Doing more with less has become the Reds’ central challenge, and if Cincinnati wants a blueprint, the Brewers are sitting right there in the same division.
Milwaukee and Cincinnati are almost mirror images when it comes to spending. The Reds’ payroll counts $150.8 million toward the luxury tax threshold, which ranks 19th in baseball, while the Brewers sit just behind them at $144.4 million.
But the results haven’t been close. Milwaukee has reached the postseason in seven of the last eight seasons.
Cincinnati has gotten there only twice in the last 12 campaigns.
One of the biggest differences has been the Brewers’ willingness to lock up young talent early. Jackson Chourio was the headline case, landing an eight-year, $82 million deal before he even made his major league debut. Milwaukee has kept pushing that approach this year, too, with extensions for No. 4 overall prospect Cooper Pratt and, most recently, No. 5 prospect Luis Lara.
Lara’s deal is the one that really stands out. It comes with a $31 million commitment over seven years, and three club options can push it to $79 million. Even then, the Brewers aren’t losing much by skipping the usual pre-arbitration savings, because those costs are already built into the contract.
That kind of move is exactly why Alfredo Duno is worth watching in Cincinnati.
The Reds’ No. 1 prospect fits the profile of a player who could force the issue before he ever debuts in the majors. Duno is a powerful, patient hitter with a feel for the strike zone that stands out for his age. If he reaches his ceiling behind the plate, he’s the kind of catcher who could eventually command a massive payday.
He’s still only in High-A, though his production in Dayton suggests he may not be there for long. The 20-year-old has double-dingers dingers and a 15.4% walk rate. The main offensive concern is that his strikeout rate has climbed back to 27% after dropping to a career-best 18.4% last year in Daytona.
The next stop looks like Double-A, and Triple-A could come as soon as the end of this season, though 2027 is the more realistic timeline. Once he gets a taste of the minors’ highest level, the Reds should be thinking seriously about an extension.
Cincinnati already missed that window last year with Sal Stewart and Chase Burns. Extensions are still possible for both, but their performances in the majors have already changed the price tag.
With Duno, the Reds still have a chance to get ahead of the curve. There’s obvious risk, especially with a big-bodied catcher who is more exposed to injury than most.
But the upside is hard to ignore. A long-term deal now could give Cincinnati a bargain that frees it up elsewhere and pays off in a major way down the line.
In Other News...
Reds Could Be Heading Toward A Nathaniel Lowe Deadline Decision
The Reds are entering the deadline stretch with one of their more interesting roster questions centered on Nathaniel Lowe, a left-handed power bat who has quickly become a notable trade piece. Jeff Passans ranking of Lowe among the top 100 trade assets only adds to the sense that Cincinnati could have real leverage here, especially if the front office decides it wants to cash in on value rather than simply hold steady.
Michael Toglia gives the situation an internal layer worth watching. The former Rockies first-round pick has been productive in the minors and could be the kind of in-house option the Reds turn to if Lowe is moved, giving the club a chance to replace power without going outside the organization. Whether that becomes the plan may depend on how Cincinnati defines itself over the next few days, since the deadline still leaves open the possibility of a move in either direction. [Read more 🡒]
Carlos Jorge Just Gave Reds Fans Another Reason To Start Wondering
Carlos Jorge has been pushing his way into the conversation for a while, and the Reds moved him again as part of the latest wave of prospect promotions. The outfielder went from Double-A Chattanooga to Triple-A Louisville, a sign that his bat has kept forcing the issue as he continues climbing through the system. Jos Acua and Johnathan Lavallee also got the call to Louisville, giving the Bats a little more organizational traffic on a busy development day.
Jorges appeal has been obvious to anyone tracking the minors: a strong batting average, a lively OPS and enough production to earn Southern League Player of the Week honors for May 26-31. He has also already shown he can rebound from a scary collision with the outfield wall last year, which only adds to the intrigue around how far his momentum can carry him now that he is one step closer to the majors. [Read more 🡒]