Reds Face A Tough Trade Call On A Former Top Pick

With the potential trade of Dylan Crews on the horizon, the Reds have a chance to strategically enhance their roster while considering the risks and rewards of acquiring a former top prospect.

The Reds have shown they’re willing to shop in the bargain aisle when the upside is real, and that approach could put them in the mix for a much bigger name this time around.

According to Spencer Nusbaum of The Athletic, Washington Nationals outfielder Dylan Crews is firmly on the trade block. For Cincinnati, that creates an interesting possibility: a former No. 2 overall pick from just three years ago who still carries plenty of upside, plus the kind of roster flexibility teams love.

But this would not be a simple low-cost flyer.

Nick Krall has found value before with buy-low bets, and some of Cincinnati’s more dependable pieces in 2026 - such as JJ Bleday and Nathaniel Lowe - came from moves that didn’t exactly set off alarms around the league. He has also landed useful players in trades like Dane Myers a year ago and Spencer Steer for Tyler Mahle at the 2022 trade deadline. Crews, though, would require a much steeper price than those kinds of deals.

Washington has been looking for controllable starting pitching, and that’s where the Reds could get pulled into the conversation. Cincinnati has arms to consider, including Rhett Lowder, Brandon Williamson and Andrew Abbott.

Lowder was taken just five picks after Crews in the 2023 MLB Draft. Moving any of those pitchers would also put more pressure on Chase Burns to handle a larger share of the rotation load.

Crews’ appeal is obvious if you believe the bat is coming. He has been limited offensively in his early MLB work, posting a 79 wRC+, but he brings strong baserunning and quality defense in the outfield. He grades as a positive defender at all three outfield spots, which would give Terry Francona real lineup flexibility.

There’s also the age and control factor. Crews is only 24, remains under team control for five more seasons, and still has two option years left.

That makes the evaluation pretty straightforward: the Reds would be betting on pedigree, tools and upside, but only if they’re convinced the hit tool will show up. Crews has the bat speed and the raw power to make the gamble worthwhile. He just hasn’t done enough damage yet to make that promise feel safe.

If the Nationals’ asking price stays reasonable, Cincinnati has a real chance to take a swing. If Washington wants controllable pitching and more, Krall may decide the risk is too heavy.

In Other News...

Reds May Have A Smarter Way To Chase Jarren Duran

Jarren Durans name has started to surface in trade chatter again, and for a Reds club always looking for ways to add impact without breaking the bank, it is the kind of possibility worth watching. Duran was coming off a strong 2024 season, but his performance has slipped since then, which has only added to the sense that Boston could be open to moving him as the Red Sox sort through roster congestion and salary concerns.

For Cincinnati, the appeal is obvious: a player with upside who could fit into a broader market that includes the Padres, Cubs, Mariners and Diamondbacks. The catch is that Durans future is still unsettled, and the Red Sox have not exactly made it simple by needing to balance their own roster priorities before deciding whether to deal him or let the market sort it out. [Read more 🡒]

Spencer Steer Just Put The Reds On A Tough Clock

The Red Soxs four-year commitment to Jake Bauers is a reminder of how much clubs still value a player who can move around the field and hold his own at the plate, and it puts a familiar type back in the spotlight for Cincinnati. Spencer Steer fits that broad description for the Reds, with the kind of versatility that lets a manager shuffle the lineup and the defensive alignment without losing much offense.

For a team trying to build around younger pieces like Sal Stewart and Chase Burns, Steer suddenly looks like the sort of player that can shape the next few seasons in more than one way. He is under club control for only two more years, which gives Cincinnati a relatively short window to decide whether his all-around profile is part of the long-term plan or a valuable trade chip if the Reds decide to keep leaning into their youth movement. [Read more 🡒]

Elly De La Cruz Just Put A Painful Reds Question Front And Center

Emilio Pagns decision to opt out of his player option and head to the Detroit Tigers is another reminder that Cincinnatis offseason is already carrying real roster questions. The Reds have more than one important piece in play, with Eugenio Surez and Tyler Stephenson among the notable free agents, while the front office also has to weigh whether it wants to push forward on extensions for younger core players such as Sal Stewart and Elly De La Cruz.

De La Cruz is the name that hangs over all of it, because the conversation around him has shifted from simple extension talk to something much more uneasy. His agent, Scott Boras, recently made clear that a long-term deal with the Reds does not look likely given the clubs financial approach, and that has only added fuel to the trade speculation already surrounding one of the sports most electric players. [Read more 🡒]