Reds May Have A Costly Answer To Their Third Base Problem

Intriguingly poised in their pursuit of a stronger lineup, the Reds could capitalize on Baltimore's infield congestion to bolster their third base options through a strategic trade.

The Reds may have helped create a Baltimore problem, and now that same mess could open a door in Cincinnati.

Christian Encarnacion-Strand, whom the Reds moved for cash considerations, caught fire with the Orioles and gave Baltimore exactly the kind of production it probably didn’t see coming. In 58 games, the 27-year-old hit .277/.325/.513 with 11 homers. That surge arrived right as Coby Mayo finally started looking like the player the Orioles had been waiting on for years.

Mayo’s season ended up with 132 games, a .228/.297/.461 line and 24 home runs, but the back half told a much better story. From July 1 through the end of the season, he got 223 plate appearances and hit .267/.336/.550. His early-season line through June was a rough .190/.260/.376 with 10 homers in 231 plate appearances, but the final three months brought a much louder bat.

Baltimore already has Pete Alonso locked in at one corner of the infield, and with Jordan Westburg set to return in 2027 after missing the season with a torn UCL, the Orioles suddenly have more infield pieces than places to put them. Blaze Alexander is also in the mix, which only adds to the logjam.

That’s where Cincinnati enters the picture. The Reds still need a real upgrade over Ke’Bryan Hayes at third base, and Westburg looks like the cleanest fit.

A deal for Westburg would check a lot of boxes for the Reds. Baltimore is said to be willing to listen on everyone not named Pete Alonso, and president of baseball operations Mike Elias is looking for outfield help.

He’s even weighing whether to use his infield surplus to cover some of those outfield needs, though that sounds more like posturing than the likeliest outcome. An actual outfielder would probably be more appealing to him.

Among Baltimore’s possible trade chips, Westburg stands out as the best match for Cincinnati. The Reds have already seen what CES can do, shouldn’t bank on Mayo after one hot stretch, and would be smart to avoid the steep price that would come with Alexander.

Westburg has put together a career .264/.312/.456 line and has been steady throughout his time in the majors. He made the All-Star team in 2024, brings right-handed power, and is under team control through 2029.

He’s also projected to make just $1.5 million in his first trip through arbitration. Beyond third base, he has experience at second and could eventually push Matt McLain if another corner-infield answer shows up later this offseason.

The catch is durability. Westburg has played only 260 career games since debuting in 2023, and he has never appeared in more than 107 in a season. The injuries haven’t been chronic, but availability is still a real question.

Even with that concern, the buzz around him is growing. Several teams have already checked in on Westburg, according to the latest smoke out of Baltimore, and it remains to be seen whether that’s simple due diligence or the start of a real bidding war.

For Cincinnati, though, the case is obvious enough. If the Reds can put together a package led by JJ Bleday, Nick Krall would have to take a hard look. Westburg may not be perfect, but he might be the most impactful upgrade the club can realistically land at the right price.

In Other News...

Reds Just Got More Pressure In A Tyler Stephenson Decision

Ryan Jeffers taking the Twins one-year qualifying offer has already shifted the catching market, and it only makes the next few weeks more interesting for Cincinnati. With one of the more reliable names off the board, Tyler Stephenson suddenly looks even more valuable as a starting-caliber option for teams searching behind the plate. For the Reds, that raises the stakes on an offseason decision they were already going to have to make carefully.

Stephenson has been part of the clubs core conversation for a while, but a thinner market can change the price quickly. Cincinnati now has to weigh the comfort of keeping a known piece in place against the possibility of outside interest pushing the bidding higher, all while sorting through other catcher alternatives. The longer this plays out, the more it feels like a decision the Reds cannot afford to treat casually. [Read more 🡒]

Matt McLain May Be At Center Of A Reds Roster Shakeup

The Reds are heading into a busy stretch of roster housekeeping, with the non-tender deadline on Nov. 20 forcing some hard choices before the offseason really gets moving. Cincinnati has several players in the mix as it weighs the 40-man roster, and the discussion stretches beyond simple cuts or keepers. It is the kind of deadline that can reshape a clubs depth chart quickly, especially when arbitration projections and recent performance start pointing in different directions.

Matt McLain is among the names drawing attention as the Reds sort through those decisions, alongside Tony Santillan, Brandon Williamson, JJ Bleday and Noelvi Marte. The broader challenge for Cincinnati is figuring out which players still fit its plans and which ones might be better used as trade pieces or moved off the roster altogether before the offseason pause tied to the looming lockout changes the timing of everything. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Still Have One Affordable Catching Option Worth Watching

The Reds are still sorting out the catching picture behind Jose Trevino, and the search has a familiar feel: find someone affordable, dependable enough to handle a share of the workload, and possibly capable of stepping into a larger role if Tyler Stephenson does not return. One name that has surfaced is Joey Bart, the veteran catcher who was recently released by the Chicago White Sox and would fit the kind of low-cost gamble Cincinnati has to consider at this stage of the offseason.

Barts appeal is obvious enough for a team in the Reds position. He has already been through the ups and downs that come with trying to establish himself at the major league level, and his recent track record has been uneven, with injuries and trades interrupting his run in 2026. Still, for a club looking to add catching depth without spending heavily, he remains the kind of option worth keeping on the radar while the rest of the market takes shape. [Read more 🡒]