The Reds had this one in their hands, and then the whole thing slipped away.
Cincinnati turned a one-run lead over to Brock Burke in the ninth, only to watch St. Louis rip the game open and leave with a 10-9 win that clinched the 5-game series. What looked like a clean finish turned into a mess on a routine fly ball, and the Cardinals made the most of the extra life.
The night started with Brady Singer and JJ Wetherholt trading early blows. Wetherholt got hit by Singer’s eighth pitch, moved around the bases, and scored on a groundout to give St.
Louis a 1-0 lead. Two innings later, Wetherholt sparked another rally with a one-out single, Ivan Herrera walked behind him, and Jordan Walker crushed a three-run homer with two outs to make it 4-0.
For six innings, that was the margin. Then Cincinnati’s offense finally woke up in the bottom of the sixth.
Hector Rodriguez opened the inning with an infield hit, Ke’Bryan Hayes followed with a single to center, and Sal Stewart drew a one-out walk to load the bases. St.
Louis went to Ryne Stanek, who came in to face JJ Bleday after Bleday had gone 0-8 against him in his career. This time, Bleday won the matchup with an RBI single to right that brought home Rodriguez.
After a strikeout, Matt McLain stepped in and did the damage that flipped the game: Stanek left a splitter over the plate, and McLain launched a grand slam into the seats in left for a 5-4 Reds lead.
Cincinnati’s bullpen held that lead through the seventh and eighth. Julian Garcia worked around a walk with a double play and a flyout on just eight pitches in the seventh, and Tejay Antone handled the eighth despite a two-out walk, even picking off Joshua Baez.
Then came the ninth, and everything unraveled.
Burke allowed a leadoff single to Jose Fermin. Bryan Torres then squared to bunt and was hit by a pitch on a play Cincinnati challenged and lost.
A flyout moved both runners up, putting the tying run at third and the go-ahead run at second. Burke struck out Everson Pereira for the second out, then got the kind of ball every pitcher wants: a routine fly ball into left center.
TJ Friedl was underneath it. Dane Myers came over, called him off, and then dropped it.
Two runs scored on the play, and St. Louis jumped in front 6-5.
The Cardinals kept pouring it on after that. Burke intentionally walked Alec Burleson for the lefty-on-lefty look, but Burleson chopped a ball just past Michael Toglia at first to bring in another run.
Jordan Walker walked to load the bases, Burke walked in a run, and his night was over. Zach Maxwell entered and gave up an RBI single that pushed the lead to 10-5.
The Reds still had one more surge left in them.
Matt McLain and Dane Myers both walked to start the bottom of the ninth. Eugenio Suarez pinch hit for Ke’Bryan Hayes with two outs and singled to center to score a run.
Elly De La Cruz then walked to load the bases, forcing St. Louis to bring in closer Riley O’Brien against Sal Stewart.
Stewart came through with a two-run single to cut it to 10-8, JJ Bleday drew another walk to reload the bases, and Tyler Stephenson worked a four-pitch walk to make it a one-run game. But McLain lined out to the warning track in right, and that was that.
Key moment of the game: Dane Myers not catching what would have been the final out and allowing St. Louis to take the lead in the 9th inning.
Notes worth noting: Ke’Bryan Hayes finally singled in the sixth, going 1-3 and raising his batting average to .152. He’s now played in 74 games, and only twice this season has his average been higher than .150 at the end of a game.
Julian Garcia’s scoreless inning dropped his ERA back under 3.00, now sitting at 2.93 through 21 games and 27.2 innings. TJ Friedl went 0-1, his average fell to .157, and he still hasn’t had a hit since July 11th.
He’s 0-29 in the second half.
Friday August 20th, 9:40pm ET
In Other News...
Spencer Steer Update Could Force A Tough Reds Decision
The Reds open a three-game series against the Arizona Diamondbacks with Nick Lodolo on the mound, but there was plenty happening around the roster before the first pitch. Cincinnati added former Braves right-hander Darius Vines on a minor-league deal, a move that gives the organization some extra pitching depth as it keeps sorting through the long grind of the season. Austin Hendricks demotion to Double-A Chattanooga also underscored how quickly the club is still adjusting pieces at the lower levels.
The more pressing watch, though, is Spencer Steer, who is due for a wrist re-evaluation that could determine whether surgery becomes necessary. Any update there would ripple beyond Steer himself, since the Reds have already had to manage lineup uncertainty and can ill afford another extended absence from a player theyve had to count on in multiple roles. For a club trying to keep momentum while navigating injuries and roster churn, this is the kind of situation that could force a difficult decision soon. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Face An Elly De La Cruz Question They Cant Ignore
Terry Francona has made it clear he would rather not keep Elly De La Cruz in the leadoff spot, even with the switch-hitting star still giving the Reds all the traits that normally make a lineup look better at the top. De La Cruz brings speed, plate discipline and the kind of dynamic threat Cincinnati can build around, but the way he has been used has also put extra pressure on both him and Sal Stewart in the heart of the order.
The bigger question is whether the Reds can find a cleaner answer before next season, because this is not a problem that looks likely to solve itself. De La Cruzs slump has come at the same time the club has struggled, and a more traditional table-setter would make sense in theory, but the available choices may not fit Cincinnatis budget or roster needs all that well. [Read more 🡒]
Tommy Pham Just Piled Onto A Reds Frustration Fans Already Feel
A dropped fly ball was bad enough for the Reds to absorb in a game against the Cardinals, but the noise around it only grew after Tommy Pham took the criticism public on social media. Pham, who spent time with Cincinnati before moving on and is now in the minor leagues in the Phillies organization, took aim at Dane Myers and suggested the outfielder had put personal numbers ahead of the team, a charge that immediately stirred debate.
For Reds fans already bracing for another round of frustration, the episode added an unwelcome layer to a loss that might otherwise have faded quickly. Phams limited role this season gives his comments a certain awkwardness all their own, but they still landed in a familiar place for Cincinnati: another distraction attached to a team trying to sort out the basics while the conversation turns somewhere else. [Read more 🡒]