FanSided MLB insider Robert Murray didn’t sugarcoat the Cincinnati Reds’ trade deadline at all.
On a podcast appearance with Just Baseball Media, Murray said the deadline was hard to make sense of from the outside, and even harder when he relayed how other front offices viewed it. Asked about the Reds’ offseason plans, he said, "You're leading me down a rabbit hole. Their deadline was the most confusing by far."
Murray then added that the reaction around the league was blunt. "Every executive, and this is no exaggeration when I say this, every executive was absolutely befuddled with what they did and didn't do," Murray said.
"It was bizarre. Like, Tyler Stephenson - their asking price was way too high - and there were teams openly mocking them for it."
He also pointed directly to the need for Cincinnati to make smarter decisions around its core this offseason, finishing with, "They need to learn from their mistakes this past deadline, because that was, that was bad."
The report lands as a brutal hit to the Reds’ front office, especially after a deadline that already felt like a missed opportunity to many fans. Murray’s comments suggest the confusion wasn’t just local frustration - it was widespread across the league.
One of the biggest questions centered on Stephenson, who is a free agent after the season. The Reds held onto him even though the trade market was looking for catching help. Cincinnati also declined to move Brady Singer before the August 3 deadline, and Brock Burke stayed put as well.
That left plenty of questions about the club’s approach. Either Terry Francona persuaded the organization that this year’s team still had a real shot at the playoffs, or the front office simply misread the market. Either way, the deadline came and went without the kind of moves many around the league expected.
The broader issue now is trust. Murray’s reporting paints a picture of a front office that other executives didn’t take seriously in deadline talks, and that’s a damaging look for Nick Krall and company heading into the offseason. Krall’s contract situation remains unclear, though he did receive an unspecified extension in 2023.
For now, the Reds are left with the fallout from a deadline that drew heavy criticism internally and externally, and Murray’s comments only sharpened the spotlight on how the organization handled it.
In Other News...
Reds Were Caught In An Umpire Strike Zone Disaster At Wrigley
A rough night behind the plate at Wrigley Field put the strike zone back in the spotlight for the Reds, and it was Bill Miller who ended up at the center of it. In a game against the Cubs, Miller went 0-for-8 on Automated Ball-Strike challenges, with every one of those calls overturned, a stunning showing that stood out immediately as the worst by any umpire since the challenge system was introduced this season.
For Cincinnati, the frustration was about more than just one unsettled game. Miller has already had a controversial run-in with Reds players in the past, and this latest episode only added to the sense that the margins around the plate can still swing a night in a hurry, even with ABS now there to keep things in check. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Taking A Surprising Late Season Approach With Chase Burns
Chase Burns will keep taking the ball for the Reds the rest of the season, even with arm fatigue and a career-high workload hanging over him. Cincinnati has decided against shutting him down early, choosing instead to monitor his innings and pitch counts while letting the young right-hander continue building through the final stretch.
Burns also added a little more context to why this matters to him now, pointing to the uncertainty around the 2027 season and the possibility of a lockout. For a Reds club trying to balance present-day caution with long-term development, the decision keeps Burns on his current routine and gives the organization a clearer look at how he handles a full season's grind. [Read more 🡒]
Chase Burns Gets A Big Cubs Test With His Reds Momentum On Edge
Chase Burns is set for a prime-time assignment at Wrigley Field, drawing the Chicago Cubs on NBCs Sunday Night Baseball as the Reds look to steady a starter who has been one of their most important arms this season. Burns has put together a 14-3 record with a 2.77 ERA, and the matchup gives Cincinnati a chance to see how he handles one of the tougher road environments in the sport.
The timing makes the start a little more intriguing, too. Burns will be facing the Cubs for the first time in his career after his last trip to the mound went poorly against the Giants, when he allowed five runs over 3 2/3 innings. For a Reds team trying to keep his momentum intact, this feels like more than just another turn through the rotation. [Read more 🡒]