Emilio Pagan’s decision to turn down his $10 million player option and head into free agency looked like a clean break on the surface. But one Reds insider doesn’t seem ready to close the book just yet.
Cincinnati beat reporter C. Trent Rosecrans said on Sunday that he still sees Pagan as the likeliest candidate to handle the ninth inning for the Reds next season.
"If I were kind of putting odds on it, I would still give him (Pagan) the best odds," C. Trent Rosecrans said on the Riverfront Territory podcast on Sunday night.
"Emilio Pagan is a guy who is beloved in the clubhouse and front office. I think what he saw was one year, $10 million, after the season he had and how he did it, there is a good chance that is the floor."
That view makes some sense when you look at how Pagan finished. He battled a hamstring injury early, then came back on July 1 and was sharp the rest of the way, posting a 1.88 ERA over his final 30 appearances of the season.
The bigger question is whether the Reds can - or should - make him the answer again. They don’t have an obvious in-house replacement waiting to step into the role.
Brock Burke would fit, but he’s also a free agent. Luis Mey has the kind of arm that could eventually play in the ninth, but asking him to jump straight into that job would be a major leap, especially with his uneven big-league track record.
That’s why a reunion in 2027 still feels possible, even after the opt-out.
Pagan is set to turn 36 in May, and turning down a one-year, $10 million deal suggests he’s looking for something longer-term. But a multi-year commitment at more than $10 million annually for a 36-year-old closer is a tough sell, even after the way he’s pitched over the last two seasons.
And Cincinnati has plenty of other business to handle first. The Reds need help at third base, a solution at second unless they’re content to keep rolling with Matt McLain, more punch in the outfield to support platoons with Dane Myers and JJ Bleday, and possibly a catcher if Tyler Stephenson doesn’t come back. That’s before the front office even gets to the starting rotation.
With that many needs on the board, paying top dollar for an older closer may be hard to justify - no matter how well he’s liked inside the clubhouse.
In Other News...
Carlos Jorge Is Giving Reds Fans A Real Outfield Reason To Watch
Major League Baseballs Gold Glove announcement left the Reds empty-handed, but there was at least one defensive bright spot tied to the organization. Minor League Baseball recognized Carlos Jorge, who finished the year with Cincinnati, as one of the seasons top outfield defenders, a nod that gives the club something to point to even with the big-league awards coming up short.
Jorge has also carried that momentum into winter ball, where he has been producing at the plate in the Dominican Winter League. In one recent game, he piled up three hits, two steals, three runs scored and two RBIs, a reminder that his value is not limited to the glove and that his name is starting to pop in more than one setting. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Could Be Tempted By A Power Bat With Serious Risk
A winter roster squeeze in Boston has put Triston Casas in an unusual spot, and that could matter for teams looking to add left-handed power without paying top-tier prices. The Red Sox first baseman still has enough offensive upside to draw interest, but his path has been complicated by injuries and a dip in production since 2023, which is why his future is being discussed at all despite a relatively modest arbitration projection.
For Cincinnati, the appeal is obvious. The Reds have been searching for ways to deepen the lineup and could view Casas as the kind of bat that changes the look of the order if hes healthy and productive. But the risk is just as clear, because his recent track record makes him far from a clean fit, and any club that gets involved would need a backup plan in place if the gamble doesnt pay off. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Enter A Crucial Offseason With One Big Decision Looming
The offseason has arrived with plenty for Cincinnati to sort through, and the free-agent list is already long enough to make the next few days feel consequential. Tyler Stephenson, Brock Burke, Brady Singer, Emilio Pagn, Eugenio Surez and Pierce Johnson are among the names now on the market, giving the Reds a mix of bullpen, rotation and lineup questions to weigh as they map out the winter.
Carlos Jorge added a brighter note to the organizations end-of-year picture, earning a Minor League Gold Glove and getting a late-season look in the majors. The defense is clearly there, but his bat will need to take a step forward if he is going to stick, which leaves Cincinnati with another evaluation to make as the roster picture comes into focus. [Read more 🡒]