Reds Just Showed How Thin Their Pitching Depth Has Become

The Cincinnati Reds' latest lineup adjustments have spotlighted critical gaps in their roster depth as they struggle through the season.

The Reds’ latest pitching move says a lot about where the organization stands right now.

Ahead of Monday’s doubleheader against the St. Louis Cardinals, Cincinnati brought up Zach McCambley as the 27th man, then made a separate shuffle that included designating Ron Marinaccio for assignment and selecting the contract of Kent Emanuel. That’s the name that jumps out - not because he’s a headline arm, but because he’s the one the Reds are turning to.

Emanuel, 34, has spent most of the 2026 season in the Atlantic League. He’s appeared in just one game for the Reds’ organization, and it came last week with Triple-A Louisville, where he threw six innings, allowed one run and two hits, and struck out eight. For a club trying to piece together a doubleheader, that was enough to earn him another look.

A third-round pick of the Houston Astros in 2013 out of North Carolina, Emanuel has bounced around the league and has been with the Astros, Philadelphia Phillies, Pittsburgh Pirates, and Miami Marlins. He made his MLB debut in 2021.

What makes this move stand out is the state of Cincinnati’s pitching depth. Hunter Greene went on the 60-day IL last week after Tommy John surgery, Brandon Williamson is still working back from a shoulder issue on a rehab assignment, and Julian Aguiar, Brandon Leibrandt, and José Franco are all on the seven-day IL at Triple-A. The Reds simply do not have much impact pitching sitting around.

Williamson pitched in a rehab appearance on Sunday, which ruled him out for Monday in Cincinnati. Chase Petty had been a possible option, but he’s been used mostly as a reliever in the majors this season. Kevin Abel, Jose Acuña, and Sam Benschoter were other names who could have gotten the nod, but Emanuel brings at least some experience that the others don’t.

He’s logged big-league time with Houston in 2021 and Miami in 2024, and his career line reads 1-0 with a 4.58 ERA and 25 strikeouts. If he can cover five or six innings and limit the damage, that’s about all Terry Francona can ask for in Game 1.

The bigger picture is hard to ignore. The Reds were supposed to be in the contender conversation this season, but instead they’re sitting in the NL Central basement and have less than a 1% chance to make the playoffs. That’s the kind of roster reality that puts pressure on Nick Krall and the front office, and this latest call-up only throws it into sharper focus.

In Other News...

Reds Suddenly Have More Riding On Tyler Stephenson Than Expected

Alfredo Dunos injury has changed the Reds catching outlook faster than anyone expected. The organizations top catching prospect hurt his right hamstring in late July and could miss the rest of the minor-league season, leaving Cincinnati with a thinner pipeline at a position it had hoped would get steadier as the year went on. For a club trying to line up its long-term roster, that puts more attention on Tyler Stephenson, who remains the most established catching option in the system.

Stephenson is also moving toward free agency, which makes the timing awkward for the Reds. With Duno sidelined and no obvious immediate successor ready to take over, the front office suddenly has to think beyond the next few months and decide whether to keep Stephenson in place, add a veteran stopgap, or both. However they handle it, the injury has turned the catching position into a much bigger offseason question than it looked like a week ago. [Read more 🡒]

Reds Doubleheader Loss Just Triggered A Roster Question Fans Didn't Expect

The Reds first game of Tuesdays doubleheader in St. Louis had all the feel of a missed opportunity, with Cincinnati falling 2-1 after managing only three hits. Rhett Lowders recent rough patch continued, while Andre Pallante kept the Cardinals in control, extending the contrast between a young starter trying to settle in and a veteran who has been far steadier this season.

The roster fallout came quickly after the game, too, as Cincinnati moved on from Kent Emanuel and filled that spot with Zach Maxwell. It is the kind of mid-doubleheader shuffle that can get overlooked in the rush of a long day, but for a team trying to sort out its pitching picture, it adds another layer to a loss that already raised more questions than it answered. [Read more 🡒]