The Cincinnati Reds have an offseason problem staring them right in the face at second base, and MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand thinks one possible answer could be a familiar name with plenty of upside: Yankees infielder Jazz Chisholm.
That fit, at least on paper, is easy to understand. Matt McLain has been strong defensively at second, but his bat has lagged for two straight years.
Juan Brito is still a question mark. And if the Reds want more offense, second base is one of the clearest places to find it.
Feinsand made the case bluntly: "Baseball-wise, there might not be a better fit for Chisholm than the Reds, who ranked 29th in the Majors with a .608 OPS at second base and 27th overall with a .693 OPS against right-handed pitching," Feinsand wrote. "The biggest question is whether Cincinnati will be willing to give Chisholm a multi-year deal, though it’s conceivable that he could seek a one-year “prove it” deal with an eye toward testing free agency again a year from now."
The offensive logic checks out. Chisholm would be an upgrade over McLain at the position, and his best version would give Cincinnati a real boost. In 2025, he posted an .813 OPS with 4.1 WAR, the kind of production that changes the shape of a lineup.
But the next season told a different story. Chisholm’s numbers slipped in 2026, when he hit .231/.312/.399 with 38 extra-base hits. That’s not eye-popping production, but even that level would still be an improvement over what the Reds got at second base.
That’s where the real decision comes in for Cincinnati: talent versus cost. Chisholm could take a meaningful chunk out of the payroll, and the Reds still have other roster holes to patch. Paying him as if the 2025 version is the standard carries obvious risk after the step back he took in 2026.
A one-year "prove it" deal would change the conversation. If Chisholm were willing to take that route, the Reds’ interest would make a lot more sense, because the downside would be far easier to manage.
There’s also the matter of the noise that can come with Chisholm. His on-field style can draw attention, including the kind of details that stand out, like playing second base with a Blow Pop in his mouth. That alone shouldn’t make or break the decision, but when the production dips, the extra attention can become part of the equation.
The fit is there. The need is there. The real question for Cincinnati is whether the price is right.
In Other News...
Reds Offseason Could Shape Sal Stewart In One Important Way
The Reds head into the offseason with a long shopping list, and the biggest decisions are not limited to the rotation and bullpen. Cincinnati also has to sort out third base, find a right-handed-hitting outfielder and address catching depth, all while trying to keep the lineup moving in a way that fits the next wave of young talent. Sal Stewarts historic rookie season in 2026 only sharpened the focus on how the club can best support him as he moves into the next stage of his career.
One name that naturally fits into that conversation is Paul Goldschmidt, who could bring both stability and a veteran presence to a clubhouse trying to bridge present needs with future upside. For the Reds, the appeal goes beyond just plugging a lineup hole, since a player like Goldschmidt could help guide Stewart while also giving the team a useful piece in the mix against certain matchups. What Cincinnati decides this winter will say plenty about how aggressively it wants to shape Stewarts path, and whether it can turn a roster need into a broader developmental advantage. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Could Target A Cheap Outfield Option Fans Overlooked
As the Reds sort through their offseason roster plans, they are looking at the usual mix of headline-grabbing free agents and quieter, cheaper options who could still fit a need. One name that pops up in that second lane is Drew Waters, the former Royals prospect who recently elected free agency and could appeal as a low-risk addition for a club that values versatility and athleticism in the outfield.
Waters did not get a big league look last season, but his profile still makes him interesting for Cincinnati. His switch-hitting bat, baserunning ability and defensive value give him a chance to compete for a reserve role, especially if the Reds want insurance across the outfield without committing significant money or a guaranteed everyday spot. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Face A Messy Offseason That Could Reshape Their 2027 Lineup
The Reds spent the 2026 season sorting through a roster that still feels like it is being built around a few core names, and the look ahead to Opening Day 2027 already has that same uneasy mix of promise and uncertainty. Elly De La Cruz remains the headliner, Spencer Steer is still part of the conversation, and Hunter Burns has emerged as one of the most important pieces in the picture after what he showed last year.
What makes the offseason especially interesting is how much could still change before the lineup card is ever written. Hunter Greenes injury clouds the pitching plan, Nick Lodolos status is part of the trade chatter, and third base is among the spots that may need help if the front office decides to go outside the organization. The Reds have enough talent to imagine a competitive group again in 2027, but the exact shape of that group could hinge on a few moves that are far from settled. [Read more 🡒]