Reds Face A Risky Rotation Choice As Pressure Builds

The Cincinnati Reds are exploring their options on the free agent market, with an eye on pitcher Dustin May to bolster their rotation amid injury concerns and performance risks.

The Reds are being linked to another starting pitcher, and this one comes with both upside and baggage.

According to former MLB general manager Jim Bowden, Cincinnati is among several clubs showing interest in free agent right-hander Dustin May. Bowden said on X that May’s market is picking up, with the Reds joined by the Cubs, Nationals, Orioles, Giants, Guardians, Marlins, White Sox, and Blue Jays.

For Cincinnati, the fit makes sense on paper. The rotation took a noticeable step backward in 2026, Hunter Greene is expected to miss the entire 2027 season after Tommy John surgery, and Brady Singer is also a free agent. That leaves the Reds with real innings to replace, and starting pitching is clearly on the shopping list.

May, 29, split the 2026 season between the Cardinals and Brewers. Across 31 starts, he went 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA, 144 strikeouts, and a 1.32 WHIP.

His stint in St. Louis was the stronger of the two stops, as he put up a 4.38 ERA in 21 starts and struck out 106 batters over 109 innings.

After moving to Milwaukee, though, the bottom fell out a bit. In 10 starts there, he logged a 5.65 ERA and gave up 23 earned runs in 36 2/3 innings.

That’s not exactly the kind of line that gets a fan base buzzing.

Still, there’s at least one reason May keeps showing up in these conversations: his style. He’s long been known as a ground-ball pitcher, and that trait can play in Great American Ball Park.

But the numbers from 2026 suggest that edge may not be as sharp as it once was. His ground ball rate sat around 44% in the first half of the season, and his issues against left-handed hitters are another concern in a park that can punish mistakes in the air.

FanGraphs’ Ben Clemens projects May for a two-year, $30 million deal, which is a hefty price tag for a pitcher coming off a 4.70 ERA.

That puts Cincinnati in a familiar spot: weigh the ceiling against the floor. May has flashed real quality at times, and there’s no denying the talent is there.

But the Reds also have to decide whether bringing back Singer might be the cleaner move. Singer struggled in 2026, but he has been more dependable over the course of his career and didn’t miss a start in his two seasons with Cincinnati.

May may offer the higher ceiling. Singer may offer the steadier hand.

And with Greene sidelined, the Reds need innings badly enough that both paths are on the table. The question is whether they want the safer bet or the bigger swing.

In Other News...

Reds Face A Tough Trade Call On A Former Top Pick

The Reds are weighing a familiar kind of front-office gamble: whether to buy low on a former elite draft pick whose value still rests more on projection than production. Dylan Crews, the former No. 2 overall selection, is drawing trade interest from Cincinnati after flashing the kind of defense and baserunning that can help a contender right away, even if the bat has not yet caught up in his brief major league stint.

For a Reds club that has tried to balance present needs with long-term depth, the question is not just whether Crews can hit enough to justify the move, but whether the price makes sense. A deal would likely require significant pitching prospects, which puts Cincinnati in the uncomfortable spot of deciding how much future talent it is willing to sacrifice for a player whose ceiling is still obvious, even if the offensive track record is not. [Read more 🡒]

Reds May Have A Smarter Way To Chase Jarren Duran

Jarren Durans name has started to surface in trade chatter again, and for a Reds club always looking for ways to add impact without breaking the bank, it is the kind of possibility worth watching. Duran was coming off a strong 2024 season, but his performance has slipped since then, which has only added to the sense that Boston could be open to moving him as the Red Sox sort through roster congestion and salary concerns.

For Cincinnati, the appeal is obvious: a player with upside who could fit into a broader market that includes the Padres, Cubs, Mariners and Diamondbacks. The catch is that Durans future is still unsettled, and the Red Sox have not exactly made it simple by needing to balance their own roster priorities before deciding whether to deal him or let the market sort it out. [Read more 🡒]

Spencer Steer Just Put The Reds On A Tough Clock

The Red Soxs four-year commitment to Jake Bauers is a reminder of how much clubs still value a player who can move around the field and hold his own at the plate, and it puts a familiar type back in the spotlight for Cincinnati. Spencer Steer fits that broad description for the Reds, with the kind of versatility that lets a manager shuffle the lineup and the defensive alignment without losing much offense.

For a team trying to build around younger pieces like Sal Stewart and Chase Burns, Steer suddenly looks like the sort of player that can shape the next few seasons in more than one way. He is under club control for only two more years, which gives Cincinnati a relatively short window to decide whether his all-around profile is part of the long-term plan or a valuable trade chip if the Reds decide to keep leaning into their youth movement. [Read more 🡒]