The Reds have already made one coaching decision, but the bigger question is the one they still haven’t answered.
On Thursday, Cincinnati said pitching director Derek Johnson will not be back in 2027. That leaves director of hitting Chris Valaika as the obvious name fans are watching next, especially after a rough 2026 season that went sideways on both sides of the ball.
The organization has been moving at a different pace than several other clubs around the league. The Angels started their changes earlier this season by dismissing pitching coach Mike Maddux.
The Mariners went further on Monday, parting with manager Dan Wilson and four members of his coaching staff. The Royals also made a move this week, re-assigning hitting coach Alec Zumwalt to the minor leagues.
Cincinnati, meanwhile, has already said Terry Francona will return as manager for the 2027 season. The front office leadership is also staying in place. But that stability only sharpens the pressure on the coaches after a season in which the Reds struggled badly at the plate and on the mound.
Johnson’s exit had been hanging out there since June, when he took an indefinite leave of absence. Assistant pitching coach Matt Tracy and bullpen coach Oscar Marin stepped into his role during that stretch, and both now look like logical candidates to handle the pitching staff next season.
Nick Krall addressed Johnson’s departure this way: “Derek Johnson took a personal leave of absence in June of this year and will not be returning. We wish Derek and his family the best. A search for a new pitching coach will begin immediately.”
The numbers on the mound showed a staff that improved after the change. Before Johnson’s leave, Reds pitchers were at 7.89 K/9, 4.68 BB/9 and 1.44 HR/9.
They were striking out only 19.8% of hitters and walking nearly 12%. After Tracy and Marin took over, the strikeout rate rose to 8.29 K/9, walks fell to 3.95 BB/9 and home runs dropped to 1.28 HR/9.
The overall strikeout rate moved up to 20.7%, while the walk rate dipped to 9.9%.
The offensive side gives Valaika even less room to breathe. Cincinnati hit 136 home runs, good for fourth-most in the majors behind only the Cubs, Astros and Mets.
But the power didn’t carry the rest of the lineup far enough. The Reds still finished with the fourth-fewest runs in baseball at 402.
The rest of the offensive profile was ugly. Cincinnati ranked seventh in slugging percentage, but also 16th in walks, 27th in RBI, 28th in on-base percentage, 29th in wRC+, and dead last in batting average, doubles and strikeout rate.
It’s the second straight year Valaika has been unable to lift the offense into the top tier. And with no announcement yet on his status, every quiet day only feeds the same question: is another coaching change coming, or are the Reds content to let this version of the staff roll on?
In Other News...
Reds Have A Bigger Lineup Problem Than Fans Realized
The Reds offensive issues in 2026 were deeper than a simple slump, and the numbers made that clear. Cincinnati finished 27th in runs scored even with a relatively high home run total, a sign the lineup could still leave the yard but often failed to string together the kind of production that actually turns power into innings and wins.
KeBryan Hayes became one of the clearest examples of how uneven the roster looked, turning in historically poor offensive numbers by modern standards. More broadly, the problem was one of construction as much as execution, with a collection of one-dimensional players who underwhelmed in different ways at the plate, in the field and on the bases, leaving the Reds with a lineup that never quite fit together. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Linked To A Cheap Upside Bet Worth Watching
Nolan Jones is back on the free-agent market after spending the 2026 season in the minors with Seattles Triple-A affiliate, and the profile still makes him an interesting name for clubs looking for inexpensive upside. A former second-round pick and once-regarded top prospect, Jones has already shown he can help at the major league level, most notably during a strong rookie season with the Rockies in 2023, even if his follow-up has been more uneven.
For a team like the Reds, that kind of background can be enough to merit a closer look. A minor-league deal with a spring training invite would fit the usual low-risk, high-reward lane for a player trying to reboot his value, and Cincinnati has every reason to keep tabs on that sort of opportunity as it looks for depth without blocking its better long-term bets. [Read more 🡒]
Phil Castellini Put The Reds Biggest Leadership Problem Back In Focus
Phil Castellini, Nick Krall and Brad Meador met with the media this week to address the Reds 2026 outlook, and the conversation quickly turned to a more immediate issue: how a season that was supposed to go better ended up falling short of expectations. Castellini acknowledged as much, saying the organization needs to review every decision it made in an effort to sharpen both operations and strategy execution moving forward.
The comments also landed against the backdrop of a recent report about internal blame between the front office and ownership, which only sharpened the focus on how the Reds are actually run. For a team trying to turn the page, the bigger question may not be what gets changed first, but whether the people making those calls are aligned enough to make the changes count. [Read more 🡒]