Reds May Have Found A Cheaper Answer To A Costly Pitching Need

The Cincinnati Reds are eyeing a potential reunion with pitcher Cal Quantrill as a strategic move to strengthen their rotation and bullpen in the upcoming season.

The Reds are staring at the same kind of hole they had a year ago, and this time the answer might come from a familiar face.

Cincinnati really felt the absence of Nick Martinez in 2026. After the regular season ended, reports said Nick Krall wanted to bring Martinez back instead of reuniting with Eugenio Suárez, but ownership preferred to bring Geno back to the Queen City.

Now the Reds are heading into the 2026-27 offseason - one that may only last another week or so - and the need is obvious. They need someone who can give them length out of the bullpen, and maybe even step into a start or three on short notice. Martinez is back on the market, but he’s expected to land a multi-year deal worth at least $20 million per season, a price that would push Cincinnati beyond what it wants to spend on a middle-of-the-rotation arm.

That doesn’t mean the Reds are out of options. It just means they have to be sharper.

Cal Quantrill could fit that exact lane. The right-hander spent last season with the Texas Rangers, and he also has a connection to Terry Francona and new pitching coach Joe Torres from their time with the Cleveland Guardians. With the offseason likely coming to a screeching halt on December 1, this is the kind of pitcher Cincinnati should be lining up now.

Quantrill had a rough 2025 split between the Miami Marlins and Atlanta Braves, but he bounced back in 2026. The soon-to-be 32-year-old posted a 2.86 ERA over 110 innings while making 32 appearances, including 15 starts.

He’s not going to blow hitters away - his strikeout rate in 2026 was 18.3% - but he limits damage by avoiding walks, with a 5.6% BB rate, and he generated plenty of soft contact last season. Like Martinez, Quantrill works with a deep pitch mix that keeps hitters guessing. He leans on his sinker, especially against right-handed batters, and mixes in a curveball and cutter against lefties.

The price is still unclear, but the best comparison might be the two-year, $24 million deal the Reds gave Martinez before the 2023 season. That contract came with an opt-out after the first year, and Martinez used it before later receiving a qualifying offer.

Cincinnati has to make smart, savvy moves this winter. A one- or two-year deal for Quantrill would fit that bill.

In Other News...

Former Reds Reliever Just Exposed A Tough Truth About Cincinnati

Emilio Pagns decision to turn down his $10 million option with the Reds and land a one-year, $11.5 million deal with the Tigers says plenty about where the market and the moment lined up for him. For Cincinnati, it is another reminder that even when a reliever performs well enough to draw interest, the conversation can quickly shift from retaining talent to explaining why a player would rather look elsewhere.

Pagn made clear that winning and a chance to compete for the playoffs mattered in choosing Detroit, and that is the uncomfortable part for the Reds. The Tigers offered a different kind of sell, with a roster and organizational direction that gave Pagn a clearer path to meaningful September baseball, while Cincinnati is left to keep trying to convince veterans that its own next step is close enough to buy into. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Suddenly Have A Cheap Way To Address Two Roster Needs

The Twins decision to non-tender Bailey Ober and Trevor Larnach has quietly opened a door for clubs looking for affordable help, and the Reds fit that description well. Ober, a right-hander with real upside when healthy, suddenly becomes the kind of low-cost pitching gamble that can appeal to a Cincinnati staff still sorting out its depth. Larnach, meanwhile, gives the Reds a left-handed outfield option with a track record that compares favorably to JJ Bleday, which is exactly the sort of marginal upgrade a front office can chase when it is trying to patch multiple holes without spending big.

For Cincinnati, the appeal is obvious because these are not splashy names, but they do line up with two areas the roster could use help. Obers recent injury history and declining velocity make him a risk, yet the price tag should reflect that, and Larnach offers a different kind of fit as a bat-first outfielder who could compete for playing time right away. Whether the Reds actually pursue either player is still an open question, but the non-tender market just gave them a cheaper path to address both the rotation and the outfield if they want to be aggressive. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Face One Key Decision On A Dodgers Outfield Fit

The Reds have made it pretty clear this offseason that they want more platoon help, and that need lines up neatly with a player like Alex Call. The Dodgers outfielder fits the profile Cincinnati has been talking about, especially as a right-handed bat who could help balance an outfield mix that could use more options against left-handed pitching.

Call was recently retained by Los Angeles through arbitration, which gives the Dodgers another layer of control as the market starts to take shape. For the Reds, that means any pursuit would likely have to come through trade, and the question now is whether they decide this is the kind of fit worth pushing for as they try to fill out the roster. [Read more 🡒]