’s contract, which runs through 2029. Doing that would only weaken the return on the entire deal.
Cincinnati already paid for the Hayes mistake once. It can’t afford to pay for it again.
In Other News...
Joey Votto Just Changed His Tune On Elly De La Cruz
Joey Vottos view of Elly De La Cruz has come a long way from the caution he felt when the young shortstop first arrived in the majors. Votto admitted he once saw a player with plenty of flash but also plenty of risk, the kind of talent whose strikeouts, errors and recklessness could make it hard to trust the long view. Since then, De La Cruz has given him plenty of reason to rethink that stance, with Votto pointing to the way he works, carries himself and keeps showing up every day.
What stands out now, from Vottos perspective, is not just the tools but the steadiness behind them. He praised De La Cruzs humility and drive, and noted that the Reds have watched him turn raw ability into something more dependable through consistent performance and durability. Votto even placed him in rare company when talking about the shortstop standard in Cincinnati, which says plenty about how far De La Cruz has come in the eyes of one of the franchises most respected voices. [Read more 🡒]
One Reds Deadline Gamble Might Finally Be Worth The Wait
The Reds 2022 deadline haul is still being judged through a harsh lens, especially after the club shipped out Luis Castillo and Tyler Mahle in separate deals that reshaped the roster in a hurry. One of the quieter moves from that summer was sending Brandon Drury to San Diego for Victor Acosta, a return that has tested patience because Acosta spent years stuck in the lower minors before finally giving Cincinnati a reason to keep watching.
Acostas latest step forward came in Dayton, where he delivered a breakthrough game that hinted at more than just a hot night at the plate. For a trade that once looked like a footnote, that kind of performance matters, because the Reds are still waiting to see whether this is the start of a real climb or just another brief flash in a long, uneven development path. [Read more 🡒]