Noelvi Marte’s path in Cincinnati has taken another sharp turn, and the latest comments from the Reds’ front office only make his future look murkier.
What once appeared to be a clean move into right field has become a messy slide backward. Marte shifted from third base to right field in the middle of the 2025 season and, for a while, it looked as if the job might be his long term.
He even had a “season-saving” moment against the Pittsburgh Pirates, stealing a home run from Bryan Reynolds. Marte finished that season with a .263/.300/.448 line and 33 extra-base hits, then arrived at Spring Training expecting to be Cincinnati’s everyday right fielder.
That plan never got off the ground. Marte scuffled in camp, and Terry Francona questioned his work ethic. After a little more than 30 at-bats and uneven playing time early in the season, the Reds optioned him to Triple-A Louisville.
He hit his way back. But the production in Louisville didn’t carry over once he returned to the majors. By August, he was back in Triple-A, and Francona again made it clear that the issue went beyond the box score.
"I said, ‘This is kind of a pivotal time for you,’" Francona told MLB.com's Mark Sheldon. "’Don’t just go down.’
He’s probably going to find ways to get hits in Triple-A. I said, ‘You’ve got to play with some urgency and get after it.
Be the first one out there. Don’t be the last one out there.
Take charge in the outfield, things like that.’”
Francona’s message pointed to the details around the edges - the sort of habits and daily standards that can decide whether a player sticks. He doubled down on that point when he described Marte’s broader challenge.
“He has all the tools to be an everyday player," Francona said. "Saying that, when you’re playing every day, you’ve got to find a way to help the team win.
And it’s not just getting hits. It’s playing the position.
It’s just being accountable for many different things. He was just having a tough time by his own admission.”
By the time the season ended, Marte’s numbers had cratered. He finished at .189/.229/.321 with 13 extra-base hits in 63 games with the Reds.
On Thursday morning, Phil Castellini, Nick Krall, and Brad Meador met with the media and reviewed the 2026 season. Krall, in particular, was strikingly direct about Marte.
"Noelvi Marte was bad," Krall told Charlie Goldsmith of Charlie's Chalkboard. "We should have sent him down earlier than we did."
Krall’s assessment stood out even more when set next to his comments on TJ Friedl, who also struggled.
"Friedl didn’t work out. He lost some athleticism and struggled to do what he did in 2025. We’ve got to improve the roster first and foremost.”
The repeated criticism from both Krall and Francona suggests there may be something more going on with Marte than a simple slump. Whatever the exact explanation, the Reds’ public comments make it hard to ignore how sharply their view of him seems to have shifted.
Krall did offer one note of hope, though it came with a clear condition.
“If he can get the ball in the zone, he has a chance to be an impact player,” Krall said. “But unless he can do it, he has got to figure out how to get the ball in the zone and swing at quality pitches.”
For now, Marte looks like a player whose margin for error in Cincinnati has all but disappeared. It would not be a surprise if he has already worn a Reds uniform for the last time.
In Other News...
Reds Roster Purge Just Took Another Hit Fans Will Notice
The Reds kept reshaping their roster fallout from the 2026 season, clearing two more 40-man spots in the process. Infielder Ivan Johnson was outrighted to Triple-A Louisville, while injured slugger Michael Toglia was claimed off the roster by the Seattle Mariners through waivers, continuing a steady wave of turnover as Cincinnati works through its offseason decisions.
Will Bensons situation added another layer to the shuffle, with the outfielder electing free agency after being designated for assignment and previously accepting a Triple-A assignment. For a club that already knows it needs better depth across both the position-player side and the pitching staff, these moves only sharpen the sense that the Reds are heading into a winter defined by more change than stability. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Just Added Another Offseason Roster Question In The Outfield
Will Bensons time in Cincinnati appears to have run its course after a season that never quite found a stable rhythm. The outfielder split time between the major league roster and the minors, spending 51 games with the big club and another 66 in the system while his playing time bounced around and his results varied depending on the pitcher in front of him.
For the Reds, Bensons departure adds another offseason question to an outfield group that still needs clarity. He arrived with the promise of building on a strong 2023, but he was unable to sustain that production, and his decision to elect free agency leaves Cincinnati to sort out what comes next in a spot that already felt unsettled. [Read more 🡒]
Reds May Need These 3 Prospects More Than Anyone Realizes
The Reds are headed into an offseason where the payroll math matters as much as the roster depth chart, with salary commitments and arbitration raises already tightening the teams free-agent flexibility. That puts an even brighter spotlight on the farm system, where a few names are starting to look less like long-term projects and more like possible answers if Cincinnati wants to stay competitive without spending heavily on outside help.
Graham has made a noticeable offensive leap and could be in line for protection from the Rule 5 Draft, while Duno keeps standing out with the bat even as questions remain about whether he can hold up defensively. Acuna is still earlier in his climb, but the young pitcher is moving through the minors with enough promise to keep the Reds interested, especially if the command keeps improving. By 2027, one or more of these prospects could matter a lot more to Cincinnati than they do right now. [Read more 🡒]