Sal Stewart keeps putting together a rookie season that should have the award conversation locked down, yet the debate keeps drifting elsewhere.
The Cincinnati Reds’ young star has already made a few preseason NL Rookie of the Year picks look foolish, but the noise around him hasn’t gone away. St.
Louis Cardinals second baseman JJ Wetherholt opened the year as the favorite and stayed Stewart’s main competition for much of the season, though his injury effectively ended that chase. Now, with Wetherholt possibly nearing a return from the IL, the attention has shifted to a new challenger: New York Mets starter Nolan McLean.
McLean has had a strong year and looks like a promising young arm, but the idea that he belongs in the same conversation as one of the league’s best pitchers, rookie or otherwise, is a stretch. SNY in New York leaned that way, and it feels like classic homerism.
McLean’s 3.06 ERA ranks 15th among qualified big league starters, but his 3.57 FIP sits more than a half-run higher, and his 9.7% walk rate is the eighth-highest in baseball. That’s good production, not award-winning dominance.
Stewart, meanwhile, isn’t in MVP territory yet. But his rookie line belongs in a different class entirely. His season is already one of the best by a hitter in MLB history, and he has been the game’s top run producer this year despite the offensive dead weight around him.
And that’s the part some people still seem determined to overlook.
There’s clearly a segment of the audience that doesn’t want to give Stewart the award. First basemen get painted as big, slow sluggers with limited value, and that bias shows up fast when the trophies are being handed out. The same goes for the people who shrug off RBIs entirely.
Sure, RBIs are no longer treated like the gold standard they once were. That’s because a player’s lineup spot and the traffic ahead of him can inflate the number. If you keep coming to the plate with runners on, you’re going to drive in more runs than the average hitter.
But Stewart’s case goes beyond the usual stat arguments. Cincinnati ranks 27th in MLB with a .309 on-base percentage, which means he’s not constantly stepping in with the bases loaded or even regularly with traffic all over the bases. He’s simply been ruthless when the chances do come.
He’s hitting .313 with runners in scoring position, and this isn’t empty contact. His .597 slugging percentage in those spots shows he’s not just poking singles through the infield. He’s changing innings, and he’s doing it with authority.
In the end, baseball comes down to runs. Score more than the other team, and you win.
Prevent more than the other team, and you win. On that front, no rookie has done more than Sal Stewart.
That’s why he should win Rookie of the Year. Easily.
In Other News...
Reds Should Be Paying Attention To Carlos Jorge Right Now
Carlos Jorge keeps turning heads in ways that matter for a Reds organization always looking for the next useful piece. In a game against the Dodgers, the rookie outfielder made a notable catch that served as another reminder of how far he has come since Cincinnati moved him from second base to center field in 2023. The shift was a significant one, but Jorge has made it look increasingly natural while logging more than 250 games at the position.
For the Reds, his progress fits into a broader development pattern that can be hard to get right. Not every prospect who changes positions takes to it this cleanly, and the club has had its share of less successful conversions. Jorges growth is why he deserves more attention now, not just for the highlight plays, but for what he could represent if Cincinnati keeps finding value in players willing to learn something new. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Prospect Faces A Brutal Reality After Yet Another Setback
The Reds farm system has had plenty to track this September, even if the first step in the postseason has not gone the way either affiliate wanted. Daytona and Dayton both opened their league championship series with losses, which puts immediate pressure on each club as the playoffs move deeper into the week. For Cincinnati, the bigger picture still includes several prospects whose seasons have carried real meaning, from Daytonas lineup to the hitters trying to find footing at higher levels.
Ichiro Cano has been one of the more encouraging names in that group, putting together a strong year with Daytona while batting .297 with seven home runs. Ruben Ibarra also turned in a notable season by setting a career high with 22 homers for Chattanooga, while former first-round pick Austin Hendrick continues to search for traction after dropping from Triple-A to Double-A. With the affiliates fighting to extend their seasons, there is still plenty of interest in how those player arcs finish out, even if the road has already gotten a little steeper. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Front Office Debate Just Got More Uncomfortable
Baseball Prospectus did not exactly flatter the Reds when it slotted their front office 26th in Major League Baseball, dropping the club into a sixth-tier label that can only be described as a bad time. The assessment lands with a particular sting because Cincinnati has shown a real knack for developing pitching, even if the broader body of work has settled into a familiar sort of mediocrity under Nick Krall.
Since 2021, the Reds have gone 456-500, a record that says plenty about the middle ground they have occupied while trying to build something more durable. Front office rankings are never simple, especially when ownership spending limits and trade vetoes can shape the outcome as much as the baseball operations department itself, but the verdict here does not feel hard to defend. [Read more 🡒]