The Cincinnati Reds made their choice clear ahead of the series opener against the Los Angeles Dodgers: Ke’Bryan Hayes is back, and Edwin Arroyo is headed to Triple-A Louisville.
Cincinnati activated Hayes from the 10-day injured list and optioned Arroyo out, a move that lands as a blunt message to the young infielder. The Reds brought Arroyo back to the majors last month after Hayes went on the IL with a groin injury, but the return trip didn’t go the way Arroyo needed it to.
In six games since coming back, Arroyo managed just 1-for-18 and struck out seven times. Across the season, he has appeared in 50 major league games and is hitting .223/.266/.264. For all the contact he’s made in the minors this year, he still hasn’t hit his first big league home run, even after blasting 15 in Triple-A.
Cincinnati had options when it came time to clear space for Hayes. The club is carrying three catchers, and Will Banfield has not started since August 23 and is 0-for-4 since his call-up. But the Reds chose to move on from Arroyo instead.
That decision also reflects the way Juan Brito has played since arriving earlier this month. The former Cleveland Guardians infielder has gone 4-for-14 in four games, has two extra-base hits, and has already connected for his first major league homer. Brito can handle multiple spots on the field, and at the moment he has taken over the role that had been sitting there for Arroyo.
It would be a stretch to say Arroyo has been completely Wally Pipp’d by Brito, but the rookie has not done enough in his brief time in the majors to hold the staff’s trust. That doesn’t mean the Reds are done with him - he’s still just 23 years old - but another chance may not come until spring training next year.
For Arroyo, the takeaway is straightforward. Most rookies don’t light it up right away, and he’s now got a clearer picture of what has to improve if he wants to make it back in 2027. His 39.7% chase rate is a problem, and pitch recognition looks like the obvious place to begin.
In Other News...
Reds Just Added Outfield Insurance For A Stretch Run Concern
The Reds added a little more outfield depth this week by signing veteran Dominic Fletcher to a minor league deal, a move that gives the organization another experienced option as the stretch run begins to come into focus. Fletcher, who last appeared in the majors in 2025, had been in Triple-A with the Pirates before exercising a release clause to make the jump to Cincinnati.
For a club trying to stay protected against the wear and tear of a long season, these are the kinds of low-risk additions that can matter later. Cincinnati still has Elly De La Cruz anchoring the conversation on the field, with the star shortstop turning in a strong season and ranking near the top among MLB shortstops and Reds position players in a number of performance categories, but the front office clearly is still looking for ways to keep the roster flexible if the outfield picture gets tighter. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Face An Elly De La Cruz Decision They May Not Win
Elly De La Cruz has already become the kind of player who forces a franchise to think bigger than its usual comfort zone, and Joey Votto only added to that conversation by floating the idea that the Reds young star could someday command a deal on the scale of the sports biggest superstars. The speculation is easy to understand when you factor in De La Cruzs age, his defensive value and the kind of impact he has already shown, but it also underscores just how rare that financial tier is in Major League Baseball.
For Cincinnati, the question is less about whether De La Cruz belongs in that conversation than whether the club can realistically stay in it. Only a tiny handful of players have ever signed contracts in that range, and the Reds would have to navigate not just the size of the eventual number, but everything it would mean for the rest of the roster and the organizations long-term planning. De La Cruzs current contract situation leaves the door open for all of that to come into focus sooner rather than later, even if the final answer still feels a long way off. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Fans Have A New Ownership Rumor To Watch
The recent sale of the Los Angeles Angels has stirred up more than one ripple around baseball, and Cincinnati is now part of the conversation. According to MLB insider Bob Nightengale, rival owners believe the Reds could be the next club on the market, a notion that immediately gets attention in a city where the Castellini familys stewardship has long been a source of fan frustration.
There is still no official indication that the Reds are actually for sale, which is why the rumor lands more as a sign of league chatter than confirmed reality. Even so, the speculation adds another layer to a franchise that has spent years trying to convince its followers that better days are ahead, while executives continue to face the same underlying question every big-market team does when ownership talk starts to circulate: what happens next, and who decides it? [Read more 🡒]