The Reds’ offense has been a mess all season, and the problem is now staring Nick Krall and the front office right in the face: Ke’Bryan Hayes and Matt McLain have become a roster headache Cincinnati can’t ignore.
By the numbers, the lineup has gone nowhere. Cincinnati ranks 27th in runs scored, and its 87 wRC+ sits dead last. That’s the kind of production that leaves little room for patience, especially when two everyday players are dragging things down at the same time.
Hayes and McLain have combined for -0.3 fWAR, and both are carrying OPS marks below .600. That’s a brutal return from two players who were supposed to help keep the offense afloat, not weigh it down.
If the Reds were drawing up a clean solution, Hayes would be the obvious name to move. The 29-year-old is in the worst season of his career, posting a .453 OPS and 19 wRC+ across 190 plate appearances.
Even the defense that usually keeps him on the field has slipped some, with career lows in Outs Above Average at 2 OAA and Defensive Runs Saved at 5 DRS. Injuries and limited playing time have played a part, but the standard for Hayes is simple: if he’s not delivering Gold Glove-caliber defense, he’s hard to justify.
The problem is the contract. Cincinnati still owes him $23 million through 2029, which makes him nearly impossible to trade. Unless ownership shocks everyone and approves an unconditional release, Hayes looks stuck in Cincinnati.
McLain presents a different kind of dilemma. His season has also been rough, even though he’s managed to reach double-digit home runs and steals for the third straight year and has been trending up lately.
Still, the big picture has been ugly. After a dynamic debut in 2023, his value has cratered, and his batting average is barely above the Mendoza Line.
That’s left him with a disappointing 79 wRC+.
Unlike Hayes, McLain still brings real trade appeal because of his glove. He’s a strong defender at second base, sitting at 7 OAA, and he also comes with three years of arbitration remaining.
There would be teams willing to take that shot. But Cincinnati would be selling low, and the return would reflect how much his bat has slipped.
So the Reds are stuck trying to fix second and third base without many clean answers. Hayes is effectively unmovable because of the money, while McLain can only be dealt for pennies on the dollar. The club can choose to bet on one or both bouncing back offensively, but that’s the same gamble that has already buried the bottom of the order this season.
It leaves Krall and the front office with a difficult offseason problem and no easy way out.
In Other News...
Several Reds Enter September With Their 2027 Future Suddenly In Doubt
September is arriving with a lot more uncertainty than the Reds probably expected, because several players who were supposed to help define this stretch are now fighting for their place in the clubs longer-term plans. TJ Friedl, Ke'Bryan Hayes, Sam Moll, Michael Toglia, Noelvi Marte, Connor Phillips and Brandon Williamson are all in the spotlight for the same reason: their 2026 production has not matched the kind of value the organization needs, and that puts real pressure on the final weeks of the season.
The Reds are not just sorting out the present tense here, they are staring at a 2027 offseason that could bring significant roster decisions. For some of these players, a strong finish would help steady the conversation and buy more time; for others, the combination of performance and contract considerations could leave the front office weighing changes sooner rather than later. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Suddenly Face Another Lineup Concern With Michael Toglia
Michael Toglias brief run with Cincinnati hit another snag this week when the Reds put him on the injured list retroactive to Aug. 22 after he dislocated his right shoulder in a game. The move forced the club to turn to Triple-A Louisville for depth, with infielder/outfielder Ivan Johnson coming up to fill the roster spot.
Terry Francona said there is some optimism around Toglias recovery, though the next round of testing will help determine how soon he can move forward. For a Reds team trying to keep its lineup intact down the stretch, any absence in the middle of the order or on the bench can complicate the day-to-day mix, and this one now leaves Cincinnati waiting on a clearer timetable. [Read more 🡒]
Hunter Greenes Injury Just Changed The Reds KeBryan Hayes Reality
Hunter Greenes Tommy John surgery leaves the Reds staring at a rotation problem that stretches well beyond this season. Cincinnati knew it would need answers on the mound, but losing Greene for the rest of 2026 and likely 2027 changes the timetable in a major way, especially with payroll still carrying his salary and more financial decisions looming around other key players.
That context also helps explain why KeBryan Hayes now looks far more likely to stay in Cincinnati in 2027. The Reds have to balance innings, commitments and roster flexibility, and with Greene sidelined, the path of least resistance may be keeping Hayes in place rather than creating another need they do not have to address. [Read more 🡒]